Alabasta and the Sandora River are visible. Drum Island alone is over 50 kilometers in diameter, the same as Sandora. The climate zone for Drum Island extends far beyond those 50 kilometers on all directions. The in-between sea beyond that before reaching Alabasta's climate zone. The would absolutely be visible.
It does when you trying to categorize the climates for different islands and so on by the very definition of climate zones.
I already addressed this. That isn’t true
Genuine question, what do you think this large crack in Alabasta is
Outside of Drum Island's immediate climate zone is where it is snowing, consistently, each time.
Did you just say that we don't see signs of rainy weather in the arc where the entire plot point of the arc was that somebody stole the rain? And that there is no rain for the climate zone because the rain was taken away from the island, and in the panel shown there was the rain finally coming back?
None of this makes sense at all.
that does not match how the river is portrayed in the next panelsGenuine question, what do you think this large crack in Alabasta is
Surely Oda didn't accidentally make a mark at a random spot that just so happens to be where the Sandora River runs through the island right?
I am not measuring it by the very definition of climate zones.
yeah, because it's ZOOMED OUT.
Thats how a zoom works bud
Yeah
So if we took the ship's average speed in the real world and applied it to the calc it would prove that One Piece ship speed is different in the real world. As if we took the real-world speed. Drum Island would likely be in the image.
We don't measure size that way, if we did, things like WoW's Azeroth would be so much bigger...
Also, the fact that they need a permanent log pose to travel to the island so they might have skipped some islands.
They'll say drum island is 2km wide and there's no way for it to truly be in the panel so what's the point
they didn't skip any islands, the logpose works in that it goes to the closest island
No, for Alabasta, they used an Eternal Pose to get there. The only used a log pose to get to drum island.
Canonically Alabasta is the 4th island in the log pose. they were going to use an eternal pose from little garden (the 2nd island), but then they took the regular log route after Nami got sick, and since alabasta was the next island it didn't matter
Can you reword this? I'm having trouble understanding what you mean here. Are you saying that this panel is at an angle?
It is at a 5° angle or thereabouts, look, the island isn't dead center!
Oda was able to showcase a 50km crack on the screen at that altitude. He can show anything he wants.
She didn't say it's right before Alabasta, she just said it's near alabasta
So in that case, it should be visible on the panel then...
OR 'near' is relative.
Either way, it should be closer than drum.
it's literally a piece of shit i don't even genuinely give it the lax to consider it a real island
"Which island is next on the Grand Line?" Is my question to that answer.
they ain't pick up what i was putting down twin
You can’t measure a climate zone when we already trying to measure the width and length of the Grand Line and all. Also there is no way to measure climate zones in that regard. The measurements for climate zones are meant for weather and atmospheric conditions as well so it is literally pointless to even go that route either way.
The reason I say this is:
Question for you.
What do you think a climate zone is in One Piece regarding the grand line?
You said what the definition of a climate zone is in the real world.
It still applies for one Piece, just on a different planet.
So you don't know what a climate zone in One Piece is.
No, that's not my point. The point is that if POV isn't like super far from them, all the clouds you see will correspond to very small part of the surface you see on the panel.
I don't think anyone claimed this to be the case; it's just something that can't be ruled out.
