No, what you listed was mostly just a bunch of meaningless promotional hype. Donny Cates isn't an absolute authority on Marvel Comics either.
I won't comment on Invincible and LEGO stuff, I'm not all that knowledgeable on them though I still highly doubt they are canon.
Not an indication that the crossover is canon or that DC and Fortnite share a cosmology.
How does this mean the crossover is canon, let alone that Fortnite and DC share a cosmology.
This is literally all meaningless promotional hype.
Isolated statements of a few writers for DC that consider the crossover to be canon are absolutely not an indication of a shared cosmology. Even taking these statements at face value doesn't indicate the crossover is canon on both sides and trying to cross scale the cosmologies or any characters is even more egregious.
Again, just meaningless promotional hype. It doesn't matter how much the crossover is advertised, that does not mean it is canon.
These do not indicate canonicity at all. Every crossover ever can be considered a combination of two worlds.
The story of Creation in Fortnite is that everything was made from the Zero Point. In DC, it's different. Simple as that.
There is no shared continuity.
The Zero Point being mysterious doesn't prove anything.
Batman has stated that many things are "outside of reality", "beyond the multiverse", and similar statements before. This doesn't prove anything.
No, this has not been agreed upon.
You should really do that now so that we can be sure you are not trying to scale Fortnite characters to egregiously high tiers like High 1-A.
No, what you listed was mostly just a bunch of meaningless promotional hype. Donny Cates isn't an absolute authority on Marvel Comics either.
I won't comment on Invincible and LEGO stuff, I'm not all that knowledgeable on them though I still highly doubt they are canon.
- You are proving my point. If only the author says its Canon, its a problem because he apparently doesn't have authority over his work or its impact (even though that is not how the comic book industry works at all).
- But if the Company itself says it, its apparently only promotional material and cannot be true at all. Because apparently everything they say is just for hype. because apparently statements cant be both promotional and true at the same time. Because apparently Companies are supposed to just stay silent and not say anything during an event that is special because it is driven by the fact it is canon because apparently anything they say during that is just hype and promo and not valid at all. And apparently everything is a promo window despite that not being how promo works.
- And even if the SVP, the EIC and the CCO involved all agree and state it is an authentic and Canon event, it doesn't matter because their word apparently means nothing at all despite being the highest authority in Creative Directory and Story. Righ right, it all makes sense.
- And I don't know if this is just me but, when I see something I am not knowledgeable in, I usually tell the other person that and not just assume they're wrong with no basis. Maybe its just me...
Not an indication that the crossover is canon or that DC and Fortnite share a cosmology.
- That is a introduction dude.
How does this mean the crossover is canon, let alone that Fortnite and DC share a cosmology.
- If you look at the format of the post, I introduce the material first then go over how its Canon. That is an introduction to the material involved.
This is literally all meaningless promotional hype.
- Right because you have absolute authority above Jim Lee and other DC creative team members to the point where you can just dismiss their statements about their own Continuity as just meaningless promotional hype.
Very nice argument dude.
Isolated statements of a few writers for DC that consider the crossover to be canon are absolutely not an indication of a shared cosmology. Even taking these statements at face value doesn't indicate the crossover is canon on both sides and trying to cross scale the cosmologies or any characters is even more egregious.
- Don't just gloss over them, adress them.
- And you realize this isn't just "a few DC writers", this is also by Jim Lee himself. he is the highest authority on DC dude.
- And again, "Even taking these statements at face value doesn't indicate the crossover is canon on both sides." Read their statements, they are telling its canon and takes place in the main Continuity.
Again, just meaningless promotional hype. It doesn't matter how much the crossover is advertised, that does not mean it is canon.
- Again, no reason given as to why that is the case and why both cannot be true at the same time. You're just throwing that word around and hoping it lands.
These do not indicate canonicity at all. Every crossover ever can be considered a combination of two worlds.
- I would agree except for the fact it is stated by Jim Lee himself and also because other crossovers are stated or shown to take place outside the main Continuity.
- Here, if you actually read the statements I posted you would know that the main driver for this Crossover was to tell an authentic Batman story in the main Continuity and have him use his detective skills in the World of Fortnite.
- They are literally yelling at your face that it is canon and takes place in the main Continuity.
The story of Creation in Fortnite is that everything was made from the Zero Point. In DC, it's different. Simple as that. There is no shared continuity.
- I would agree if it wasn't for the fact that Scott Snyder himself wrote The Zero Point to be source of everything and The Creator as well.
- That is the reason for this post; To find a solution that isn't just ignoring Authoritative figures regarding the two Cosmos.
The Zero Point being mysterious doesn't prove anything.
- No reason given as to why. If you're just going to keep sending messages with no reasoning then you are just taking spaces and getting nowhere. Provide reasoning.
- That was just a possible solution I came up with. My reasoning behind it is that since The Zero Point is a mystery, it would be excluded from the statements that would cause problems.
- This would allow for the two cosmos to co-exist with the bridger being the Tier 0.
Batman has stated that many things are "outside of reality", "beyond the multiverse", and similar statements before. This doesn't prove anything.
- Ok so what if he has before? what does that have to do with this? You're lack of providing reasoning is making it very hard to understand what you are trying to say.
- And yes, it does prove The Zero Point and its creation are outside the Multiverse, that much is clear so I don't know what you are talking about.
No, this has not been agreed upon.
- You might not agree but everyone else at DC fandom sure does.
- And this was another possible solution . It would be appreciated if you provided one (without ignoring authority for no reason).
You should really do that now so that we can be sure you are not trying to scale Fortnite characters to egregiously high tiers like High 1-A.
- I will later.
- What would even be the point to you? You've already made up your mind (no reason given) that they're not Canon so why does it even matter to you?
- Do you only care about gatekeeping the Tiers or do you actually care about Authenticity and what the actually creators and companies are saying is Canon to their storyline?
- If you actually care about being Authentic, we can continue. If you only care about the tiers while dismissing the truth about the Canon then I get it and we can drop this.
