- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #321
Already answered above about....4(?), maybe 5 times.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Fu Xiaoli vs Rimuru
- Thread starter Firephoenixearl
- Start date
- 2,447
- 166
If your talking about this:
Because I already answered it. There is something happening to Rimuru due to desperado and I fail to see nothing happening to him. Like the moment Rimuru act to challenge Fu, the fate thing triggers showing Rimuru the truth of its death. Btw, I don't see the truth of its death happening because is impossible to achieve, naming one scenario on how Rimuru dies is impossible due to his physiology which are his regeneration, resistances, abilities, etc. It's nlf to assume that it will work, but let's say Rimuru does get incapped, Raphael is there.
I don't really see a scenario where you think Fu will win sorry. I just failed to see it
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #323
No, I don't mean that. You quite literally made the exact same argument before and I answered it.
- 2,447
- 166
Well I'll just find it tomorrow (or more depending on my schedule) since I'm gonna sleep now.
It would help quoting it since I've arrived late into the discussion and only looked the arguments present after I've joined
It would help quoting it since I've arrived late into the discussion and only looked the arguments present after I've joined
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #325
Nah dawg. The answer im talking about is an answer i made to your post.
- 173
- 21
Wow, this is train wreck. I doubt that this is going to go anywhere. .-.
Last edited:
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #327
Well, you got that right.
- 15,713
- 7,692
Correct me, if I wrong, I guess Earl's counterpoint is that Rapheal won't be able to see a future where Rimuru doesn't die from the fate manipulation so it would hesitate in its decision to protect Rimuru.
My view is that even in this case Raphael will still try to win to do something as I said earlier. In character, it makes less than Raphael would literally do nothing at all. I still think Raphael would try to fight to Rimuru's wish and win the fight; there is precedence that Raphael still tries to follow Rimuru's wishes in the series when Rimuru is out of commission.
My view is that even in this case Raphael will still try to win to do something as I said earlier. In character, it makes less than Raphael would literally do nothing at all. I still think Raphael would try to fight to Rimuru's wish and win the fight; there is precedence that Raphael still tries to follow Rimuru's wishes in the series when Rimuru is out of commission.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #329
Rimuru won't be out of commission though. If it's gonna follow Rimuru's wish it's not gonna fight. Cus Rimuru will not want to fight someone who will instantly kill him.
- 15,713
- 7,692
If it's gonna follow Rimuru's wish it's not gonna fight. Cus Rimuru will not want to fight someone who will instantly kill him.
- Since near the end of his first key, Rimuru is willing to fight anyone that could kill him; even he can't defeat them, Rimuru is willing to try to do lasting damage to his opponents. So, I think this point is a poor counterpoint to say Rimuru will not fight someone that can kill him instantly or not.
- If Rimuru was like a standard MC with no elaboration on his death mindset in battle, I would have been more willing to agree on the point.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #331
I've explained so many times i've lost count by now. "could" die and "will" die are 2 different things.
- 15,713
- 7,692
The difference doesn't matter much, in this case; in short, Rimuru is willing to fight even if he could or will die. Raphael is highly likely to respect his wish, on the matter.
Edit: Sorry for the confusion, I should have included the "will" die case earlier.
Last edited:
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #333
When though? There is almost never a case where death is guaranteed against an opponent. And most ppl with the protag mindset would just say "as long as the possibility exist i will pull it off etc etc". I would need to see a case where Rimuru goes in a fight that meant certain death.
- 15,713
- 7,692
It is just a mindset thing that Rimuru acquired needs the end of his key.
The case I know where it is largely implied is Rimuru's fight against the Empire since he got Great Sage that can make accurate predictions in all battles from its abilities; the Empire has multiple characters way stronger and many other comparable to him. It was pointed out, Rimuru still fought even though he was scared.
I think I bring some scans later.
I will be honest, I am somewhat confused by the point. Is the question, in essence, Rimuru or Raphael will not fight at all if Rimuru is scared because I notice this fight doesn't have the SBA condition? The answer is like no. Rimuru has a high resistance to fear anyway if we treated the fear as just being from an ability.
If this fight has SBA, I think the "scare" point likely won't matter.
The case I know where it is largely implied is Rimuru's fight against the Empire since he got Great Sage that can make accurate predictions in all battles from its abilities; the Empire has multiple characters way stronger and many other comparable to him. It was pointed out, Rimuru still fought even though he was scared.
I think I bring some scans later.
I will be honest, I am somewhat confused by the point. Is the question, in essence, Rimuru or Raphael will not fight at all if Rimuru is scared because I notice this fight doesn't have the SBA condition? The answer is like no. Rimuru has a high resistance to fear anyway if we treated the fear as just being from an ability.
If this fight has SBA, I think the "scare" point likely won't matter.
Last edited:
- 15,765
- 5,678
Very significant chance this match may not happen anymore as Rimuru is getting upgraded to 6-A.
- 15,918
- 2,680
- 15,765
- 5,678
As all things are. I think his first key might be 6-C though? I dunno.
- 15,765
- 5,678
Nearly a week later, and I found something that renders all of our arguments fairly meaningless.
