-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Katsuki Bakugou Minor Downgrade
- Thread starter Damage3245
- Start date
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #83
Therefir, how is Howitzer Impact suggested to be higher than 8-B. Bakugou cannot tank his own 8-B explosion.
He needs the gauntlets to protect himself.
He needs the gauntlets to protect himself.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #86
Aren't the OVA's only canon to the anime?
And just because he needs to charge the attack doesn't mean it is higher than 8-B. It could just be a higher version of 8-B than his other explosions.
And now that we've settled that Bakugou's ordinary huge explosions are High 8-C. We need to agree that the explosions Bakugou used on Uraraka were weaker than that are it is much more likely that she has either 9-B or 9-A durability.
EDIT: If your suggestion was: At least High 8-C+ normally, 8-B with Howitzer Impact, that'd be better.
And just because he needs to charge the attack doesn't mean it is higher than 8-B. It could just be a higher version of 8-B than his other explosions.
And now that we've settled that Bakugou's ordinary huge explosions are High 8-C. We need to agree that the explosions Bakugou used on Uraraka were weaker than that are it is much more likely that she has either 9-B or 9-A durability.
EDIT: If your suggestion was: At least High 8-C+ normally, 8-B with Howitzer Impact, that'd be better.
- 9,629
- 8,663
Well, the creator of the manga worked on the OVA's.
I prefer: "At least High 8-C+ normally, 8-B with his strongest explosions" (The fodder villain was close to High 8-C+, and Bakugou is stronger now.)
I do not know about Uraraka, it's hard to think that Bakugou was holding back that much against her.
I prefer: "At least High 8-C+ normally, 8-B with his strongest explosions" (The fodder villain was close to High 8-C+, and Bakugou is stronger now.)
I do not know about Uraraka, it's hard to think that Bakugou was holding back that much against her.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #89
> I do not know about Uraraka, it's hard to think that Bakugou was holding back that much against her. It's not hard at all. They were fighting in a tournament match, and it's not like fighting Uraraka is like fighting All Might. Using his maximum-power explosions is risky to itself and potentially lethal to other people.
Both Deku and Uraraka up to the point of the Sports Fest have only been hit by attacks that were much weaker than Bakugou's maximum-power explosions. It is more consistent for the verse that her durability be somewhere in the range of 9-B to 9-A.
The generous calc gives High 8-C+ for one of Bakugou's maximum-power explosions. That suggests to me that Bakugou's normally explosions are consistently High 8-C+ which makes sense in the series. That his special moves like Howitzer Impact are 8-B is justifiable from that.
Both Deku and Uraraka up to the point of the Sports Fest have only been hit by attacks that were much weaker than Bakugou's maximum-power explosions. It is more consistent for the verse that her durability be somewhere in the range of 9-B to 9-A.
The generous calc gives High 8-C+ for one of Bakugou's maximum-power explosions. That suggests to me that Bakugou's normally explosions are consistently High 8-C+ which makes sense in the series. That his special moves like Howitzer Impact are 8-B is justifiable from that.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #91
Deku directly compares Bakugou's maximum-power explosion with the one from the end of his fight with Uraraka.
And if you consider 'actual Bakugou' to be different from the one in the touranment, then that's additional reason to downgrade Uraraka's durability.
EDIT: I don't see what's wrong High 8-C+ normally, and 8-B with his special moves.
Bakugou pretty much confirms that the explosion which was calced to be High 8-C+ (which is very generous given that's the evaporation result) is his maximum power and when he's not doing any super moves.
And if you consider 'actual Bakugou' to be different from the one in the touranment, then that's additional reason to downgrade Uraraka's durability.
EDIT: I don't see what's wrong High 8-C+ normally, and 8-B with his special moves.
Bakugou pretty much confirms that the explosion which was calced to be High 8-C+ (which is very generous given that's the evaporation result) is his maximum power and when he's not doing any super moves.
- 9,629
- 8,663
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #93
If that calc gets an evaluation and redone, I'd be interested in seeing the result.
EDIT: Therefir, mentioning that everyone in the verse scales from it still doesn't sit right with me because of how baseless that is.
EDIT: Therefir, mentioning that everyone in the verse scales from it still doesn't sit right with me because of how baseless that is.
- 9,629
- 8,663
AidenBrooks999's suggestion:
"Maybe we could something like:
9-B for the likes of Quirkless Deku and others
9-A+ scaling from deku taking Muscular's casual hits and his finger flicks (So this would scale to Bakugou and Todoroki)
I think Deku's 100% punching through severals floors and Bakugou's big explosion I calcd once at 8-C, so you have that. (Also, we have a crater 100% deku did against Chisaki)"
"Maybe we could something like:
9-B for the likes of Quirkless Deku and others
9-A+ scaling from deku taking Muscular's casual hits and his finger flicks (So this would scale to Bakugou and Todoroki)
I think Deku's 100% punching through severals floors and Bakugou's big explosion I calcd once at 8-C, so you have that. (Also, we have a crater 100% deku did against Chisaki)"
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #95
That sounds pretty reasonable. Where did he suggest that?
