- 61,134
- 14,543
Two red-headed spear wielders, one cold and sadistic, the other kind and compassionate.
In character, no prior knowledge or prep time, who wins?
In character, no prior knowledge or prep time, who wins?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Erza Knightwalker vs Pyrrha Nikos
- Thread starter WeeklyBattles
- Start date
- Status
- 1
- 0
I would probably say Knightwalker. Here's what information I could gather from the RWBY wiki, Fairy Tail wiki, and (of course) the pages from this wiki.
Pyrrha Nikos
Pros:
-Aura allows her to take a certain amount of damage with no injury
-Semblance: Polarity (can redirect Knightwalker's spear)
-Longer attack range
-Extremely accurate [Snagged Jaune's hood onto a tree with Miló (spear form) while he was launched from a cliff dozens of meters away from her position several seconds after she landed from her launch]
-Level-headed strategist (can make quick assessments after a few minutes of fighting)
-Balanced fighter (Adept at all of Miló's forms, can quickly switch between them mid-strike, keep attacking in quick succession, and quickly counterattack after defending)
Cons:
- Physically weaker than Knightwalker
- No means to fight back against several of Knightwalker's Ten Commandment forms other than magnetic redirection
-She must come into contact with Knightwalker's spear for her semblance to take effect
-Slower when Knightwalker has Velocity Spear, Silfarion equipped
-Can't take a hit from Saint Spear, Ravelt (Knightwalker's strongest spear)
Erza Knightwalker
Pros:
-Physically stronger
-Multiple spear forms give her a wide variety of options for attacks
-More aggressive fighter
-Superior speed with Velocity Spear, Silfarion
-Far superior power with Saint Spear, Ravelt
Cons:
-Overconfidant
-Less strategic than Pyrrha
-Shorter attack range
Pyrrha would be able to keep up with Erza at first, landing precise strikes in rapid succession and countering Erza's attacks because of her quick thinking and her semblance. However, once Erza switches to a different spear form, Pyrrha would be forced to defend as best as she could; seeing as she has no other means to counter besides her semblance, that would be very difficult considering that Erza is far more aggressive. Her only option is to stay out of Erza's range and use her rifle to deal damage to critical limbs from afar. Unfortunately Erza would close the gap very quickly with her Velocity Spear, Silfarion. Pyrrha might be able to dodge seeing as she has a high hypersonic reaction and can redirect the spear with her semblance, but eventually she would get hit because of Erza's faster speed. Though she's hit from Erza's spear she won't be injured because of her aura, up to a certain point. However, considering that Pyrrha's durability was never pushed to it's limit before, she may not be able to tank a hit from Erza's Saint Spear, Ravelt. If she get's hit, Pyrrha would be defeated at that exact moment, but it wouldn't matter if it was a direct hit or not because Ravelt would just cause a powerful explosion.
Though this is just my opinion and I may have some errors.
Pyrrha Nikos
Pros:
-Aura allows her to take a certain amount of damage with no injury
-Semblance: Polarity (can redirect Knightwalker's spear)
-Longer attack range
-Extremely accurate [Snagged Jaune's hood onto a tree with Miló (spear form) while he was launched from a cliff dozens of meters away from her position several seconds after she landed from her launch]
-Level-headed strategist (can make quick assessments after a few minutes of fighting)
-Balanced fighter (Adept at all of Miló's forms, can quickly switch between them mid-strike, keep attacking in quick succession, and quickly counterattack after defending)
Cons:
- Physically weaker than Knightwalker
- No means to fight back against several of Knightwalker's Ten Commandment forms other than magnetic redirection
-She must come into contact with Knightwalker's spear for her semblance to take effect
-Slower when Knightwalker has Velocity Spear, Silfarion equipped
-Can't take a hit from Saint Spear, Ravelt (Knightwalker's strongest spear)
Erza Knightwalker
Pros:
-Physically stronger
-Multiple spear forms give her a wide variety of options for attacks
-More aggressive fighter
-Superior speed with Velocity Spear, Silfarion
-Far superior power with Saint Spear, Ravelt
Cons:
-Overconfidant
-Less strategic than Pyrrha
-Shorter attack range
Pyrrha would be able to keep up with Erza at first, landing precise strikes in rapid succession and countering Erza's attacks because of her quick thinking and her semblance. However, once Erza switches to a different spear form, Pyrrha would be forced to defend as best as she could; seeing as she has no other means to counter besides her semblance, that would be very difficult considering that Erza is far more aggressive. Her only option is to stay out of Erza's range and use her rifle to deal damage to critical limbs from afar. Unfortunately Erza would close the gap very quickly with her Velocity Spear, Silfarion. Pyrrha might be able to dodge seeing as she has a high hypersonic reaction and can redirect the spear with her semblance, but eventually she would get hit because of Erza's faster speed. Though she's hit from Erza's spear she won't be injured because of her aura, up to a certain point. However, considering that Pyrrha's durability was never pushed to it's limit before, she may not be able to tank a hit from Erza's Saint Spear, Ravelt. If she get's hit, Pyrrha would be defeated at that exact moment, but it wouldn't matter if it was a direct hit or not because Ravelt would just cause a powerful explosion.
Though this is just my opinion and I may have some errors.
- 3,557
- 639
I'm going with Pyrrha, she has superior reactuions and her semblance make her the worst possible enemy for someone who carries round a giant metal weapon
- 42
- 10
Pyrrha. Semblance it way too hax, she's MUCH faster, and more strategetic.
- 7,330
- 1,301
By comparison in tiers alone Erza should win
She has much more useful weapons such as the sword that 'are ignored' by the target
Not to mention Erza is hypersonic and has fought Laxus before who utilizes lightning. She should be able to win. Especially since she dealt with opponents that can use someone's clothing against them. Heck she can probably fight her with her fists if necessary. Not to mention Erza should be able to take whatever Pyrrha dishes out.
Sorry Warpy, siding with FT on this one
She has much more useful weapons such as the sword that 'are ignored' by the target
Not to mention Erza is hypersonic and has fought Laxus before who utilizes lightning. She should be able to win. Especially since she dealt with opponents that can use someone's clothing against them. Heck she can probably fight her with her fists if necessary. Not to mention Erza should be able to take whatever Pyrrha dishes out.
Sorry Warpy, siding with FT on this one
- 2,870
- 73
Erza knight walker.
- 7,330
- 1,301
Brain fart whoops
Well regardless she still kinda has similar stats to Erza considering she went toe to toe with her. And physicality should still be enough. She was smart enough to cut her hair off to prevent the enemy from pretending as her so she should be able to bypass the issue with metals once she figures it out
Well regardless she still kinda has similar stats to Erza considering she went toe to toe with her. And physicality should still be enough. She was smart enough to cut her hair off to prevent the enemy from pretending as her so she should be able to bypass the issue with metals once she figures it out
- 178
- 3
Erza takes this.
- 61,134
- 14,543
- Thread starter
- #10
Guys, you know this fight was made before the RWBY downgrade right? This one shouldn't really count since it's a Large Building character vs a Town level character.
- Status
Similar threads
