- 10,277
- 17,268
@KingTempest for the name.
After my “excursions” with NNT I've set my sights on Black Clover, while admittingly having a lot less things i disagree with, still has abilities which i personally disagree with, either being on the profiles entirely or i wish to change to better reflect the ability in actuality.
So given this introduction, let’s continue onto the actual meat
of this thread.
This ability has been completely wanked into high heavens, it’s, for some reason assumed combat-applicable in the sense of it being capable of deconstructing people and not just the objects around Yuno just because it’s capable of deconstructing physical matter around him…. Which is an assumption that’s shown over and over again to be untrue, given the fact Yuno has never, ever within the story of Black Clover actually deconstructed someone with this aura. We can’t assume just because it’s capable of deconstructing objects around him means it can deconstruct people when it’s never shown such feats or doesn’t have a logical basis behind it being capable of deconstructing people.
It should be downgraded to Limited and explained on the profile that its deconstruction effects are only applicable against objects around Yuno and not actually people as well.
Julius’s magic doesn’t create wounds which are “unhealable”, they just cause heavy damage to the point of taking long amounts of time to actually regenerate from, even after using healing-boosting magic like Fana’s Phoenix Robe. Also nothing implies that the reasoning behind why Julius’s Magic does this is because of somesort of regeneration negation “effect”, compared to the interpretation that Julius’s Magic just deals more damage comparatively to other magic types within the series, and such inherently requires more time to regenerate from. It’d be similar to giving someone who has Existence Erasure, Regeneration Negation because it takes longer for someone to regenerate from that compared to being vaporized by lightning. It’s just an inherent function that abilities with higher “potency” or "effects" have.
It should be removed completely from both Julius’s and Lucius’s profiles imo. But if push comes to shove then I'd be fine with compromising on a Possibly Limited rating.
Nothing is explained on his profile why Type 2 is assumed compared to Type 3, which is the standard Type of Conceptual Manipulation for abilities that aren’t explained in-depthly or have extremely vague showings. If Black Clover supporters can’t provide evidence why it should be Type 2, it needs to be downgraded to Type 3, similar to Lilith’s and Naamah’s Conceptual Manipulation.
Agree: azontr, CloverDragon03, DaReaperMan, Kachon123, Worthless (Agrees with Morris and Yuno), Panache_x (Agrees with Yuno), SuperStar, DemonGodMitchAubin, Arnoldstone18, KingTempest, Damage3245
Disagree: Milly_Rocking_Bandit (Disagrees with regen negation removal), Worthless (Disagrees with removing regen negation), Epsilon_R (Yuno's Deconstruction), Panache_x (Disagrees with regen negation removal but agrees with limited rating)
Neutral: Milly_Rocking_Bandit (Doesn't care about Morris and Yuno)
After my “excursions” with NNT I've set my sights on Black Clover, while admittingly having a lot less things i disagree with, still has abilities which i personally disagree with, either being on the profiles entirely or i wish to change to better reflect the ability in actuality.
So given this introduction, let’s continue onto the actual meat
of this thread.Yuno Grinberryall
Passive Deconstruction -This ability has been completely wanked into high heavens, it’s, for some reason assumed combat-applicable in the sense of it being capable of deconstructing people and not just the objects around Yuno just because it’s capable of deconstructing physical matter around him…. Which is an assumption that’s shown over and over again to be untrue, given the fact Yuno has never, ever within the story of Black Clover actually deconstructed someone with this aura. We can’t assume just because it’s capable of deconstructing objects around him means it can deconstruct people when it’s never shown such feats or doesn’t have a logical basis behind it being capable of deconstructing people.
It should be downgraded to Limited and explained on the profile that its deconstruction effects are only applicable against objects around Yuno and not actually people as well.
Julius Novachrono/Lucius Zogratis
Regeneration Negation -Julius’s magic doesn’t create wounds which are “unhealable”, they just cause heavy damage to the point of taking long amounts of time to actually regenerate from, even after using healing-boosting magic like Fana’s Phoenix Robe. Also nothing implies that the reasoning behind why Julius’s Magic does this is because of somesort of regeneration negation “effect”, compared to the interpretation that Julius’s Magic just deals more damage comparatively to other magic types within the series, and such inherently requires more time to regenerate from. It’d be similar to giving someone who has Existence Erasure, Regeneration Negation because it takes longer for someone to regenerate from that compared to being vaporized by lightning. It’s just an inherent function that abilities with higher “potency” or "effects" have.
It should be removed completely from both Julius’s and Lucius’s profiles imo. But if push comes to shove then I'd be fine with compromising on a Possibly Limited rating.
Morris Libardirt
Conceptual Manipulation -Nothing is explained on his profile why Type 2 is assumed compared to Type 3, which is the standard Type of Conceptual Manipulation for abilities that aren’t explained in-depthly or have extremely vague showings. If Black Clover supporters can’t provide evidence why it should be Type 2, it needs to be downgraded to Type 3, similar to Lilith’s and Naamah’s Conceptual Manipulation.
Agree: azontr, CloverDragon03, DaReaperMan, Kachon123, Worthless (Agrees with Morris and Yuno), Panache_x (Agrees with Yuno), SuperStar, DemonGodMitchAubin, Arnoldstone18, KingTempest, Damage3245
Disagree: Milly_Rocking_Bandit (Disagrees with regen negation removal), Worthless (Disagrees with removing regen negation), Epsilon_R (Yuno's Deconstruction), Panache_x (Disagrees with regen negation removal but agrees with limited rating)
Neutral: Milly_Rocking_Bandit (Doesn't care about Morris and Yuno)
Last edited:
