• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Makima wincons are mind control, bfr, bio hax and cosmo while boa wincon is touching makima once so I think mkm wins this
 
Bio hax is negated since Law demonstrated that Haki negated Doc Q’s biological alteration of him.

Haki also prevented Law from moving Big Mom and Kaido to other locations, so it potentially counters BFR.

Mindhax is iffy because Boa has the willpower to stave off hundreds of shadows when just two are capable of mindhax, plus Boa is a very prominent figure as the pirate empress and naturally commands respect.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure Boa can just keep spamming until everyone in Japan is stoned, she can go for five days in a straight fight.
 
You’re right, damn.

That said I don’t think it’s infeasible Makima would find Boa at least a little attractive, since snails found her hot.
 
Would petrification even work? Makima resists Transmutation, and Public Safety– which has access to the Stone Devil– still didn't think she could be killed.
 
Yeah okay fair enough.
Makima FRA (unless the sheer AP difference is capable of reducing Makima to a point she can’t regen from).
 
Can Makima transfer non-fatal effects? Because Hancock's petrification is non-fatal. You do not die after petrification. And it can be reversed by the user.
 
Can Makima transfer non-fatal effects? Because Hancock's petrification is non-fatal. You do not die after petrification. And it can be reversed by the user.
if her opponents considers it a attack then it gets transferred
 
Not sure if the passive Mero Mero is an attack, since it’s an effect that activated via having any sort of emotion of thinking Hancock is cute or sexy, but it working is still questionable for other reasons.
 
Not sure if the passive Mero Mero is an attack, since it’s an effect that activated via having any sort of emotion of thinking Hancock is cute or sexy, but it working is still questionable for other reasons.
Makima wouldn't feel any emotion toward her so that's not really an option
Would petrification even work? Makima resists Transmutation, and Public Safety– which has access to the Stone Devil– still didn't think she could be killed.
I agree with this, if the stone devil was an option against her contract I'm sure it would have been mentioned against her
 
Makima wouldn't feel any emotion toward her so that's not really an option
image.png

Middle Left Caption next to Panel: An ability that captivates and petrifies people regardless of age or gender! It can materialize thrown kisses and even launch physical attacks!
Bottom Caption next to Panel: The "Mero Mero Mellow" that captures the hearts of opponents and petrifies them. It is impossible for anyone other than the ability user to undo the petrification! (Databook Blue Deep).
 
Not feeling emotion isn’t enough since it works on Pacifista.
Makima doesn't feel any specific emotion to any human due to seeing herself above them

Makima only feels emotion towards Pochita, so I heavily doubt that she would feel any emotion toward Boa
image.png

Middle Left Caption next to Panel: An ability that captivates and petrifies people regardless of age or gender! It can materialize thrown kisses and even launch physical attacks!
Bottom Caption next to Panel: The "Mero Mero Mellow" that captures the hearts of opponents and petrifies them. It is impossible for anyone other than the ability user to undo the petrification! (Databook Blue Deep).
It depends on Boa's perception of the ability and how she uses it on the opponent, In this case she would be using Conqueror's Haki for the outcome of making Makima go lights out which means she perceives it as an attack
^
To resist Makima's Conquest, a sudden burst of emotion is needed, although even then Makima can shut it down by giving another command (eg. "Down.")
^
 
Makima doesn't feel any specific emotion to any human due to seeing herself above them

Makima only feels emotion towards Pochita, so I heavily doubt that she would feel any emotion toward Boa
Feeling above someone is itself an emotion about them, also this is just straight up wrong.
Ejfoi3O.png

To resist Makima's Conquest, a sudden burst of emotion is needed, although even then Makima can shut it down by giving another command (eg. "Down.")
Too bad it probably isn't gonna effect her in the first place.
It depends on Boa's perception of the ability and how she uses it on the opponent, In this case she would be using Conqueror's Haki for the outcome of making Makima go lights out which means she perceives it as an attack
This does not at all address what I said.
 
Feeling above someone is itself an emotion about them, also this is just straight up wrong.
Ejfoi3O.png
Makima in this scene was crying because of what the movie represented, the fact that since Makima was above everyone she met she would never be able to form an equal relationship with anyone. Which at the end of part 1 we found out her dream to be in an equal relationship with someone

Also Makima doesn't feel above them she straight up is litteraly above them and cannot form an equal relationship with them. In the control devil arc she states she sees humans as dogs

Too bad it probably isn't gonna effect her in the first place.
Whats stopping Makima's Mind manip from affecting Boa
This does not at all address what I said.
It goes over the fact that those abilities will just be transferred to a random Japanese citizen
 
im pretty sure denji says in chapter 97 that makima can't differenciate human faces from one another(just like yoru can't differenciate denji and pochita)
 
Depends on the context but elaborate
Through sheer willpower they can resist losing their mind when absorbing shadows through the Kage Kage no Mi. Shadows belonging to strong willed people are difficult to control, allowing them to rebel against Moria's pact which usually immediately submits a shadow to his supremacy and orders. Spiritual energy is contained within one's soul/life; this energy is represented by the fighting power or the Haki itself.
- Almost every page
 
And Boa's haki (resistance) scales:
Baseline Resistance<Taishigi<Smoker<Vergo<Law~Hancock
Which is 4 layers.
 
Back
Top