Garou Lifting Strength Calc Discussion

[Veronica]

Moon level Garou? Let's go!

 

[KLOL506]

Moon level Garou? Let's go!

in b4 "Even the Class Z calc and 5-C calc are mathematically incorrect" BS pops up and this never ends.

 

[Chariot190]

in b4 "Even the Class Z calc and 5-C calc are mathematically incorrect" BS pops up and this never ends.

Sounds like the average Tuesday for OPM tbh.

 

[XSOULOFCINDERX]

Sounds like the average Tuesday for OPM tbh.

OPM can never catch a break.

 

[Kachon123]

OPM can never catch a break.

Fr. It's really annoying.

 

[Spinoirr]

Better writing and all it cost was a low 5-B feat

 

[KLOL506]

in b4 you get a Tier 3 feat out of this.

 

[Phoenks]

We are 100% getting a higher feat before the arc ends. That much feels expected.

 

[RatherClueless]

Gone for 1.5 days and this turns into a huge mess.

I'll write a proper reply tomorrow. Way too much to go through to write a reply at 3AM.

 

[Kachon123]

I'll write a proper reply tomorrow. Way too much to go through to write a reply at 3AM.

This thread should be closed. Don't waste your time. The Class Y feat was axed with the redraw, so we can only use the Class Z feat, which is already on the page.

We have already voted that the feat is valid, so any further arguments will just be ignored. I'm trying to get a staff member to close this.

 

[LaserPrecision]

Doesn't that seem a bit unfair? Just to just cut off the thread and not allow someone to express further contentions they have with the feat. I feel if this were the other way around (I.e. the feat being legit was the unpopular vote) you'd want more time to explain. I think you should at least give them one more day to explain themselves.

 

[Kachon123]

Doesn't that seem a bit unfair? Just to just cut off the thread and not allow someone to express further contentions they have with the feat. I feel if this were the other way around (I.e. the feat being legit was the unpopular vote) you'd want more time to explain. I think you should at least give them one more day to explain themselves.

We've had the feat being valid for a while now. Rusty even gave up arguing because they wouldn't change their minds. The vote has ended, and the feats are valid. It has been hours since we moved on to the next topic, and CGM, other Staff, and Users have already voted on step 2 as well.

We are done debating that topic. This can be closed. If they have any other issues, they can make another CRT, though I doubt it would get any different result from this.

 

[Therefir]

Yeah no, I definitely don't agree with having a CTR put on hold when we have all put our interpretation of the feat on the table, and the most accurate one has been that it can indeed be considered a lifting strength feat.

As for me, I don't plan to change my opinion any time soon, and TheRustyOne said that as well.

The Class Y feat is no longer canon until further notice, and the Class Z is already on the profiles, so there no longer a decision to make, I will ask Antvasima to close this.

 

[Magmag]

Doesn't that seem a bit unfair? Just to just cut off the thread and not allow someone to express further contentions they have with the feat. I feel if this were the other way around (I.e. the feat being legit was the unpopular vote) you'd want more time to explain. I think you should at least give them one more day to explain themselves.

The feat that is valid has been accepted and discussed for the past 6 days with the same contention discussed over and over with no progress made. I mean waiting is fine but there aren’t any new points to be made, nothing about the feat has changed since 2 weeks ago.

 

[Therefir]

Doesn't that seem a bit unfair? Just to just cut off the thread and not allow someone to express further contentions they have with the feat. I feel if this were the other way around (I.e. the feat being legit was the unpopular vote) you'd want more time to explain. I think you should at least give them one more day to explain themselves.

Yeah no, I definitely don't agree with having a CTR put on hold when we have all put our interpretation of the feat on the table, and the most accurate one has been that it can indeed be considered a lifting strength feat.

As for me, I don't plan to change my opinion any time soon, and TheRustyOne said that as well.

The Class Y feat is no longer canon until further notice, and the Class Z is already on the profiles, so there no longer a decision to make, I will ask @Antvasima to close this.

 

[Kachon123]

I will ask Antvasima to close this.

Thank you.

 

[Nierre]

I was gonna say the same thing but seems like Kachon and Therefir beat me to it

EDIT: and magmag

 

[Magmag]

EDIT: and magmag

You’re gonna make me cry Nierre

 

[LaserPrecision]

Yeah no, I definitely don't agree with having a CTR put on hold when we have all put our interpretation of the feat on the table, and the most accurate one has been that it can indeed be considered a lifting strength feat.

As for me, I don't plan to change my opinion any time soon, and TheRustyOne said that as well.

The Class Y feat is no longer canon until further notice, and the Class Z is already on the profiles, so there no longer a decision to make, I will ask @Antvasima to close this.

I guess that's fair. I don't disagree with the use of the calc myself, I just felt instead of cutting someone off briefly, we should let them give their final take on the manner. Otherwise it might result in a CRT from them or some other type of thread when it could've been taken care of here.

If the thread needs to be closed, than so be it. Just wanted to try and be fair to the opposing side.

 

[Tural2004]

OPM can never catch a break.

Being a popular verse is hard

 

[KLOL506]

@LordTracer You know what to do fam.

 

[LordTracer]

Clooooosing.