Getbackers: Terrible Profiles, NLFs and Unjustified Profiles.

[Firephoenixearl]

Not really.

Then ask away. That's what im here for.

 

[Hl3_or_bust]

all of you inital issues were debunked to my knowledge, and several people have come forward, having read GB, and support the current ratings

 

[The_Tetromino_King]

It seems Fire was right even though when someone said he couldn't be trusted because of the Medaka Box nonsense before.

This thread could be closed.

 

[Warren_Valion]

Like I said again, I question pretty much everything, which is why I'm waiting for Griffin's reading.

You guys are forgetting this ^

He's waiting for a source that he trusts to show him the proof he wants. That's why this thread has lost traction. Reading and evaluating a series properly takes time.


And besides, there were people who know GB, that came up and said that MOST things are alright.

I just finished reading Getbackers and I can vouch that most of the abilities the characters have is okay. However, a lot of things are wrong for the archiver profile...

That indicates that there are problems, possibly numerous ones, with the profiles and interpretations. And those need to be fixed.


Stop trying to rush or stop a revision of a verse. It takes time to make sure things are up to a standard that we try and achieve on the wiki.

 

[Hl3_or_bust]

just because Matt trusts someone does not make their opinion anymore valid than anyone elses

dude, he literally only says that he has issues with the Archiver profile

 

[The_Tetromino_King]

It doesn't matter if Matt trust someone, pretty sure alot of people here now can vouch for Fire claims.

Close this.

 

[Ogbunabali]

Revisions aren't done on a popularity contest.

 

[Warren_Valion]

When a person has a history of overinflating a character or verse to beyond the level they actually are, their credibility is diminished. Waiting for others to either prove that person right or show that they are wrong is a logical next step.

And what? Did we read the same quote?

"I just finished reading Getbackers and I can vouch that most of the abilities the characters have is okay."

Most.

As in not all.

And this goes for all the characters, not just The Archiever.

The users biggest problems are with The Archiever, however.

 

[Hl3_or_bust]

then 99.9% of all CRTs need to be redone if the opinions of anyone other than an Admin don;t count or matter

 

[Hl3_or_bust]

When a person has a history of overinflating a character or verse to beyond the level they actually are, their credibility is diminished. Waiting for others to either prove that person right or show that they are wrong is a logical next step.
And what? Did we read the same quote?

"I just finished reading Getbackers and I can vouch that most of the abilities the characters have is okay."

Most.

As in not all.

And this goes for all the characters, not just The Archiever.

The users biggest problems are with The Archiever, however.

this is not Medaka Box. That argument holds no weight and is basically an insult against Fire

ok? You act like every profile will have massive changes. At the absolute best, you're right, but it's more reasonable to say that it;s a case of semantics

 

[LordGriffin1000]

There is actually a big problem with Akabane and Ban's Logic Manipulation that I'll deal with when I'm finished.

You guys read the damn manga but you didn't take into account one thing "Consistency". Close this thread as their is no point in keeping it open right now because I'm not finished. I'll create another one when I'm ready.