- 121
- 6
No is not weather the death star is dwarf star level is. you are using your own head cannon with zero regard when it gets debunked.Taking zero responsibility
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I haven't been debunked yet. You've yet to give me a reason to believe the Rebels, as a fleet, could obliterate the DS1 Superstructure, which was your claim.ByAsura said:You've just repeated your argument with no regard for anything that debunks you.
So what? a stray turbolaser wouldn't do meaningful damage to a moon-sized station.ByAsura said:I said it wouldn't obliterate the fleet before a stray bolt hit it, something which is only supported by the movies. Also, it's Asura (meant to be Azura).
General Dodonna was referring to the Imperial Starfleet: not the Rebel forces.ByAsura said:It really does. Also, as I've said before, the entire Rebel fleet possesses greater firepower than its superlaser. Anyway, if you agree that the Death Star's field gives some sort of protection, I'd be fine with just saying "Higher with..." instead of a specific value.
No I didn't. Link the comment where I said it provides defense: the X-Wings literally fly right through it and YOU agreed that it doesn't provide defense in this comment here.ByAsura said:I was talking just about the magnetic field offering defense, which you agreed it does.
No, he would not have, because the only starfleet referenced in the film id the Empire's. "Dangerous to your Starfleet, commander. Not to this Battlestation."ByAsura said:No he wasn't. They were literally in a meeting with the Rebels, he would have said imperial starfleet.
Either stick on topic or stop commenting. At this point you're just harassing Idzami for disagreeing.Enterprise NCC-1701-E said:Ant please ban him we should remove form the knowledge star trek board for his behavior. Please start to talk agian everyone believes you Idzami
XING06 had me added to the Knowledgeable Members list for Star Trek due to me clearing up some wiki-wide inaccuracies about phaser operation and backing them up with feats. @Enterprise wants me removed from it for my "behavior". He then mocked me by telling me sarcastically to "keep talking because everyone believes me".ByAsura said:@Enterprise I don't want to sound offensive, but your sentences are difficult to understand.
Care to explain how the X-Wings casually went through a barrier that can stop star ships, then? Oh, and the magnetic field that kept out the Falcon was protecting the opening of the docking bay, not the whole station:ByAsura said:Actually, this was a misunderstanding. I thought you were referring to the field. That was very early into the thread and I haven't head that opinion for quite a while because there's evidence that contradicts it. The Millennium doesn't go through it and they say its outer defenses not designed for small fighters, specifically showing the magnetic field as well as the turbolasers. But I guess one instance trumps two.
Again, the only starfleet referenced in the Entire original Star Wars script is the Empire's. Everything from Luke's comments, to Han's comments, to the Empire's officers, to General Dodanna was referring to the Imperial Fleet.ByAsura said:They say starfleet because it's on their side. If the Rebels were referring to the Empire's fleet, they would have called it the Imperial Starfleet, like Luke does "Well, I'll be at the Academy next season... after that who knows. I won't be drafted into the Imperial Starfleet that's for sure... Take care of yourself, you'll always be the best friend I've got."
That explanation ("The Empire doesn't consider a small, one-man fighter to be any threat, or they'd have a tighter defense.") was talking about the turbolasers, which we see the X-wings evading. This is also noted by the Imperial Officer who spoke to Vader ("We count 30 rebel ships, Lord Vader, but they're so small, they're evading our turbolasers.") The turbolasers are the defenses being referred to.ByAsura said:I'm getting really tired of this. Fine, I conceed that the outer defense and the cargo bay magnetic field might be different, but they literally explain why fighters go right through it in the movie, and even then there's some turbulance.
"Dangerous to your starfleet, Commander, not to this battle station."ByAsura said:No, you've just cherry-picked one instance of someone calling the Empire Fleet a "starfleet" to make that assumption. Luke, someone who isn't affiliated with the Empire, calls it the Imperial Starfleet, and that's what any rebel would call it. Also, this term is completely replaced by just the word fleet in all movies, where they call it rebel or imperial.
I don't have a Youtube channel. It is probably yet another troll that has an unhealthy obsession with me.Enterprise NCC-1701-E said:I am also subscribed to your Youtube channel under the name Supreme Infinity Imperial Endgame.
Agreed.Matthew Schroeder said:EU is part of the universe, that has always been the case and trying to change everything out of nowhere to downplay Star Wars is silly.
I mean, there's an awfully huge difference between this:Antvasima said:Okay. Thank you for the clarification. It does not seem necessary though.
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Imperial-class_Star_DestroyerAntvasima said:I think that the currently features two main official canons are enough. It would be an unnecessary considerable effort to add anything more.
Same.Antvasima said:I think that the currently features two main official canons are enough. It would be an unnecessary considerable effort to add anything more.