- 19,826
- 16,240
Well in some of the old systems there was a Wild Magic chart thing. One of the possible results for spell failure resulted in the spell caster accidently raising a sunken island or continent. Dunno if it scales to anything though
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
(D&D) Composite Adventurer WIP Blog
- Thread starter Mr. Bambu
- Start date
-
- Tags
- dungeons and dragons
- 24,799
- 6,134
- 1,317
- 243
yeah I got the 4e stuff covered. just the 11-12 part of the next key is going to take a while to get all the notable stuff from, since level 11 adds so much for 4e PCs.
Edit: also I ended up finding a being named Mual-Tar from 4e that needed 2 greater gods to beat. just to find out the version of the players fight can't scale do to Mul-tar losing most of there power while chained. So it looks like resist and in verse immunity nullification from 4e stuff only works up to a 2-C level.
Edit: also I ended up finding a being named Mual-Tar from 4e that needed 2 greater gods to beat. just to find out the version of the players fight can't scale do to Mul-tar losing most of there power while chained. So it looks like resist and in verse immunity nullification from 4e stuff only works up to a 2-C level.
GreyFang82
He/Him- 2,747
- 328
There's one like that in 5e but I'm pretty sure it's not as impressive. But if you are a level 1 wild magic sorcerer you 100% could end up casting fireball centered on yourself on accident.Qawsedf234 said:
Edit: There is one where in the next minute, if you die, you automatically cast reincarnate on yourself... so that's something right?
- 19,826
- 16,240
Yeah that's one of the wild surge powers. Main issue is that its utterly random. You have as much of a chance of getting self-ressurection as you do of falling madly in love with your target.
- 1,317
- 243
I know this is a bit off topic. But does anyone happen to have anything for the verson of iron kindgoms that used D&D 3.5?
- 26,324
- 3,114
Wouldn't it be better to make a separate profile for each class ?
- 19,826
- 16,240
It was concluded that it would be redundant due to the massive amounts of cross scaling that would insue.
- 1,317
- 243
- 32,343
- 20,267
I'm personally against composite Class characters from RPGs.
- 32,343
- 20,267
That's not a substantial response. The problem with such profiles is that they create absurd, bloated characters that quite frankly don't exist and cannot exist under fair game circumstances. You can't have a D&D Character with every single ability simultaneously. It's impossible.
Udlmaster
They/Them- 6,875
- 2,072
Actually, it's not.
The levels of a D&D character can achieve has no limits, saying "Fair game" isn't a response, as it requires interaction from a GM controlled by a real person and if you say that can happen, the all beings in D&D thus become 1-A because I say they transcend the concept of dimensions in my "fair game".
The levels of a D&D character can achieve has no limits, saying "Fair game" isn't a response, as it requires interaction from a GM controlled by a real person and if you say that can happen, the all beings in D&D thus become 1-A because I say they transcend the concept of dimensions in my "fair game".
- 32,343
- 20,267
Just because you as a GM would push to create an absurd, nonsense scenario, doesn't make it canon to the setting, because it's not. There are rules and limitations, and the very notion of a GM and a story crafted by real life people in each play makes a profile impossible.
- 24,183
- 3,936
Eh... I hate to say it, but I agree with Matt here. We should stick for D&D profiles on established characters.
Udlmaster
They/Them- 6,875
- 2,072
You obviously didn't get what I was pointing out, you can't say "fair game" because you're applying your own intentions to a profile, and thus anyone can then apply their own intentions to the profiles.
What I am saying is that you don't get to choose what is fair and what isn't, and in a normal game, you can have a character with all abilities and all classes.
And there aren't rules in D&D, if you've bothered to read the first few paragraphs of any D&D book, they tel you their books are rules.
And " a story crafted by real life people in each play makes a profile impossible" exactly, so don't try to craft it.
What I am saying is that you don't get to choose what is fair and what isn't, and in a normal game, you can have a character with all abilities and all classes.
And there aren't rules in D&D, if you've bothered to read the first few paragraphs of any D&D book, they tel you their books are rules.
And " a story crafted by real life people in each play makes a profile impossible" exactly, so don't try to craft it.
- 32,343
- 20,267
You don't get to choose what can or can't be put yourself either, and putting literally every ability ever with no regard for internal consistency and logic is not preferrable in the slightest. Even single-class profiles for RPG Characters can be extremely wanked. Mages in WoG are primarily very weak, but you merging every single potential ability into one profile that also uses the highest levels of AP is not only unrealistic, but also factually dishonest with the reality of the game.
Udlmaster
They/Them- 6,875
- 2,072
I'm not, you are, that's literally what you're doing.
You're talking about "internal consistency" but you're making baseless claims, you have no consistency. "Not preferrable in the slightest" by whos account?
By yours? Then you're back tracking and crafting a profile based on your personal beliefs, which you are currently ranting on at me, saying it's wrong.
And it's not "wanked" at all, and you're just flat out lying for saying that, because there's nothing "wanked" about it, and since you've given no evidence for this, I dismiss this based on Hitchen's razor.
Also, stop pulling a red herring, no one is trying to get the "highest levels of AP", you don't have to lie about people in a debate, because just like you're saying, it's "factually dishonest"
You're talking about "internal consistency" but you're making baseless claims, you have no consistency. "Not preferrable in the slightest" by whos account?
By yours? Then you're back tracking and crafting a profile based on your personal beliefs, which you are currently ranting on at me, saying it's wrong.
And it's not "wanked" at all, and you're just flat out lying for saying that, because there's nothing "wanked" about it, and since you've given no evidence for this, I dismiss this based on Hitchen's razor.
Also, stop pulling a red herring, no one is trying to get the "highest levels of AP", you don't have to lie about people in a debate, because just like you're saying, it's "factually dishonest"
- 19,122
- 6,333
There is nothing that is unjustified with the stats or the abilities itself, but in no way it reflects your average D&D adventurer.
It's a composite that can theoretically exist, but doesn't. You ca have every ability in D&D at once? Yes.
Is it something that usually happens/has ever happened? I doubt it
It's a composite that can theoretically exist, but doesn't. You ca have every ability in D&D at once? Yes.
Is it something that usually happens/has ever happened? I doubt it
- 32,343
- 20,267
It's not baseless claims, it's called being reasonable.
By the account of anyone who realistically plays D&D and obeys any set of rules and follows any internal consistency, they would agree that such profiles as proposed here are unrealistic and impossible. You cannot have a character with simultaneously every ability in the game and maxed out stats in everything, you just can't. And yet it's a profile for this impossible fusion that you want to make.
It is thevery definition of wank and no matter how much you try to dismiss contrary points using terms for fallacies erroneously thrown around, it doesn't change the fact that such a character profile does not exist. It's factually dishonest to act otherwise.
By the account of anyone who realistically plays D&D and obeys any set of rules and follows any internal consistency, they would agree that such profiles as proposed here are unrealistic and impossible. You cannot have a character with simultaneously every ability in the game and maxed out stats in everything, you just can't. And yet it's a profile for this impossible fusion that you want to make.
It is thevery definition of wank and no matter how much you try to dismiss contrary points using terms for fallacies erroneously thrown around, it doesn't change the fact that such a character profile does not exist. It's factually dishonest to act otherwise.
- 32,343
- 20,267
This is precisely my point, the profile is unrealistically / impossible jacked in every conceivable way for no real reason other than make it as powerful as possible. Are the people making it wanting to portray a realistic depiction of a D&D Adventurer, or are they just trying to get the most absurdly strong and haxed character possible to make it a high-tier character that'll win matches?Kaltias said:
It's the later.
- 24,183
- 3,936
I mean
As someone who loves d&d
Are max level player characters tier 2? Yes
Do they have every spell in game? Lolno
As someone who loves d&d
Are max level player characters tier 2? Yes
Do they have every spell in game? Lolno
- 19,826
- 16,240
It might be a good idea to at least separate the abilities between classes. If only because a 1/1/1/1/1/1/1 person is technically level 7 rather than level 1 which makes tiering wonky. Though the upper level guys tend to be basically composite character classes due to their power.
Also in general composite profiles are extremely stacked due to a far larger drawing pool
Also in general composite profiles are extremely stacked due to a far larger drawing pool
- 19,826
- 16,240
> Do they have every spell in game?
I mean, some legitmatly do
I mean, some legitmatly do
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 21,761
- 19,684
- Thread starter
- #391
Actually, thanks to Zeromaru I've found basis that all gods have every spell in the game. Their statblocks seem to denote what they do regularly. Saying you disagree with a composite class profile is fine, but that's really and truly the most accurate representation as cross-classing is an actual thing in-game. That doesn't make this the most common adventurer you'll see in-game; it is the culmination of those players' possibilities.
Also, Zach, look at the blog- they peak at Tier 1, remember?
- 24,183
- 3,936
Wait
So Malcanthet gets a wall of text? Yes this is perfect
- 32,343
- 20,267
I have extreme doubts on the legitimacy of the current profiles and so do many other users, and I don't think composite class profiles are acceptable for the wiki in the slightest. And I specially question the Tier 1 scaling as a whole.
- 24,183
- 3,936
@Matt
You mean Luminous Being?
You mean Luminous Being?
- 19,826
- 16,240
The most there is, is an optinal thing to make them a Quasideity and able to grant spells.Mr. Bambu said:
- 32,343
- 20,267
Luminous Being is like legitimaly the only Tier 1 character I've seen.
- 24,183
- 3,936
Ah yeah lumi is definitely tier 1
But to be honest even I'm not sure about anyone else
But to be honest even I'm not sure about anyone else
Mr. Bambu
Suffer-Not-Injustice Bambu
VS Battles
Joke Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Silver Supporter
- 21,761
- 19,684
- Thread starter
- #400
Matt, I'm aware. That's why I'm creating the explanation blog, since people have now begun doubting literally anything if there isn't an eighteen mile long blog telling them why it's okay.
Tier 1 is the simple bit since it comes solely from an old setting of Mystara. Frankly I wasn't happy about it when I heard of it either, but put simply- players are destined to become Immortals, higher-dimensional beings that are aware of five-dimensional space. Immortals are further aware of the Old Ones, beings that wish for the Immortals to ascend to their own level of existence but, until they do, place a barrier on their minds. Immortals are inherently lesser than Old Ones, so we don't know where they'd be without this existing barrier. Finally, the Immortals have mathematically proven the existence of infinite spatial dimensions of Mystara, but cannot access those higher dimensions to confirm their issues. Hence why a lot of the Tier 1 stuff is "possibly".
It'll all be in the blog and then I can get back to actually important work.
Tier 1 is the simple bit since it comes solely from an old setting of Mystara. Frankly I wasn't happy about it when I heard of it either, but put simply- players are destined to become Immortals, higher-dimensional beings that are aware of five-dimensional space. Immortals are further aware of the Old Ones, beings that wish for the Immortals to ascend to their own level of existence but, until they do, place a barrier on their minds. Immortals are inherently lesser than Old Ones, so we don't know where they'd be without this existing barrier. Finally, the Immortals have mathematically proven the existence of infinite spatial dimensions of Mystara, but cannot access those higher dimensions to confirm their issues. Hence why a lot of the Tier 1 stuff is "possibly".
It'll all be in the blog and then I can get back to actually important work.
Similar threads
