Why would the other dimension make more sense?
Again, sonic does not have cosmic awareness
No-one is saying he does
then why is everyone here in the ship of ''another dimension''being valid?that will imply sonic has cosmic awareness to know what his other self is doing IN ANOTHER DIMENSION.
Who said Modern Sonic knew what Classic Sonic was doing? The whole reason the timeline split was brought up was because Modern didn’t remember.
where is the proof that he didn't remember it?
No-one during Forces initially had any idea what the Phantom Ruby was or what it was capable of.
only Sonic and Tails were present when the phantom ruby did it's things, no one else was present, and time travel does not work like that.
That-What-No? We're talking about how the Modern Cast doesn't remember the events of Mania, despite Mania being the past. Such as Eggman canonically not having heard of the Phantom Ruby in the Prequel Comic, but ALSO canonically found and harnessed it back in Mania. Or how Sonic and Tails canonically came across it in Mania, but have no idea what it is in the actual Forces game. The explanation that existed, canonically, for all of this, before the Timeline was put back together, was that it "Split." Generations caused an alteration to the timeline. You can hear about this from Flynn in older Bumblekasts (I believe) and I think Iizuka(?). However, NOW, it's all one continuous timeline, (TailsTube, Iizuka and Ian Flynn's recent Bumblekasts), meaning there's this inconsistency between events. Hence the question: "How does the Wiki approach this?"
It sure doesn't seem like I'm the only one who's against the retcon, but whatever. Not much can be done about it.
The way we're currently approaching it is good enough imo. Story wise, there's only one timeline, but power-scalling wise, we give Classic Sonic a key for his modern appearances to fix the inconsistancies. It doesn't make sense, but it's the most amount of sense this can possibly make. Any other power-scalling implications this time paradox carries should be ignored unless explicitely integral to the story.
Like Classic sonic restoring time
It's not a power scaling inconsistancy, since it falls into Classic Sonic's "modern appearances" key
Whatever
They didn't accept it because of Solaris. They did because Super Silver massively upscales from base Sonic's infinite speed feats and a Super form's speed is described as "incalculable". I don't expect them to ever explicitely scale anyone in the game verse to Solaris in a long time, still. That would require them to swallow thier pride.
Perhaps your right and I'm being a bit too optimistic. Ah well I'd be fine with it as long as they acknowledge the final egg blaster and that's what I'm betting will happen. Heres where I think they will scale both.
I agree that this is what they'll do with Eggman, although 5A is likely to be reserved for some of his stronger machines that explicitely scale to the chaos emeralds. I'm split on whether they'll put Bowser at 3-C or under planet level, but I do think they'll put Dreamy Bowser and Time Eater at a relative level of power, with Eggman being a bit faster overall
Let's see. Maybe they will accept this since it's new info, but I've seen equally competant researchers ignore it completely in the past
Flying through the end of time might just be written off as time travel and not speed. Generally they go with the lowball interpretation unless its Marvel/DC god tiers.
mierda with that, this is the time eater, why would he not have the speed to travel through time?
Because they seemingly take the lowest interpretations of feats
Neither of these statements sounds very Immeasurable to me, rather just flowery language to make it sound dramatic
Except time travel via sheer speed IS immeasurable, lol
This has always sounded like a cop-out "debunk" to me. Anything can be dismissed under the guise of making something sound "dramatic". No different than "flowery language". An encyclopedia is informative in nature.
Well, sorry for feeling like this, but personally it does sound weak, if it was written directly like "Super Sonics fly through time to defeat Time Eater" it would be better
Which is pretty much 90% true if that's the case, most of writers on the planet don't know what time travel through speed is and especially doesn't know that it makes you faster than infinity
Don't apologize, you're absolutely entitled to your opinion and I can at least get why even if I disagree.