Rimuru himself admits to not caring about if he dies or not, after being hit with an instant death attack with Raphael active.
So, yeah, uhh... He sees his fate, decides to go through with it, and EE's.
Rimuru himself admits to not caring about if he dies or not, after being hit with an instant death attack with Raphael active.
So, yeah, uhh... He sees his fate, decides to go through with it, and EE's.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #339
That is severely off context.
1. He wasn't scared of dying in a fight not that he'd willingly throw his life away for no reason cus why not. Knowing an ability can kill you and knowing that you will definitely die in a fight are different things as i said.
2. He was worried about his friends, again altruism, not crackhead energy.
3. He knew he wouldn't die from it from what Raphael told him.
1. He wasn't scared of dying in a fight not that he'd willingly throw his life away for no reason cus why not. Knowing an ability can kill you and knowing that you will definitely die in a fight are different things as i said.
2. He was worried about his friends, again altruism, not crackhead energy.
3. He knew he wouldn't die from it from what Raphael told him.
- 15,765
- 5,678
What do you mean severely off context, that's the full scene.
No, he literally says he is not afraid of dying. He knows he's in a fight when he senses her intent, and then the death images go in. He is not afraid to die.
Are his friends in this match or something...?
You're actually making up stuff that isn't there, because Raphael told him about her Holy-barrier, he analyzed Greedy One. Death Wish was a Unique Skill, Rimuru has an Ultimate Skill, and as such, lower skills (the former) won't work on him.
So yeah, he is not afraid of dying, so I still keep my vote for Rimuru.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #341
Yes, doesn't mean he's just gonna throw his life away for no reason.
Precisely they aren't. Which is why he won't really have a reason to die.
- 15,765
- 5,678
Hold on, hold, hold. So, do these images of death exist or not? Yes, or no? Similarly, if yes, I want you to give scans, because now I'm rather skeptical on this whole "true vision of death thing".
I have literally no idea what you are talking about. He had no fear of dying because he had already died before, he was only scared of his friends dying from that attack because he knew they couldn't survive it like he could.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #343
They are real futures. They are the future that will materialize if you challenge a desperado. However they will not materialize unless you challenge the desperado. It's basically Alternate Future Display.
- 15,765
- 5,678
Can I see scans?
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #345
Scans of what?
- 15,765
- 5,678
These characters seeing these futures if they fight a Desparado.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #349
Smh
- 15,765
- 5,678
Thanks. Alright, so now that we've established Rimuru had no fear of dying, and his only fear was his friend's dying (which they aren't here), I see no reason why it doesn't end here.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #351
As i said though, not being scared of death doesn't mean he'd throw his life away. He has no reason to initate the fight.
- 15,765
- 5,678
He senses her intent, as we've established earlier, and then fight starts.
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #353
What would that do?
- 15,765
- 5,678
Did you not say that her Desparado aura/passive activates once you sense their intent, and previously used that as an argument to say Rimuru gets incapped?
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #355
Yeah. But i don't get the whole "fight starts". Why would the fight start? I feel like we skipped a buncha steps. How did Rimuru get over the fear of death?
- 15,765
- 5,678
Because he isn't afraid of dying, as I've provided with scans...?
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #357
- 15,765
- 5,678
We keep going in circles. He senses her intent, death images follow, Rimuru shrugs it off, he kills her.
- 15,713
- 7,692
Okay, in the end, the points look to be: will Rimuru still fight even he knows he will lose or would lose?
Note that the fatehax can't kill Rimuru so the "will" instance is false, in this case.
The evidence in the Light Novel points to yes, overall. We already have evidence that Raphael will follow Rimuru's wishes, also.
Earl, you look to be the only one who thinks Rimuru will not take action because of fear of death; I am specifically talking about his personality. I don't think the counterarguments were fully debunked on this point. At this point, I would say leave the points to being voted by the others where the consensus will be based on the stronger arguments.
Note that the fatehax can't kill Rimuru so the "will" instance is false, in this case.
The evidence in the Light Novel points to yes, overall. We already have evidence that Raphael will follow Rimuru's wishes, also.
Earl, you look to be the only one who thinks Rimuru will not take action because of fear of death; I am specifically talking about his personality. I don't think the counterarguments were fully debunked on this point. At this point, I would say leave the points to being voted by the others where the consensus will be based on the stronger arguments.
Last edited:
- 20,504
- 1,587
- Thread starter
- #360
Do you not get my point though?
He is not scared of dying, not he wants to die. He realizes that he will die if he starts the fight. Why would he start that fight? Not being scared to die would apply if there was any reason to pick up the fight in the first place.
Him picking up the fight means he is throwing his life away? Why would he do that? He is not in a scenario where death is unavoidable, so why would he put himself in that situation?
He is not scared of dying, not he wants to die. He realizes that he will die if he starts the fight. Why would he start that fight? Not being scared to die would apply if there was any reason to pick up the fight in the first place.
Him picking up the fight means he is throwing his life away? Why would he do that? He is not in a scenario where death is unavoidable, so why would he put himself in that situation?
I don't "think" though, i argue.
Similar threads
- Locked
