• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Roblox verses - To nuke, or not to nuke?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Personally, I don’t think Dinosaur Simulator should stay as a verse. It’s literally a simulator about playing as a dinosaur and growing up, getting DNA by aging, and getting new dinos. It’s only “lore” is unique original dinosaurs it adds, but those are effectively just OCs and there’s virtually no lore behind any of them.

Also, it only has 2 profiles, both of which seem outdated.
 
I'm going to explain why some of the verses I made pages for should stay

Isle- Action horror game with combat, puzzles, lore and no copyright violations apperaing

Databrawl- Combat focused game with lore and no copyright violations as of the current version

Ronald- Horror game with a scene with fighting it it and a story and no copyright violations besides the main antagonist being based off of Ronald McDonald some and a minor character based off of Grimance appearing
 
I'm going to explain why some of the verses I made pages for should stay

Isle- Action horror game with combat, puzzles, lore and no copyright violations apperaing

Databrawl- Combat focused game with lore and no copyright violations as of the current version

Ronald- Horror game with a scene with fighting it it and a story and no copyright violations besides the main antagonist being based off of Ronald McDonald some and a minor character based off of Grimance appearing
Seems fine imo
 
Personally, I don’t think Dinosaur Simulator should stay as a verse. It’s literally a simulator about playing as a dinosaur and growing up, getting DNA by aging, and getting new dinos. It’s only “lore” is unique original dinosaurs it adds, but those are effectively just OCs and there’s virtually no lore behind any of them.

Also, it only has 2 profiles, both of which seem outdated.
Yeah, I can see your point on that. Profiles haven't been updated since several stat revisions in the game iirc. Could nuke them if you'd like.
 
Yeah, I can see your point on that. Profiles haven't been updated since several stat revisions in the game iirc. Could nuke them if you'd like.
Definitely seems viable here, so I think that’s something to go on the list of nukes.

I’ll try to keep track of a list of verses we are nuking. So far, we seemingly have 2.

1. Dinosaur Simulator

2. Super Nostalgia Zone
 
I don't know much about Roblox and before reading this I thought it was a game similar to Minecraft. But after reading through it, I suppose Zanybrainy makes sense. I would definitely disagree with nuking every single RPG maker verse and merging it all as "RPG Maker" verse. If Roblox is more or less a platform to make games rather than a specific game franchise, then Roblox should not be considered a verse with the various franchises made using roblox being considered legit verses.
 
I don't know much about Roblox and before reading this I thought it was a game similar to Minecraft. But after reading through it, I suppose Zanybrainy makes sense. I would definitely disagree with nuking every single RPG maker verse and merging it all as "RPG Maker" verse. If Roblox is more or less a platform to make games rather than a specific game franchise, then Roblox should not be considered a verse with the various franchises made using roblox being considered legit verses.
Yep, it’s a platform to make games. We’re basically saying if the game has proper lore and a proper story and such, that it can stay. Anything else gets nuked.
 
It's a game platform; we need to exercise some discretion and make this a case-by-case thing rather than allowing every Roblox game through, but they're not exactly against any rules by default, so long as they have their own lore and feats and blah blah blah. It's a similar case as to Mugen games; they can be unique narratives with their own characters and feats, i.e. the Black Heart.
 
So should I make a list of verses that have been accepted to have profiles, verses that currently aren't allowed to have profiles, and verses where nothing has been decided on?
 
I can help you on that

Tho we can agree that Survive the Killers games are not allowed since they have games that has copyrighted characters like Slenderman


and Marvel Tycoon Games or just Tycoon Games in general are banned imo
 
I decided to make the list

Verses allowed so far
  • The Stalker
  • Isle
  • Piggy
  • Databrawl
  • Ronald
  • Fantastic Frontier
  • Monster Islands
  • Mad City
  • Jailbreak
  • SwordBurst Online
  • Zealous Fighters
  • Elemental Battlegrounds
  • Phantom Forces
  • Shark Bite
  • Zombie Attack
Verses not allowed
  • Super Nostalgic Zone (Plotless without any crazy feats)
  • Dinosaur Simulator (Lack of lore and is a game about simulating dinosaurs)
  • Black Magic (The speed is wrong)
  • Tycoon games
 
Last edited:
I decided to make the list

Verses allowed so far
  • The Stalker
  • Isle
  • Piggy
  • Databrawl
  • Ronald
Verses not allowed
  • Super Nostalgic Zone (Plotless without any crazy feats)
  • Dinosaur Simulator (Lack of lore and is a game about simulating dinosaurs)
  • Black Magic (The speed is wrong)
Undecided verses
  • Fantastic Frontier
  • Monster Islands
  • Elemental Battlegrounds
  • Swordburst Online
  • Zealous Fighter
  • Jailbreak
  • Mad City
  • Phantom Forces
  • Shark Bite
  • Zombie Attack
I meant BM's verse page/profiles getting deleted since the stats are outdated. It's its own setting with valid lore, game provides visuals to the existing lore I think.

For the undecided:

  • Fantastic Frontier Has a setting with its own characters. Should be fine.
  • Monster Islands: Same as above.
  • Elemental Battlegrounds: Game doesn't really have any established lore, but there are descriptions for the abilities of every element that explain how spells work, such as Earth's Meteor Declivity pulling meteors from the sky. Definitely able to gauge feats here, but there isn't a consistent setting.
  • Swordburst Online: Unsure
  • Zealous Fighters: Unsure
  • Jailbreak: Unsure
  • Mad City: It's a game about cops and heroes trying to stop criminals within a city. There are various events within the game's setting that have influenced it in different ways (most notably, Cluckle's birthday bash - which caused the collective of the criminals, heroes, villains and cops to nuke the entire city, changing the landscape in the process)
  • Phantom Forces: Unsure
  • Shark Bite: Minigame-esque game where players fight a shark that can casually destroy boats. Definitely able to gauge feats, but there isn't a super established setting.
  • Zombie Attack: Unsure
 
So if you just made a CRT, it could be fixed and saved?
I'm very lazy with profiles atm. Would rather have it nuked for now. I can recreate the verse page at a later point in time. Plan I have ATM is to create profiles for the real important characters like Aominoa and Eoh.
 
Zombie Attack: Has original characters and it is basically about killing zombies and bosses (I think it stays imo)

Jailbreak: Pretty much like Mad City and it also has its own characters as well and iirc they had a boss battle before
 
I'm very lazy with profiles atm. Would rather have it nuked for now. I can recreate the verse page at a later point in time. Plan I have ATM is to create profiles for the real important characters like Aominoa and Eoh.
mk then, i’m not exactly interested in going through black magic looking for feats/lore myself
 
mk then, i’m not exactly interested in going through black magic looking for feats/lore myself
Good choice. Had to go through hell trying to find the lore docs for the game. While there are feats for the characters in BM1/BM2, how they exactly scale to one another or if there is lore for the classes in question are a real nuisance to find.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top