- 4,114
- 2,172
So yeah, Darkness vs Stormtrooper went pretty well, so I think I'll try another off-beat thread to see how it'll do. This time, it'll be a witch against a black cat: Nanny McPhee vs Rip the Cat from Goosebumps. In terms of haxwalls, Rip perhaps has the smallest haxwall out of all the magic-based Goosebumps characters. Both characters are capable of creating tornados, which are 8-C at the very least. I wasn't able to access how powerful Rip's feat is since all his tornado did was shake a graveyard. McPhee's tornado, however, can be compared to an F2 Tornado, which comes very close to 8-C+ at the bare minimum.
Rip the Cat's durability is basically a death sentence: 10-C. It is, however, uncertain what Nanny McPhee's durability is, but it is likely that she is comparable to any other human, who is more than certainly more durable than a cat.
However, that doesn't mean both don't have their wincons. Both characters' tornados can kill one another. Rip's scratches have life-stealing capabilities that would turn McPhee into a sort of were-cat, giving a win by death or a win by control. Also, Rip has literally nine lives to begin with, so he's gonna give McPhee a hard time when handling him.
As for Nanny McPhee, she has the following win-cons against him:
Here are their profiles:
Nanny McPhee's Profile
Rip the Cat's Profile
Who takes this?
Witch: 4 (Frieza force soldier 100, Peppersalt43, Artorimachi Meteoraft, The Almighty Wholeome)
Cat: 0
Inconclusive: 0
Rip the Cat's durability is basically a death sentence: 10-C. It is, however, uncertain what Nanny McPhee's durability is, but it is likely that she is comparable to any other human, who is more than certainly more durable than a cat.
However, that doesn't mean both don't have their wincons. Both characters' tornados can kill one another. Rip's scratches have life-stealing capabilities that would turn McPhee into a sort of were-cat, giving a win by death or a win by control. Also, Rip has literally nine lives to begin with, so he's gonna give McPhee a hard time when handling him.
As for Nanny McPhee, she has the following win-cons against him:
- Disease Manipulation: By giving Rip measles, she could have the resulting rash make Rip commit Cat Seppuku with his own scratches.
- Animal Manipulation: Nanny McPhee can use her power over animals to gain control of Rip, given how she can control an elephant. Bear in mind, elephants are near-human levels in terms of intelligence and function similarly to primitive human tribes who lived off the knowledge of their land. Rip can potentially resist this since he can will himself to not die.
- Charm Casting: McPhee make it so that Rip exhibits boot camp levels of obedience just by... well, basically existing (see "Charm Casting" section on her profile). Rip can potentially resist this since he can will himself to not die.
- Body Puppetry: Since she has body puppetry by her side, Nanny McPhee can take control of Rip's body, preventing him from scratching her altogether. In that same venue, Nanny McPhee can make Rip seppuku himself until all of his lives are gone. Considering that zombies are essentially puppets in the Haitian folktales they originally came from, McPhee should have no problem doing this to Rip.
- Non-Physical Interaction: With this ability by her side, if she couldn't deal with Rip through any of her other abilities above, then she could potentially apply these abilities (minus measles) to Rip's ghost cat minions. More than likely, however, this would be to placate them rather than remove them. Honestly, her NPI was never explained in her page.
Here are their profiles:
Nanny McPhee's Profile
Rip the Cat's Profile
Who takes this?
Witch: 4 (Frieza force soldier 100, Peppersalt43, Artorimachi Meteoraft, The Almighty Wholeome)
Cat: 0
Inconclusive: 0
Last edited:
