- 52,605
- 46,829
Tooru Logic Manipulation or Law Manipulation?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Wiki Vandalism Reports
- Thread starter Antvasima
- Start date
-
- Tags
- editing rules site rules
- 15,208
- 22,465
The original ability is Law manipulation, just being written as Logic manipulation and is linked to Law manipulation. And DontTalkDT already rejected it being Logic hax and said it is Law hax instead in the comment i have linked, unless you want to say his word isn't absolute, which i have nothing to say
- 12,757
- 15,223
I think DontTalk doesn't know about JoJo enough to give a veredict and was basing his thoughts on what profiles said, which is fair and correct from a certain point of view. But since Chariot said it's Law and doesn't want to elaborate on it being Logic (really, it'd take lots of scans, writing texts and explaining how fate is written in JoJo since it's a major concept within the series) then applying law back should be the correct choice here.
- 2,603
- 5,156
Okay then.
Since that's the verdict, no further action is needed, as I already reverted the change several hours ago, so it's back to Law Manipulation again.
I also gave the user a heads-up.
Since that's the verdict, no further action is needed, as I already reverted the change several hours ago, so it's back to Law Manipulation again.
I also gave the user a heads-up.
- 2,603
- 5,156
I'll just note here that I removed the "Logic Manipulation" text display to avoid confusion and listed it as an outright Law Manipulation text.
It appears that the user who edited it believed they were correcting an error, since the while it linked to Law Manipulation, the display text was Logic Manipulation.
- 12,757
- 15,223
At the time there was no Logic Manipulation page iirc, so Chariot listed it as Law and wrote Logic because they're... similar, or rather, close to each other. Now that we have one and actually need more explanation to qualify, I think we'd rather not do that yet.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
These edits by Kaay Garth are minor, but the formatting is wrong and the matchup doesn't exist.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
Anonymous_Learner added a fight of 5 against 4 votes to these characters’ profiles, which goes against our rule requiring at least 7 votes for one side.
I reverted it.
I reverted it.
- 2,603
- 5,156
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,212
I do not remember, but they seem like mostly reasonable self-evident changes. Although the durability change should have required a minor CRT.
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,781
- 6,040
Thought i knew something, didn't.
Apologizes, won't happen again
- 15,208
- 22,465
There was two stats change, one was Durability, the other was Stamina. And one addition of Explosion Manipulation, the rest was justification edit with scan in form of youtube videoI do not remember, but they seem like mostly reasonable self-evident changes. Although the durability change should have required a minor CRT.
The justification edit is fine i think, however the other changes isn't, individually those changes are minor, however grouped together make them a considerable change which personally i think this require a CRT to be addressed, however if other staff are fine with these additions without a CRT then i will not object
Though i did a quick evaluation and i think the Explosion Manipulation is undeserved, rigging a house to make it explode shouldn't be considered a power and just be under either skill/feat or intelligence
Last edited:
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,215
Yes, I suppose that makes good sense.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
Cosmopolitanwexx added battles that took place within the manga's story to the Notable Matchups
I reverted them.
I reverted them.
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,218
Butler handled it.
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,219
Thank you for giving an instruction to this member.
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
The user Rockyrod22 made changes to Lord Boros' page, although it doesn't appear malicious.
The changes were already reverted by AceOfSpaces3709,
but Rockyrod22 should probably be given instructions.
The changes were already reverted by AceOfSpaces3709,
but Rockyrod22 should probably be given instructions.
- 2,603
- 5,156
- 4,939
- 2,128
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
But thank you for helping out.
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
- 4,939
- 2,128
I keep mudding up the diff, mb
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,226
Butler deleted it.
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,227
I gave another warning instruction, since it wasn't a serious issue.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
Jbcooler Ninja made some changes to Acnologia's profile, such as adding a note in the durability section. I might be mistaken, but I don’t think that’s how explanatory notes should be
He also added a weakness that, in my view, is not actually a weakness.
He also added a weakness that, in my view, is not actually a weakness.
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,229
Butler reverted the changes, and I gave an instruction message, since this did not seem severe enough for a warning.
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
Bimgus8010 upgraded Kyle Rayner to 2-C.
Masked is unaware of any CRTs for this, and there is no CRT linked.
In addition, none of the justifications support this.
However, Masked would like a staff opinion on the changes, since they are not particularly knowledgeable about DC.
Masked is unaware of any CRTs for this, and there is no CRT linked.
In addition, none of the justifications support this.
However, Masked would like a staff opinion on the changes, since they are not particularly knowledgeable about DC.
- 2,603
- 5,156
I'll revert it for now, but if there is a valid reason for it, I would not mind reversing my revert.
@Bimgus8010
Ztesrxgdfjcvgkbh
He/Him- 1,202
- 605
I'll note they seem new, so they might just be clueless
- 6,238
- 5,730
I rolled it back. They were warned before for another pages they changed by Ant, so this is kind of a second warning.
- 181
- 45
Blatant 2C universeS plural feat listed as low 2C
Even ant gave a thumbs up on my reply to change the the tier to 2C or 2A
(Let's not forget, I ask him to open the page for me to edit
)
MaskedDragon908
They/Them- 368
- 473
Kyle Rayner's AP was justified in this thread.Blatant 2C universeS plural feat listed as low 2C
Even ant gave a thumbs up on my reply to change the the tier to 2C or 2A
(Let's not forget, I ask him to open the page for me to edit
DC Heralds rescaling thread
Forgive me that this has taken so long, but irl stuff has gotten in the way a lot, but that's all out of the way (for now), let's do it. Sandbox ratings Above is what the new ratings for the current characters should look like. You may notice that not everyone is listed, and the reasoning for...
The universes created is plural because each New God is creating their own universe.
You would have to prove that they are each creating multiple, as Kyle Rayner only scales to individual New Gods.
Staff in your thread agreed to 2-B, and then 2-A scaling, but only for scaling to Barbatos.
This key of Kyle Rayner is unrelated to those revisions.
DC Comics : Higher Keys And Abilities Request (2B superman and such)
This is my first time making a thread, I wanted to request certain things Superman 2B Key He already has "varies" in his key, so I think it's reasonable that he can sometimes be 2B Some of the accepted feats that are listed for rebirth superman should scale higher than 2C He one shotted the...
If you wish to change Kyle Rayner's AP, please open a new content revision thread.
- 181
- 45
Wasn't that a part of a general 2-A upgrade-chain for DC Comics characters?
Maybe, if you think every new god emanations are 2A (I might ask other DC staff about it)
I just changed the low 2Cs key to 2C because UniverseS plural feat for Kyle rayner which you gave
for me to editWhich I also want to do to kalibak and wonder woman low 2Cs key for obvious reasons
Kalibak
Kalibak is the first son of Darkseid, born to his true love, the sorceress Suli. He inherited great power from his parents, becoming the highest-ranking military commander on Apokolips save for Darkseid himself. He is quite intelligent despite his appearance and mannerisms, and has a secret soft...
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 181
- 45
Kyle Rayner's AP was justified in this thread.
DC Heralds rescaling thread
Forgive me that this has taken so long, but irl stuff has gotten in the way a lot, but that's all out of the way (for now), let's do it. Sandbox ratings Above is what the new ratings for the current characters should look like. You may notice that not everyone is listed, and the reasoning for...vsbattles.com
The universes created is plural because each New God is creating their own universe.
You would have to prove that they are each creating multiple, as Kyle Rayner only scales to individual New Gods.
Staff in your thread agreed to 2-B, and then 2-A scaling, but only for scaling to Barbatos.
This key of Kyle Rayner is unrelated to those revisions.
DC Comics : Higher Keys And Abilities Request (2B superman and such)
This is my first time making a thread, I wanted to request certain things Superman 2B Key He already has "varies" in his key, so I think it's reasonable that he can sometimes be 2B Some of the accepted feats that are listed for rebirth superman should scale higher than 2C He one shotted the...
If you wish to change Kyle Rayner's AP, please open a new content revision thread.
No
They were upgraded to 2B because of barbatos and son of world forger
They were upgraded to 2A because of time trapper and Dr fate https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/v...2940995.png/revision/latest?cb=20240118073000 warping all timelines which 3 staff agreed upon
not detailed enough to be high 1B but ok for 2A (this one I put in my thread pretty late before it was closed)
"Comparable to random New GodS (plural) of new genesis that can create universeS (plural)"
That low 2C key is scale to many new gods who can create their own universe (using your logic).......which is still 2C
Maybe I should just ask emirp (the guy you linked and the guy who agreed with me and did the 2A upgrades first before me)
Last edited:
- 177,358
- 90,215
- Thread starter
- #4,240
