Asta vs Natsu

[Sonicflare9]

Asta (Pre-Timeskip)

Asta was left at an orphanage as an infant on the outskirts of the Clover Kingdom alongside another baby named Yuno. Excitable and outgoing, he dreams of becoming the Magic Emperor, the greatest mage in the kingdom. However, Asta is one of the rare few, if not the only one to be born without the...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Natsu Dragneel (X784 to X791)

Natsu Dragneel is a Mage of the Fairy Tail Guild, wherein he is a member of Team Natsu. He is the younger brother of Zeref Dragneel, having originally died 400 years ago, being subsequently revived as his brother's most powerful Etherious, E.N.D. (Etherious Natsu Dragneel). During this time...

vsbattles.fandom.com

eye of the midnight sun arc vs in x791

speed equalized

whooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo would win

 

[TotalMasterInfinity]

Asta (base) is about 8.83 Megatones
Natsu (Base) is about 25.8 Megatons
the difference of their bases is almost 3 times
Natsu becomes stronger than that with LFDM and with HFDM it is already above 53.15 megatons and dragon force is around 550 megatons
while Black Asta is somewhat above 197.2 Megatons
Now that in terms of power, if we talk about the skills Asta has the sale with his Anti-Magic that allows him to cancel, reflect and absorb magic, but in terms of the use of his transformations Asta has some problems such as time limit of use and activation time.
my opinion is this Asta (Base) would lose with all the forms of Natsu maybe he could give some fight to Natsu (Base) but eventually he would find defeat and no longer speak of the rest of the forms of natsu that would be a stomp while Black Asta He would defeat all forms of Natsu waiting for Dragon Force