- 2,485
- 309
https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/505298#77
https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/505298#79
Ok, so I wanted to highlight and discuss the ratings we've given to the Tier 6-B's in LOL as most of them have nothing justifying their rank save for scaling to Anivia & Lissandra without a proper reason to justify the scaling. This is only for AP and Durability stats, with other outdated stats to be replaced by the standard stats we use. It'll be a bit long so bear with me.
The champs in question are:
Freljord
Anivia, Lissandra, Ashe, Sejuani
Shurima
Azir, Xerath, Nasus, Renekton
Aspects of Targo
Leona, Pantheon, Diana, Taric
Celestials
Bard, Soraka
Others
Jax, Wukong, Aatrox, Illaoi, Jericho Swain, Jarvan Lightshield IV, Brand
Main Problems
Most of the stat justifications are nothing more than "A is a B/C/D, can do something, is said to be super strong/is a leader of nation/on par with E/F/G and so is comparable to every other 6-B character in game, including Anivia and Lissandra". My problem with this is that there are no valid sources supporting most of them (like lore feats/developer statements/etc.), especially old lore feats, which are now outdated since the Institute of War and the League itself was retconned away, and if there are any feats, they haven't been properly quantified. Thus, it comes off as very inaccurate when compared to their lore where there isn't anything that proves that they do deserve their current stats. Jax, Wukong and Illaoi are examples of this. Jax himself has 2 sections in his lore: one for Pre-Retcon and one for Post-Retcon when only the Post-Retcon lore should matter as it's the official one approved by Riot.
There is also the problem of scaling characters who have no real connections/interactions with each other and haven't really shown that they are comparable to each other (for example, saying that Aatrox is a Darkin, one of the strongest races in Runeterra and so should be comparable to Ascendants, Lissandra and Anivia). They haven't encountered each other at all save in the Rift (which isn't canon anymore) and there is a logical jump taken to think that just because they are the strongest in their region (Demacia, Noxus) that they can take on what is basically an immortal cryophoenix who can cause blizzards when dying without any hard evidence like interaction/feats/WoG to suggest that they are on the same scale. Same goes for Ascendants, the Freljord Triangle, the Darkin and the Targonian Aspects. It'd be like saying that Krillin and the Androids are comparable to Goku and Vegeta as they are the strongest beings on DB Earth. Sure, they're stronger than almost everyone else, but no one would put Krillin in the same tier as Goku or Vegeta simply because he doesn't have the feats.
I'd rather rate them based on what feats they've shown, plus scaling within their groups/regions they are from (like Xerath, Nasus, Renekton and Azir should all be comparable, with possibly Xerath as the strongest due to his Ascension). Jarvan and Swain then get scaled to other Demacian/Noxian champs, Aspects within each other and so on. I'll list down the changes below based on regions:
Note: If not specified, the changes would be scaled to Garen's stats, since we've been using those for most of the updated profiles (This may change in future updates if Garen's lore doesn't support those stats, as in he is shown to be hurt by normal blades and such, aka Tier 9-8 stuff). I'll also be using the lore given on Universe for most of the changes, as they're the main source of current official lore (save for a few which Riot haven't updated yet). The LOL wiki has many unsourced statements, so using them as evidence is not possible unless there is an official source.
Freljord
The scaling here was Anivia = Lissandra = Ashe = Sejuani (the last 2 because they had supposedly fought evenly in the past, though there is no proof that such an event ever happened).
Anivia ― No real changes needed, only a few questions regarding creating blizzards and durability. Does it count as Environmental Destruction, and if so, would it affect her stats in anyway? Also, would we rate her as a glass cannon (as in high AP but low Durability) or just assume her to have similar AP & Durability unless shown otherwise (as neither examples have been shown)? If changes occur, then they follow the wiki standard.
Lissandra ― Same questions as above (in her case, does being an Iceborn affect her stats in any way?), and get rid of the base & full power ratings, as the League doesn't exist anymore and in her lore, there's no mention of her sealing her own power. We also don't know if she can freeze the world over by herself, only that she wants to, so 6-A is not possible. Scaling to Brand/the Frozen Watchers is also not possible as Brand's lore has no mention on how strong he really is, just that he wants to burn the world and the same applies to the Watchers. Downgrade to 6-B.
Ashe & Sejuani ― These two are tricky, as they haven't fought Lissandra, Anivia or each other yet (it's not mentioned anywhere) so scaling them via that is not possible. They also haven't shown any feats on that level so I would downgrade them to the standard level. While Ashe has shown that she awakened her own hidden power when using Avarosa's bow, and it's likely that Sejuani has her own powers, nothing revealed so far supports the hypothesis that they could take on Liss by themselves (we don't know a lot about True Ice weapons and such, and how Liss would deal with attacks from them). Downgrade both to Standard level, possibly higher AP only depending on how strong their True Ice weapons and magical powers combined are.
Shurima
Note: Ascendants have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
The scaling here was and should be basically Xerath at the top followed by Azir, Nasus and Renekton in no order, scaled from Nasus, with the Country level stuff coming from equating their power to Anivia/Lissandra's power. Xerath is at the top due to him being stronger than the average Ascendant due to specific circumstances.
Nasus -Was shown to be wounded by a sword in his short story Ouroboros, but could send people flying 30 feet with a swing and cause a small sandstorm in Bloodline. Also, fought against Xerath and caused a lot of damage to the cities in which they fought. This would be a downgrade to standard levels, maybe higher by scaling to other Ascendants. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Renekton ― Should be superior physically to Nasus (as he was a powerful warrior to Nasus' scholar) but has not shown any Country level feats, so a downgrade like Nasus. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Azir ― When revived as an Ascendant, he raised the entire city of Shurima, including the massive gold sun-disc in without effort (in his video) by manipulating the sand and the disc. Should be comparable to other Ascended, so a downgrade due to lack of Country level feats. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C or higher via Telekinesis) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Xerath ― Was causing a lot of damage to Verakura in Bloodline and proved himself superior to Nasus when they fought, however no Country level feats means a downgrade. Should be superior to Azir due to taking in a lot of magic by hijacking Azir's Ascension. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C or higher by scaling to Azir) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Aspects of Targo
Note: Aspects have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
The scaling here is Leona = Diana = Pantheon = Taric, with Country level stuff coming from equating their power to that of Anivia/Lissandra's. They should still be equal with each other.
Leona ― She can summon a ray of solar energy from the sky and draws her powers from the sun, but nothing shown that would warrant her being kept at her current tier. So, this would be a downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Pantheon ― Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Diana - Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Taric - Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Celestials
Note: Celestials have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra, however there are some statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so some scaling is possible here.
Both characters have circular scaling linking back to the Ascendants, the Aspects and each other, however, any mention of Celestial power is not available, so I'm not sure where to exactly put them.
Bard ― No real info on where he stands in the rankings, but should be superior to the likes of Anivia/Lissandra as a Celestial, so should be around 6-B. No real changes unless or until we get more info.
Soraka ― As a Celestial, should be equal to Bard. Same as above.
Others
Note: These characters have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
Everyone here was scaled to Anivia/Lissandra via the League, save for Illaoi, who had one line (without sources or explanation) justifying her stats. As the League is non-canon, no real reason to keep outdated and incorrect info on the profiles.
Jax ― Old lore has been retconned, so no need to keep it and any stats based on it at all. New lore does not have him stomping Garen, as it is not mentioned anywhere in Garen's or Jax's lore and Riot hasn't given any hint of a connection between him and Jax. Garen is one of Jarvan IV's personal bodyguards as part of the Dauntless Vanguard, not a random soldier working for Fiora's family and trying to evict Jax from her bridge. Still should get standard rating by rough scaling from Fiora (who was about to fight him at the end of Jax's story). Downgrade to Standard level.
Wukong ― Old lore has been retconned, so no need to keep it and any stats based on it at all. New lore has him training with Yi and no connections to Jax, so one can scale him to Yi. Should still get the standard level. Downgrade to Standard level.
Aatrox -No real updates anytime soon, and his lore doesn't say much about how strong he really is. Falls into the same category as the Aspects where no feats of note are really shown, so he should be downgraded. Downgrade to Standard level.
Illaoi ― The Black Mist is unquantified, and nothing in the lore suggests that she fought all of it off, only that she faced the strongest spirits (like Hecarim as an example). So, a downgrade here. Downgrade to Standard level.
Jericho Swain ― Same as Jax & Wukong, in that the old lore is gone, no need to rate him by it. While his current lore doesn't say much about his power, he is the current leader of Noxus, where meritocracy is praised and powerful leaders are valued. He will be getting lore updates when the Urgot rework comes out in 4 months for a Noxus story event, but until then, a downgrade for him. Downgrade to Standard level.
Jarvan Lightshield IV ― Same as above, nothing more to say. Not sure if really superior to Garen/Fiora, but should still be on the same level as them. Downgrade to Standard level.
Brand ― Brand's tricky, as nothing in his current lore on Universe gives any concrete info about his power level, however, he was mentioned in Shuriman lore as a threat to the Ascended (Nasus and Renekton once had to seal him in a magical sarcophagus, which they later tried to use against Xerath) and he was later found in True Ice (the fire spirit, not his current flesh body, Kegan Rodhe). Nothing to justify his current stats though, so a downgrade for him. Downgrade to Standard level.
Overall, those are the changes I want to propose, so discuss away on whether the updates/changes should be implemented or not.
https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/505298#79
Ok, so I wanted to highlight and discuss the ratings we've given to the Tier 6-B's in LOL as most of them have nothing justifying their rank save for scaling to Anivia & Lissandra without a proper reason to justify the scaling. This is only for AP and Durability stats, with other outdated stats to be replaced by the standard stats we use. It'll be a bit long so bear with me.
The champs in question are:
Freljord
Anivia, Lissandra, Ashe, Sejuani
Shurima
Azir, Xerath, Nasus, Renekton
Aspects of Targo
Leona, Pantheon, Diana, Taric
Celestials
Bard, Soraka
Others
Jax, Wukong, Aatrox, Illaoi, Jericho Swain, Jarvan Lightshield IV, Brand
Main Problems
Most of the stat justifications are nothing more than "A is a B/C/D, can do something, is said to be super strong/is a leader of nation/on par with E/F/G and so is comparable to every other 6-B character in game, including Anivia and Lissandra". My problem with this is that there are no valid sources supporting most of them (like lore feats/developer statements/etc.), especially old lore feats, which are now outdated since the Institute of War and the League itself was retconned away, and if there are any feats, they haven't been properly quantified. Thus, it comes off as very inaccurate when compared to their lore where there isn't anything that proves that they do deserve their current stats. Jax, Wukong and Illaoi are examples of this. Jax himself has 2 sections in his lore: one for Pre-Retcon and one for Post-Retcon when only the Post-Retcon lore should matter as it's the official one approved by Riot.
There is also the problem of scaling characters who have no real connections/interactions with each other and haven't really shown that they are comparable to each other (for example, saying that Aatrox is a Darkin, one of the strongest races in Runeterra and so should be comparable to Ascendants, Lissandra and Anivia). They haven't encountered each other at all save in the Rift (which isn't canon anymore) and there is a logical jump taken to think that just because they are the strongest in their region (Demacia, Noxus) that they can take on what is basically an immortal cryophoenix who can cause blizzards when dying without any hard evidence like interaction/feats/WoG to suggest that they are on the same scale. Same goes for Ascendants, the Freljord Triangle, the Darkin and the Targonian Aspects. It'd be like saying that Krillin and the Androids are comparable to Goku and Vegeta as they are the strongest beings on DB Earth. Sure, they're stronger than almost everyone else, but no one would put Krillin in the same tier as Goku or Vegeta simply because he doesn't have the feats.
I'd rather rate them based on what feats they've shown, plus scaling within their groups/regions they are from (like Xerath, Nasus, Renekton and Azir should all be comparable, with possibly Xerath as the strongest due to his Ascension). Jarvan and Swain then get scaled to other Demacian/Noxian champs, Aspects within each other and so on. I'll list down the changes below based on regions:
Note: If not specified, the changes would be scaled to Garen's stats, since we've been using those for most of the updated profiles (This may change in future updates if Garen's lore doesn't support those stats, as in he is shown to be hurt by normal blades and such, aka Tier 9-8 stuff). I'll also be using the lore given on Universe for most of the changes, as they're the main source of current official lore (save for a few which Riot haven't updated yet). The LOL wiki has many unsourced statements, so using them as evidence is not possible unless there is an official source.
Freljord
The scaling here was Anivia = Lissandra = Ashe = Sejuani (the last 2 because they had supposedly fought evenly in the past, though there is no proof that such an event ever happened).
Anivia ― No real changes needed, only a few questions regarding creating blizzards and durability. Does it count as Environmental Destruction, and if so, would it affect her stats in anyway? Also, would we rate her as a glass cannon (as in high AP but low Durability) or just assume her to have similar AP & Durability unless shown otherwise (as neither examples have been shown)? If changes occur, then they follow the wiki standard.
Lissandra ― Same questions as above (in her case, does being an Iceborn affect her stats in any way?), and get rid of the base & full power ratings, as the League doesn't exist anymore and in her lore, there's no mention of her sealing her own power. We also don't know if she can freeze the world over by herself, only that she wants to, so 6-A is not possible. Scaling to Brand/the Frozen Watchers is also not possible as Brand's lore has no mention on how strong he really is, just that he wants to burn the world and the same applies to the Watchers. Downgrade to 6-B.
Ashe & Sejuani ― These two are tricky, as they haven't fought Lissandra, Anivia or each other yet (it's not mentioned anywhere) so scaling them via that is not possible. They also haven't shown any feats on that level so I would downgrade them to the standard level. While Ashe has shown that she awakened her own hidden power when using Avarosa's bow, and it's likely that Sejuani has her own powers, nothing revealed so far supports the hypothesis that they could take on Liss by themselves (we don't know a lot about True Ice weapons and such, and how Liss would deal with attacks from them). Downgrade both to Standard level, possibly higher AP only depending on how strong their True Ice weapons and magical powers combined are.
