Fire Force 3-A Adolla CRT

[Maitreya12]

Bump

If you want an update on the current situation I’m gonna be first fixing some of these fire force profiles cause they’re all like missing a few things and after that I’m gonna be making an upgrade CRT for the scaling.

I’ll post the blog for the CRT here before I make the thread public.

 

[Excellence616]

If you want an update on the current situation I’m gonna be first fixing some of these fire force profiles cause they’re all like missing a few things and after that I’m gonna be making an upgrade CRT for the scaling.

I’ll post the blog for the CRT here before I make the thread public.

Okay

 

[Halkum145]

Have you come to a conclusion on this issue?

 

[Alexander]

Have you come to a conclusion on this issue?

no

 

[Halkum145]

no

Will a new topic of discussion be opened?

 

[Alexander]

Will a new topic of discussion be opened?

maybe

 

[Dalesean027]

This thread has been rejected since months ago why is it still open?

 

[Alexander]

This thread has been rejected since months ago why is it still open?

because people are not gonna closed,because no one called a mod.

 

[Dalesean027]

Just gather evidence for tier 4 in the discussion thread since there's a precedence for that but this tier 3 had been rejected so I'm going to request this be closed

 

[ObberGobb]

I don't think it was ever officially rejected. It just kinda died.

 

[Dalesean027]

I don't think it was ever officially rejected. It just kinda died.

No it was it literally had 4 staff disagree
Post in thread 'Fire Force 3-A Adolla CRT' https://vsbattles.com/threads/fire-force-3-a-adolla-crt.143346/post-5178300

 

[ObberGobb]

What exactly were the debunks though? Staff haven't even commented on the last several pages.

 

[Dalesean027]

What exactly were the debunks though? Staff haven't even commented on the last several pages.

Because Its been rejected since page like 2 or 3 so they haven't needed to say anything more

Go back and read

 

[Alexander]

So as I said, make another thread

 

[Dalesean027]

So as I said, make another thread

Just discuss and gather evidence in the general discussion first and I'd say go for tier 4 in the next crt if one is made

 

[Alexander]

Just discuss and gather evidence in the general discussion first and I'd say go for tier 4 in the next crt if one is made

why not the 3-A again?

 

[Dalesean027]

why not the 3-A again

Keep going for 3-A firce force and there will eventually be a discussion rule put in place if its rejected again and again

At least some staff agreed with some tier 4 stuff you could at least be willing to compromise. You guys's unwillingness to compromise here was what got this entirely rejected to begin with. Tier 4 has precedence and 3-A frankly doesn't have as much

 

[ObberGobb]

I don't see anything wrong with putting out another 3-A thread with better arguments and no derailing

 

[Alexander]

The thing is that with 3-A that is much more logical, considering the nature of the series at that point.
level 4 is only one and it is not even to say that literally all the stars in the universe must have been affected.
and that is for the tier 4,there is more tier 3 that tier 4

 

[CurrySenpai]

At this point just compile the new evidence/arguments and make a new CRT lol. Just close this one already.

 

[Maitreya12]

Will a new topic of discussion be opened?

I’m planning on making the CRT probably this week.

I’ve just been updating the profiles for right now cause they’re missing things like references, explanations, or links for certain abilities.

Dw the fire force revisions are coming

 

[Maitreya12]

Keep going for 3-A firce force and there will eventually be a discussion rule put in place if its rejected again and again

At least some staff agreed with some tier 4 stuff you could at least be willing to compromise. You guys's unwillingness to compromise here was what got this entirely rejected to begin with. Tier 4 has precedence and 3-A frankly doesn't have as much

Dude I’ll be frank. That cause no staff would engage with the arguments. There was just a statement saying it was tier 4 but no reasoning was given as to why that is as opposed to universal. The arguments were just ignored.

There doesn’t need to be a “compromise” if the position is simply wrong. Tier 3 has precedence. Not only is it outright stated but it’s directly shown as well. Tier 4 doesn’t make sense in this context. In the slightest. That’s why saying “compromise” doesn’t really mean anything because the compromise doesn’t make any sense here.

 

[Dalesean027]

Dude I’ll be frank. That cause no staff would engage with the arguments. There was just a statement saying it was tier 4 but no reasoning was given as to why that is as opposed to universal. The arguments were just ignored.

There doesn’t need to be a “compromise” if the position is simply wrong. Tier 3 has precedence. Not only is it outright stated but it’s directly shown as well. Tier 4 doesn’t make sense in this context. In the slightest. That’s why saying “compromise” doesn’t really mean anything because the compromise doesn’t make any sense here.

@LordGriffin1000 @KingTempest and @Qawsedf234 all provided some input and shared agreement to the points @Pain_to12 and @Cyberblader90 made thus disagree with tier 3.

It needs to be structured and argued severely better than it was here to have any precedence is all I'm saying, tier 4 is a guarantee if you argue it and at least KingTempest even acknowledged that (4-A)

Do way better than here and for sure I'm all for it

 

[Maitreya12]

Yeah I looked over the thread and I didn’t find any reasoning given as to why 4A was taken over 3A by staff and some feats were just entirely not discussed at all or taken into account. I don’t think they necessarily agreed with the counter position either since the counter position was only for a planetary range but in the end it was decided to go for a 4A range.

Either way Imma just structure the next CRT very crucially in that I’m gonna make sure I heavily emphasize the universal feats in the series. So it does not get bogged down like this one.

 

[Alexander]

Yeah I looked over the thread and I didn’t find any reasoning given as to why 4A was taken over 3A by staff and some feats were just entirely not discussed at all or taken into account. I don’t think they necessarily agreed with the counter position either since the counter position was only for a planetary range but in the end it was decided to go for a 4A range.

Either way Imma just structure the next CRT very crucially in that I’m gonna make sure I heavily emphasize the universal feats in the series. So it does not get bogged down like this one.

ok

 

[Antvasima]

I was asked to close this thread as it has been rejected already.

https://vsbattles.com/threads/all-purpose-request-thread-new-forum.107534/post-5383832