- 10,758
- 6,491
- 5,141
- 290
I'm not sure tho.Andytrenom said:
It look like it was just "dramatic effect" or something and they came after the explosion rather than taking it
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #98
I agree. None of them look like they were caught in the explosion; it was just thier way of making a dramatic entrance into the exam.
EDIT: "Also, we have a crater 100% deku did against Chisaki" Which moment was this? When he kicked himself out of the underground base?
EDIT: "Also, we have a crater 100% deku did against Chisaki" Which moment was this? When he kicked himself out of the underground base?
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #100
What kind of hero and his subordinates would get caught in an explosion to make an entrance, rather than just waiting for the explosion to go off and then enter through the hole it left behind? Doesn't that just seem like poor planning?Andytrenom said:
There's also the fact that none of them look like they were in an explosion; no smoke, no burn marks, no superficial damage. I think you're reading too much into the panel of them being close to the wall.
@Therefire, his 1,000,000% is just a stretched out 100%.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #102
Okay, but at the same time we don't actually see them take the explosion, or ultimately how close they really were.
So there's no proof they tanked the explosion either.
EDIT: We don't even see if that wall/door in front of them is the same wall that explodes.
So there's no proof they tanked the explosion either.
EDIT: We don't even see if that wall/door in front of them is the same wall that explodes.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #103
It just doesn't look like a viable feat to me.
Anyway, @AidenBrooks999 , is what Therefire said what you're suggesting? Because I'm inclined towards that suggestion and we can start figuring out what profiles need to be updated.
Anyway, @AidenBrooks999 , is what Therefire said what you're suggesting? Because I'm inclined towards that suggestion and we can start figuring out what profiles need to be updated.
- 9,629
- 8,663
If this feat is higher than the explosion one then is consistent and can be used.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #105
Does that character have a profile?
- 9,629
- 8,663
Nope, but just in case, he actually needs that durability to use that attack, so I guess his quirk works like One For All.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #107
Isn't that just the aftershocks affecting him? Not the full shock of the super move.
Anyway, that look like an solid High 8-C feat for him in terms of destructive power at least.
Anyway, that look like an solid High 8-C feat for him in terms of destructive power at least.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #108
I'm pretty sure the manga would also make it clear that Gang Orca was inside the explosion if that's what happened. His clothes aren't even slightly damaged, singed or marked in any way.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #109
Being beind the wall doesn't mean he took the brunt of the explosion. It's a bad feat overall because we don't see it onscreen and there are plausible alternatives.
Anyway, shall we make a list of which profiles are in need of revising? Quirkless Deku and everyone that scales to him is a good place to start.
Anyway, shall we make a list of which profiles are in need of revising? Quirkless Deku and everyone that scales to him is a good place to start.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #110
The character and his subordinates you're talking about don't appear to actually be inside the explosion. No sign of it on his clothing. No indication of damage to any of them. No reason for them to actually be in the explosion other than the interpretation that they must be standing near to it.
We see a single panel of them close to a wall. For all we know they all took cover during the explosion itself and then came out once the hole had been made.
We see a single panel of them close to a wall. For all we know they all took cover during the explosion itself and then came out once the hole had been made.
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #112
Good to know. Are you going to put in a calc request for it?
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #113
It's not just that he isn't burned, it's that the scenario makes no sense in the first place. What possible reason could he have to go to the centre of the explosion in a controlled exercise for a Hero exam?
They could have been waiting behind the wall simply because that's their place to be when it goes down, and when the explosion is ready to go off, they sensibly move back to a safe distance. What's wrong with that?
EDIT: Can we drop this Gang Orca stuff? It's not relevant to the thread.
They could have been waiting behind the wall simply because that's their place to be when it goes down, and when the explosion is ready to go off, they sensibly move back to a safe distance. What's wrong with that?
EDIT: Can we drop this Gang Orca stuff? It's not relevant to the thread.
- 10,758
- 6,491
I am not going to drop this completely, but I will for this thread at least.
- 5,141
- 290
Like I said in other thread, I'm really busy with high school and college stuff, but I want to take in tjis subject as soon as possible
- 5,141
- 290
I have a bunch of BNHA calcs that i neve posted because they... well, weren't too imprssive for the scaling.
Mostly 9-A to 8-C. And a few High 8-C to 8-B
Mostly 9-A to 8-C. And a few High 8-C to 8-B
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #117
I feel like those calcs may come in handy if we're having to re-evaluate the majority of MHA profiles.
- 5,141
- 290
But I think that a consistency like this one, 8-A for Todoroki may fall a bit stretchy to even become an outlier if you ask me
- 31,208
- 27,406
- Thread starter
- #119
8-A may be a bit too inconsistent, but Todoroki himself is sort of accepted as an outlier in his own class. He has a hybrid of two strong Quirks and uses them to perform incredible, visible feats; he was even the only left standing in a clash between himself and 100% Deku.
8-B might be a more reasonable rating for him, but whether he ends up with either 8-B or 8-A may be fine. (In terms of AP, not durability).
8-B might be a more reasonable rating for him, but whether he ends up with either 8-B or 8-A may be fine. (In terms of AP, not durability).
