Elden Ring's Top Tier should be straight Tier 4 and not just "possibly".

[Blackcurrant91]

yeh I mean considering we literally just got a whole bunch of new info about the cosmology I really dont think its unreasonable that we explore/explored it. I really dont think we need to be throwing around suggestions of discussion rules given that context.

 

[Planck69]

A Discussion Rule would be ridiculous. This thread discusses information that was entirely unavailable the first time it was brought up and that's far from grounds for such a rule.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

A Discussion Rule would be ridiculous. This thread discusses information that was entirely unavailable the first time it was brought up and that's far from grounds for such a rule.

A discussion rule would be necessary if the conversation was indeed to loop back around upon itself over and over again. Which

I’m guessing it would take a separate thread to discuss the possibility of adding Low 4-C as a definite minimum?

this, was an insinuation of.

If a new DLC comes out, I've already said I don't care if we make a new CRT (presuming said DLC affords us new information to look at). The horse is well and truly dead, and it wasn't even the horse being discussed.

 

[SheevShezarrine]

I'm in agreement with either keeping the ratings as-is or changing it to "likely Tier 4". Hopefully someone will dig up instances of armillaries like what happened with Dark Souls to add extra backing of the stars being genuine giant balls.
Take your sweet time tho cus I'd like Aragorn's win over Radahn to remain on the profiles for a while

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Dark Souls tier 4 is already a problem as it is, although I do support that one I recognize that it isn't great as concrete support

 

[SheevShezarrine]

Dark Souls tier 4 is already a problem as it is, although I do support that one I recognize that it isn't great as concrete support

Pretty sure the armillary is more just supporting evidence against the sun being some TES-style hole in the sky or conjured ball of light that's much smaller+closer than our own sun, I'd have to go check the revision threads tho

 

[Chritin]

Dark Souls tier 4 is already a problem as it is, although I do support that one I recognize that it isn't great as concrete support

Granted, Dark Souls just needs help in general. Besides Demon's Souls, it has the most outdated scaling of any Fromsoft game I've seen (most of which I would attribute to Weekly and his former shenanigans).

 

[SheevShezarrine]

Granted, Dark Souls just needs help in general. Besides Demon's Souls, it has the most outdated scaling of any Fromsoft game I've seen (most of which I would attribute to Weekly and his former shenanigans).

I'll get started on a major CRT revising and updating the whole of Demon's Souls once I'm done with reworking the SoD profile and piecing together the lore. So look forward to that in like 5 years

 

[Chritin]

I'll get started on a major CRT revising and updating the whole of Demon's Souls once I'm done with reworking the SoD profile and piecing together the lore. So look forward to that in like 5 years

Dear god please. Those pages are beyond ancient and are in desperate need of help.