Shurima
Note: Ascendants have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
The scaling here was and should be basically Xerath at the top followed by Azir, Nasus and Renekton in no order, scaled from Nasus, with the Country level stuff coming from equating their power to Anivia/Lissandra's power. Xerath is at the top due to him being stronger than the average Ascendant due to specific circumstances.
Nasus -Was shown to be wounded by a sword in his short story Ouroboros, but could send people flying 30 feet with a swing and cause a small sandstorm in Bloodline. Also, fought against Xerath and caused a lot of damage to the cities in which they fought. This would be a downgrade to standard levels, maybe higher by scaling to other Ascendants. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Renekton ― Should be superior physically to Nasus (as he was a powerful warrior to Nasus' scholar) but has not shown any Country level feats, so a downgrade like Nasus. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Azir ― When revived as an Ascendant, he raised the entire city of Shurima, including the massive gold sun-disc in without effort (in his video) by manipulating the sand and the disc. Should be comparable to other Ascended, so a downgrade due to lack of Country level feats. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C or higher via Telekinesis) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Xerath ― Was causing a lot of damage to Verakura in Bloodline and proved himself superior to Nasus when they fought, however no Country level feats means a downgrade. Should be superior to Azir due to taking in a lot of magic by hijacking Azir's Ascension. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (7-C or higher by scaling to Azir) due to status as Ascendant/possible scaling to other Ascendants.
Aspects of Targo
Note: Aspects have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
The scaling here is Leona = Diana = Pantheon = Taric, with Country level stuff coming from equating their power to that of Anivia/Lissandra's. They should still be equal with each other.
Leona ― She can summon a ray of solar energy from the sky and draws her powers from the sun, but nothing shown that would warrant her being kept at her current tier. So, this would be a downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Pantheon ― Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Diana - Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Taric - Should be equal to Leona, so downgrade. Downgrade to Standard level, possibly higher (?) due to status as Aspect.
Celestials
Note: Celestials have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra, however there are some statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so some scaling is possible here.
Both characters have circular scaling linking back to the Ascendants, the Aspects and each other, however, any mention of Celestial power is not available, so I'm not sure where to exactly put them.
Bard ― No real info on where he stands in the rankings, but should be superior to the likes of Anivia/Lissandra as a Celestial, so should be around 6-B. No real changes unless or until we get more info.
Soraka ― As a Celestial, should be equal to Bard. Same as above.
Others
Note: These characters have never shown any interaction with Anivia/Lissandra and there are no statements suggesting that they are as strong as them so no scaling is possible here.
Everyone here was scaled to Anivia/Lissandra via the League, save for Illaoi, who had one line (without sources or explanation) justifying her stats. As the League is non-canon, no real reason to keep outdated and incorrect info on the profiles.
Jax ― Old lore has been retconned, so no need to keep it and any stats based on it at all. New lore does not have him stomping Garen, as it is not mentioned anywhere in Garen's or Jax's lore and Riot hasn't given any hint of a connection between him and Jax. Garen is one of Jarvan IV's personal bodyguards as part of the Dauntless Vanguard, not a random soldier working for Fiora's family and trying to evict Jax from her bridge. Still should get standard rating by rough scaling from Fiora (who was about to fight him at the end of Jax's story). Downgrade to Standard level.
Wukong ― Old lore has been retconned, so no need to keep it and any stats based on it at all. New lore has him training with Yi and no connections to Jax, so one can scale him to Yi. Should still get the standard level. Downgrade to Standard level.
Aatrox -No real updates anytime soon, and his lore doesn't say much about how strong he really is. Falls into the same category as the Aspects where no feats of note are really shown, so he should be downgraded. Downgrade to Standard level.
Illaoi ― The Black Mist is unquantified, and nothing in the lore suggests that she fought all of it off, only that she faced the strongest spirits (like Hecarim as an example). So, a downgrade here. Downgrade to Standard level.
Jericho Swain ― Same as Jax & Wukong, in that the old lore is gone, no need to rate him by it. While his current lore doesn't say much about his power, he is the current leader of Noxus, where meritocracy is praised and powerful leaders are valued. He will be getting lore updates when the Urgot rework comes out in 4 months for a Noxus story event, but until then, a downgrade for him. Downgrade to Standard level.
Jarvan Lightshield IV ― Same as above, nothing more to say. Not sure if really superior to Garen/Fiora, but should still be on the same level as them. Downgrade to Standard level.
Brand ― Brand's tricky, as nothing in his current lore on Universe gives any concrete info about his power level, however, he was mentioned in Shuriman lore as a threat to the Ascended (Nasus and Renekton once had to seal him in a magical sarcophagus, which they later tried to use against Xerath) and he was later found in True Ice (the fire spirit, not his current flesh body, Kegan Rodhe). Nothing to justify his current stats though, so a downgrade for him. Downgrade to Standard level.
Overall, those are the changes I want to propose, so discuss away on whether the updates/changes should be implemented or not.