Kinda is as explained earlier
I am pretty sure the lower version of the calc is just as valid
Assuming you're talking about the 60m/s. If so, then no Its been addressed multiple times.
And why would this scale to anyone exactly?
Hanami did this while suppressed, not only that large scale attacks like this are slower than his smaller scale ones. Yuji and Todo dodged both types.
Okay no one scales to sukuna also why is sukuna speed value getting a multiplier?
Not true. Toji in Shibuya by Megumi is stated to be equal if not faster than this Sukuna and while slower that MEgumi still reacts and dodges those Toji's attacks.
RW, unless he is 100 times faster than megumi
I'm pretty sure Dr white has countered that, if not fair point.
Seen an accepted lower value
Also no way he is 3 times faster than lightning.
Also why is this using cloud to ground lightning speed instead of electricity in the air speed?
These have been repeatedly showing to use lower level electricity speeds which have been explained as why it isn't and scales to real lightning.
This will be calc stacking since it uses the reactions of maki, someone whose speed is currently contested and the author thinks is below SOS
uses normal human speeds...
Pick one calc you cannot send many calcs for the same feat, anyway
1. The speed used for the bullet here is 450m/s, it is rubber bullet, that is impossible
2. She is 5 meters away watching someone point a gun at her, this is easily aim dodging as you can see her body move.
Same feat different interpenetration, this is one that she reacted further back. It shows cases that feat is still supersonic. As I've stated multiple times, even subbing the 220 rubber bullet speed it is still supersonic.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
This is not a feat at all.
"Readers eyesight" this makes no sense.
On top of that, this isn't accepted, nor is it even evaluated by CGMs.
Its said to be accepted by the calc creator so ask him about that. I'm taking it for it says. Also its been explained before how subsonic feats are not supportive in this as characters are also afriad of subsonic speeds.
Beautiful.
Why does this scale to anybody's combat or reactions?
Bone to pick too. The frame shows that by the first frame, the attack is already there. It wasn't just rising from under, it was already there.
So the timeframe is wrong.
Hanami did this while suppressed, not only that large scale attacks like this are slower than his smaller scale ones. Yuji and Todo dodged both types.
Curse Blitz
Subsonic+ calc. Not bad, doesn't support the superiority to sound point.
Personal issue of speed, it being superhuman is something I dislike, since a lot of these spirits on the lower end of the spectrum (Grade 4) don't show anything close to superhuman.
As said before, also this feat is only 2 times slower than a top speed Naoya.
15 finger Sukuna
Why does this scale to anybody?
3 finger Sukuna feat and Toji in Shibuya by Megumi is stated to be equal if not faster than this Sukuna and while slower that MEgumi still reacts and dodges those Toji's attacks.
I tackled this already. The assumption of his body being straight isn't logical, which is why I made my new calc.
This was countered, not only that speed was also explained to be wrong before and shown multiple times why its lightning speed which still resulted in Mach 500ish with this method.
Idk why this is accepted for 0.1 seconds. The timeframe we use for reactions is 0.2.
explained in calc.
Why are the maki feats supposed to be support to the narrative of MHS Maki (on the profiles)? Isn't this a downgrade?
Explained before, characters being Massively Hypersonic besides god tiers is false.So the idea we want them being MHS is not true. They're Supersonic in goodwill at least.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I am actually briefly coming out of wiki hiatus to counter most of these feats. Some of which I had problems with way before I went on said hiatus.
First one I am surprised as **** that using readers perspective (?????) was an acceptable calc to do.
Second one we cant see the hand she used to calc the bullet we have to idea how close it is. The distance the bullet is to her head also changes between when it is about to hit her and when it finally hits.
Third one uses anime, then uses manga and with the anime shot we cant even see wtf is happening due t blur, it can even be argued that the tree was already coming out before the "focus" was on it. Not to mention no one even scales to it.
Fourth one in the manga panel, it is not even moving. In the anime one we dont know where his arm is before it attacks.
Fifth one Sukuna could have come from any direction and snuck up on Megumi. Also the distance in the second one is 420 m they literally could not have seen Sukuna with eyesight.
Sixth one, there is a delay before the explosion, one that the target is already reacting to.
Seventh one, I dont think he actually dodged it. It is more than likely that it was already fired forwards and his left shoulder was the easiest target. He ooks surprised, not like he dodged it. In fact, the next time, he is unable to doge and has to heal himself despite the blast coming
head on at a greater distance.
Eight uses 0.1 seconds just because.
Last one has the same problem as the second.
Allegedly Accepted.
The hand was to her side and had moved from their to swipe the bullet of the way. This was discussed in the thread before these ones.
Anime images or times have been allowed as long as they aren't contradictory in portrayal, which it isn't, not only that there have been multiple statements regarding anime-manga being linked.
Again like the one above, the manga shows the arms right next to his head, and as before anime has been allowed to fill things for manga in calcing feats.
This is unlikely as there is nowhere else expect from where Sukuna could have come from, not only that Megumi didn't sense him until he was behind. This also takes less assumptions and Sukuna shows to blitz him while they fight he arrives.
I think this was was addressed above.
This isn't true and doesn't look anything like it. We see directly in front of his and that he pivots down to his right when it does hit him. Not only that but hits further away on him upper arm and not shoulder.
It uses human reaction speeds despite them already being above that so, its abit of a low ball.
Last one is a further away interpretation instead of in front of the face, and as explained for 2 the same thing.
Some of these things have been already been argued in the first thread prior to these two.
