Estarossa vs. Gildarts

[SuperKamiNappa]

No BFR
Who wins and why?

 

[Ciruno_Fortes_(COB)]

Estarossa cannot counter magic

Gildarts uses magic that splits apart people

I'm gonna side with Gildarts

Cool match though

 

[Davidsteel1]

This is an unusual matchup but cool either way. Estarossa's commandment is basically useless considering this is a random encounter. Gildarts does seem to favour physical attacks but the issue here is that he generally backs up said attacks with his magic, so while Estarossa could deflect the physical damage he can't do anything against Gildarts magic which will literally pull him into pieces. And considering Gildarts also has long ranged techniques things are looking to be in his favour, even more so when u consider that u can't effectively block his attacks. So I'm gonna say Gildarts takes this

 

[Ciruno_Fortes_(COB)]

Actually I just remembered Estarossa has soul manipulation (That might be countered by willpower) and has regen. That might allow him to survive a couple of his and make this even.

 

[Davidsteel1]

^I also forgot about the soul manipulation. How was it countered in the series?

 

[Ciruno_Fortes_(COB)]

Only one who did was Meliodas and Escanor but even Meliodas couldn't fully defend against it. Escanor might be because of his special .... ness... Idk. Dodging physical contact is another

 

[Davidsteel1]

I remember them trying it on Escanor and he no sold it, I also remember them attempting it on Ban too but he was saved, but it seems like at a point they all just forgot and stopped using it.

 

[Burning_Full_Fingers]

Sooo, Estarossa wins?

 

[Ciruno_Fortes_(COB)]

Think it's a tie

 

[Vergil_Lucifer]

In FT any mage has soul resistance. For example Franmalth. Natsu, Lucy and Happy feat some resistance to his abilites, despite he use Curse, not magic. Gildarts was able to resist it because he has equal stats with Estarossa. Also in NnT soul manipulation depending from who strong user of soul manipulation and how strong victim. Mera wasn't able so eat soul of Escanor because he is much more powerfull than she (55600 vs 39000 powerlevel). And this also need to mention that Mera strongest soul manipulation users from her verse.

So I think Gildarts take this with mid diff by use his Crash Magic

 

[Kanika-emo]

Gildarts only attacks physically, Estarossa counter

=Estarrosa Wi

 

[Davidsteel1]

@kanika I've already noted that Gildarts blows aren't simply physical blows he backs his punches up with his magic, so while Estarossa could reflect the physical damage he won't be able to withstand the magical damage

 

[Kanika-emo]

@Davidsteel1 I do not know, Acnology can be burned with real fire because it only has magic resistance and no fire resistance?

For me

Magic Fire= Normal Fire

Magical Physical Blows= Normal Blows

 

[Monarch_Laciel]

Gildarts for reasons above

 

[Vergil_Lucifer]

Kanika-emo, even if you think so (in rules of this wiki and even in Nanatsu no Taizai verse all completly different), Gildarts can just do this and Estarossa die.

Also Estarossa wasn't able to reflect Escanor "Sun Magic" so youre wrong again.

 

[Kanika-emo]

That ability does not kill, it just separates

Estarrosa will regenerate easily

...Estarrosa Stomp

 

[Monarch_Laciel]

That ability is but one application of crash magic. If Gildarts wants, I'm pretty sure he can just break apart Estarrosa. And estaross does not have the regen to come back from that.

 

[Captain_Torch]

I vote for Gildarts, for the reasoning that Davidsteel gave.

 

[Davidsteel1]

@Kami what? Aside from the fact that monarch ha clarified that that is only 1 application of crash (disassembly to be exact) how does one regenerate from that? It hardly qualifies as an injury and all that's happened is estorossas physical and magical abilities have been lessened greatly.

 

[Kanika-emo]

Starrosa can reassemble his body like a gum with Black Matter, no?

It's division and not damage after all

 

[Davidsteel1]

This is significantly different from just reattaching a body part. Unless u can show Estorossa or any one in NNT putting themselves back together from something even remotely like this, then that point is moot

 

[Altaïr_Ibn_Al_Ma'Louf]

Estarossa