- 6,605
- 4,155
Since making a revision for the whole verse take times, I just wanted to quickly talk about the note on Feathrine profile:
To summarize; it's about "Feathrine not being a Creator", however there's 2 problem with this note:
1- It's said that the japanese version says otherwise, however the link supposed to prove it is the english one. It's already kinda weird I think.
2- Umineko TIPS explain that Creators are Witches above Voyagers. In case you think it's a case of "there's no plural", the TIPS also said that they're called Gods by Voyagers, and it's how Lambdadelta call them in her memoirs. It's also logic with Maria being on "the path of the Creator" .
The only difference is that Feathrine didn't losed her sense of self/meaning, but she can't maintain it without her device. So she can somehow be considered below the other Gods? It wouldn't change a lot without a true revision anyway.
Now, we can also question the fact that the Creator wasn't mentionned as a single entity any time in the whole verse; and like the note says it "Japanese has no plural", meaning it can be in fact just refer to the collectivity of Gods or to the title of Creator (singular/plural in japanese depend of the context/what is the subject).
In short:
Feathrine's note should disappear, since she's indeed "a Creator", going by TIPS' descriptions and the narration.
The existence of "The Creator" as a single entity should be discussed, and if it is agreed to not be a single entity, then its page should be deleted.
I'm planning to make a revision for the whole verse when I have time, but I think this can easily be solved separately.
To summarize; it's about "Feathrine not being a Creator", however there's 2 problem with this note:
1- It's said that the japanese version says otherwise, however the link supposed to prove it is the english one. It's already kinda weird I think.
2- Umineko TIPS explain that Creators are Witches above Voyagers. In case you think it's a case of "there's no plural", the TIPS also said that they're called Gods by Voyagers, and it's how Lambdadelta call them in her memoirs. It's also logic with Maria being on "the path of the Creator" .
The only difference is that Feathrine didn't losed her sense of self/meaning, but she can't maintain it without her device. So she can somehow be considered below the other Gods? It wouldn't change a lot without a true revision anyway.
Now, we can also question the fact that the Creator wasn't mentionned as a single entity any time in the whole verse; and like the note says it "Japanese has no plural", meaning it can be in fact just refer to the collectivity of Gods or to the title of Creator (singular/plural in japanese depend of the context/what is the subject).
In short:
Feathrine's note should disappear, since she's indeed "a Creator", going by TIPS' descriptions and the narration.
The existence of "The Creator" as a single entity should be discussed, and if it is agreed to not be a single entity, then its page should be deleted.
I'm planning to make a revision for the whole verse when I have time, but I think this can easily be solved separately.