• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Kirby and fiction in general: No proof for magic Ôëá physical strength?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
409
Reaction score
13
No preamble; a good argument is that characters' offensive magic is the same level as their physical strength, but they may be lower levels tha their magic types they perform their biggest feats with.

Seriously, since there's difference in power between lifting strength and striking strength, how can there not be such difference also between magic types?

Also seriously:

1) In the SSB series, also created by Sakurai, Master Hand proves to be able to create universes, yet…

a. He fails to fly through Tabuu's effortlessly created thin energy wall, like Ganondorf failed to deflect the same opponent's charged large energy ball.

b. He's defeated by one fighter near the end of "World of Light", so even if Classic Modes hadn't been canon prior to Ultimate's release, they are now.

2) In Kid Icarus: Uprising, also directed by Sakurai, Palutena proves to be capable of impressive supernatural feats, yet she could barely defeat Pit (a), who is comparable to Magnus (b), who is barely strong for a Human.

a. She can obliterate any of the two with her most powerful attack, but needs half a minute to charge it.

b. Pit defeats Magnus and Gaol in a battle, but the opponents mustn't use their full strength, given how they speak.

3) In the Kirby series, Dedede helps the puffball defeat Magolor, who can do impressive magic feats, yet he needs his power increased as Masked Dedede to knock down a small rock statue with an axe swing and another one with three magic balls.

"You're saying that not only are the characters' offensive magic and physical strength lower levels than their other magic types but also they're below small rock statue level and its equivalents?"

1) That instance is just a first proof.

2) Dedede also needs three hammer swings to smash a small boulder in a cavern of Ripple Star.

3) Kirby needs the Starship to destroy the columns generating the force field protecting the first Nova's core, as supported in the earlier cutscene.

- BTW, the core being left unprotected afterward would be pointless if it weren't hit by Marx later.

- And he's sent flying by the hero but stops and flashes prior to flying?

- For starters, the latter has to summon the Nova because he can't stop the moon-sized sun and moon from fighting.

4) He can't destroy Dyna Blade's armor, as supported in her trophy description in Brawl.

5) Neither can he destroy the Halberd's Combo Cannon without Star Bullets or Copy Abilities, or its wings, reactor, or bridge directly, as supported in the dialogues.

6) He gets exhausted and hungry in a desert after gathering all the Crystal's shards on Rock Star.

7) He can't open the Star Door without the Star Seals.

8) He doesn't jump to the rising Taranza and Dedede to even try to rescue the latter from the former.

9) He fails to break free from Sectonia's left vine while she's not even squeezing him yet.

10) The catchphrase that he can inhale anything was taken at face value for Hypernova so that he can actually do what he says he can and players get surprised by seeing him inhale larger objects, the first of which is a tree barely taller than one meter in what must be a cutscene, given how the background changes, how the camera moves, and the health meter going away.

11) He needs Pon and Con to open the Jambastion's gate and enter the fortress.

12) He needs a Friend Star to destroy the boulders inside the Jambastion and escape its collapse, as supported in the cutscene and later image at the level's end .

Outliers? In order to know that, we need at least 13 proofs; and no, they can be from mini-games only if there are already at least 13 proofs from main modes.

No conclusion, either.
 
You can ask some active and experienced members listed in the Kirby (Universe) page to comment here.
 
If I do that, someone may say I'm harassing them, so I prefer waiting for whoever has good objections.

BTW, this isn't only about the Kirby game series, but fiction in general.

For example, in the Dragon Ball franchise, not created by Sakurai, Shenlong proves to be capable of impressive supernatural feats, yet he's killed by Piccolo Daimaō.
 
Nothing is likely going to happen here unless you follow my above recommendation.
 
Ok, I summon DarkDragonMedeus for anytime after New Year's Day, as I've debated him previously and I know he can have healthy debates, but let's let him read this first.

I'd also like everyone else to take the difference in power between physical power and magic/reality warping power as a possibility for other verses.
 
Preferably not, Ant. According to Eficiente, this guy is notorious for trying to downgrade Kirby on such an irrational scale. He was even warn for it in the past.

What exactly are you trying to prove and debunk here? None of this makes any sense. It all seems like massive downplay, and you're now only getting desperate. Most of the claims you are trying to make and back up can either be regarded as satire and/or gameplay/plot point elements.

Kirby's scaling isn't 100% consistent but that goes for a lot of verses on the wiki, and we as members try to ignore them and focus on the more legitmate aspects. The Hulk being beaten up by gorillas or The Spectre being harmed by Batman fits into this category, and those are considered illegitimate to their own scaling, and might be classified as outliers or Plot-Induced Stupidity. A lot of the claims you are showing here can be considered that as well.

We don't focus on the inconsistencies or outliers of a verse and contribute them accordingly. We address and contribute to the most accurate and legitimate feats demonstrated from the verse.
 
You can ask Eficiente to comment here then. After that we can probably close this.
 
EMagoIorSouI said:
Wall of text
1) Then please point out at least two proofs for Non-offensive magic power = Offensive magic power and physical power.

2) Afterward, point out at least 12 proofs for Kirby's strength being above small rock statue level and its equivalents.

- Again, "him destroying the first Nova by sending Marx flying into it" was debunked in my second point 3.

- Also again, proofs from mini-games don't count until there are already 12 proofs in main modes.
 
Wait, this is the Kirby downplayer I've been hearing about?
 
Yeah. He is not as bad as some of the downplayers on the site. Honestly, his problem is that he does not really address the high end feats and overly focuses on short comings that can also come from game mechanics and PIS. If we had someone like him for every verse, debates would be chaos and there would be nothing but setbacks.
 
Antvasima said:
You can ask Eficiente to comment here then. After that we can probably close this.
^
 
KageSakaDark said:
Yeah. He is not as bad as some of the downplayers on the site. Honestly, his problem is that he does not really address the high end feats and overly focuses on short comings that can also come from game mechanics and PIS. If we had someone like him for every verse, debates would be chaos and there would be nothing but setbacks.
I don't address "high-end feats"?

1) I've debunked "Magolor's defeat causing a universe's collapse."

But, you want me to address more?

2) Sectonia isn't really merged with the then planet-sized Dreamstalk; it doesn't die along with her, which means she's just attached to it and transformed, and it actually makes Pop Star serve as her eternal sustenance and increases her power a little.

- This is how her final beam makes Kirby struggle barely thrice as much as that tree in the cutscene pointed out in my point 10.

3) He destroys the second Nova indirectly and by taking advantage of its weak point; he uses Star Dream as a screw with the Robobot Armor's screwdriver and must use the former as a stake to strike the Nova's core.

- BTW, he faints from exhaustion after leaving the Nova from below, as he also did after defeating Dark Matter and Magolor, and as he also does after defeating Void Termina.

4) And again, I've debunked the "first Nova feat."
 
I see that low-end instances are only seen as outliers by opponents no matter how many they are...

and that "high-end" ones being really high-end must be debunked first.

Someone had claimed I don't have any proof for magic power Ôëá physical power, and I wanted to show that I do, but that needed to include low-end instances and then...

Well, lesson learned.
 
Antvasima said:
You can ask Eficiente to comment here then. After that we can probably close this.
Anyone?
 
I've restored the thread, as I have another piece of evidence now.

In order for the 12 instances to be outliers, there have to be at least 13 proofs from main modes now.
 
some of these inconsistent moments are arguable at best 1. notice how he does these 2 things with ease.

2. these scenes with Kirby getting help from his friends are inconsistent. d3 goes from taking 3 hits ( without charging btw ) to destroy a boulder, to sending Kirby and ribbon to the center of dark star just by smash his hammer on the ground https://youtu.be/c-UlE5J81Js?t=330

3. he needs it because 1, he was knocked out by Marx, and 2 he couldn't go to nova by hovering before it went to popstar, neither did he even have a warp star. he stops for a second, then flies away, but that's in gameplay, in the cutscene he is clearly sent flying backwards https://youtu.be/81ub2ze2nMA?t=283 I wonder who was the one who sent him backwards. I like how you assume he the sun is moon sized instead of the other way around. anyways, Kirby of course can't do that because he can't get any copy abilities. the game doesn't make Kirby go to the sun and moon.

4. that... shows how tough her armor is. being able to take hits from Kirby.

5. "without star bullets and copy abilities" heh y'know the things he has been doing ever since 1993

6. these scenes are clearly for comedic purpose so shouldn't be taken as literal. how does this relate to AP again?

7. the word star from star door speaks for itself

8. how is this AP related? and why would Kirby do that if he doesn't know Tarzana intentions or who he even is

9. again doesn't relate to Ap but I think even the naked eye could see that the vine is squeezing him. why else would he be screaming?

10. doesn't relate to Ap.

11. as there pause description states, "they wont let anyone though without a fight" meaning that they have some holy power to open it unlike Kirby.

12. ... what's wrong with Kirby doing that? he was destroying the boulders to clear a way.


this dudes a troll really. only wanting to downgrade 1 verse. Antvasima, please close this.
 
1) He moves the axe backward for the physical blow and charges power for the magic balls.


2.1) Still three hammer swings and a small boulder.

2.2) He sends two characters lighter than 5 kg flying at only m/s and from the surface upward.


3.1) Him being knocked out by Marx has nothing to do with the need for anything.

3.2) Him not having a Warp Star doesn't stop any from getting to him instead of the Starship.

3.3) Marx stopping doesn't affect the gameplay, so it's not a game mechanic.

3.4) Why doesn't the game let him go to the sun and moon, if not because he can't stop them from fighting? Seriously, Marx tells him they need the Nova's help.


4) That argument assumes he's OP, for which we need at least 13 proofs from main modes.

5) Please show one cutscene in which he defeats a boss or mid-boss with his bare limbs.


6.1) Not those showing a story progression.

6.2) Stamina relates to physical strength, which the thread is actually about.


7) Which grants the door some durability, but how much?

8) Taranza kidnapped Dedede, nuff said.

9) He screams after the vine squeezes him and tries to break free prior to that.

10) Inhaling strength is a type of physical strength.

11) It definitely doesn't mean that.

12) With the Friend Star's projectiles.
 
I know a fair bit about Kirby. I'll comment in a moment.
 
  • No preamble; a good argument is that characters' offensive magic is the same level as their physical strength, but they may be lower levels tha their magic types they perform their biggest feats with.
Seriously, since there's difference in power between lifting strength and striking strength, how can there not be such difference also between magic types?
If a character has clearly defined different spells, one could normally assume they vary in power. However, across most fiction, it is pretty readily shown that a character's spells or abilities will all tend to be able to hurt the same class of enemies, with only occasional outliers. An example of different 'weapon/attack types' not scaling to each other would be as simple as Nuclear Throne. However, these cases are rarer than not. So, you're right, but it's not that easy.

  • Also seriously:
1) In the SSB series, also created by Sakurai, Master Hand proves to be able to create universes, yet…
a. He fails to fly through Tabuu's effortlessly created thin energy wall, like Ganondorf failed to deflect the same opponent's charged large energy ball.
Well, yes, They're the same tier, and Tabuu is stronger. Of course Master Hand can't easily pass Tabuu's defenses.

Video game logic can be odd. It's possible to beat Minecraft with a wooden sword. You could argue for a massive upgrade for SSB characters, but that's not the point of this thread.

Humans in different verses can vary in power. Such as that guy in the latter clip, who was clearly beyond superhuman. I don't see how winning against Pit means anything.

Then such should be mentioned on her profile, alongside a 'Higher'.

Okay. Your point is..?

Have you heard the story of accurate attack potency? Where every Dragon Ball Z punch destroys the planet they are on instantly? No? Inaccuracies exist, and any verse above Tier 8 with 100% consistent AP effects will fall apart very fast.

  • "You're saying that not only are the characters' offensive magic and physical strength lower levels than their other magic types but also they're below small rock statue level and its equivalents?"
The first part is true. If one magical move has been proved to one-shot enemies, but the rest of their arsenal doesn't... That's pretty self-explanatory.

  • 1) That instance is just a first proof.
2) Dedede also needs three hammer swings to smash a small boulder in a cavern of Ripple Star.
What, you expect Sakurai to create purely galaxy-sized boulders just to satisfy us versus battles debaters?

  • 3) Kirby needs the Starship to destroy the columns generating the force field protecting the first Nova's core, as supported in the earlier cutscene.
I'll say this again. You'll be challenged to find any video game verse fit your standards of high-tier if you purely judge things by random video game battles. Making battles large enough to support high tier characters 100% doesn't make a great story.

  • - BTW, the core being left unprotected afterward would be pointless if it weren't hit by Marx later.
Okay.

  • - And he's sent flying by the hero but stops and flashes prior to flying?
I don't see your point.

  • - For starters, the latter has to summon the Nova because he can't stop the moon-sized sun and moon from fighting.
Entities that are powerful enough to grant him the immense power he gained afterwards. I'm not sure what the problem is, here, and I fail to see how size matters. If he couldn't stop Goku from fighting instead, would he be Street Level via Goku being the size of a human..?

Cool, Dyna Blade has strong armor.

  • 5) Neither can he destroy the Halberd's Combo Cannon without Star Bullets or Copy Abilities, or its wings, reactor, or bridge directly, as supported in the dialogues.
Okay. See above.

Stamina has little to do with AP.

It's clearly magical. Why would he be able to?

  • 8) He doesn't jump to the rising Taranza and Dedede to even try to rescue the latter from the former.
This has absolutely nothing to do with AP.

Sectonia is stronger than him.

I'm fairly sure we say he can only eat a certain size of enemies on this wiki. Correct me if I am wrong. Nothing to do with AP.

Why do all your arguments come down to "Kirby didn't One Punch the obstacle in his path, therefore, he's Tier 9" or something similar?

See above.

12 faulty or off-topic antifeats don't demand 13 true feats.

  • No conclusion, either.
Gotcha. You should have one, though, since you didn't even propose what we change statistics to. I have one, though. In conclusion, I disagree and this is entirely wrong.
 
I'm gonna pick apart the Kid Icarus shit because it annoys me

1. Magnus is not barely strong for a human. He's humanity's strongest soldier. So that's already false.

2. Palutena losing to Pit is not an antifeat for Palutena. It's a feat for Pit. It suggests Pit us at least comparable in strength to Palutena not that Palutena is weak as ****.

3. I don't get your point about Magnus and Gaol
 
damn... I was going to reply back to him but never mind, a debater 10x better then me did it.
 
What the hell is this guy talking about? I'm not sure if I'm just dumb or something, but i can barely understand what he's saying for half of these.
 
I can concur to what you're saying, so you're not dumb. I hardly even know how to rationalize with him because of the lack of weight his reasoning holds, it just seems like massive downplay in my eyes.
 
Eficiente has admitted that he isn't particularly fond of somelatinguy's approach to the Kirby series on the wiki, and has excused his actions as trolling. (According to this thread, at least)
 
It's clearly a massive dowmplay and bad logic. If we followed it Mario would be 9-B, Ness 9-C, etc.. because they have a lots of feats below their tier.
 
Yeah, that goes for a lot of characters on the wiki. They have numerous feats that vary between tiers, but as I stated above we incorporate their best feats, in regards of who they scale to, and/or whether said feat should be deemed as an outlier or not.
 
@Moritzva

Thank you for helping out. So do we need to perform any changes based on this discussion, or can we close this thread?
 
Antvasima said:
@Moritzva
Thank you for helping out. So do we need to perform any changes based on this discussion, or can we close this thread?
No worries.

No, no changes need to be made. I suppose the OP could give a last ditch effort at an argument, but even despite the lack of changes actually proposed in the OP, the reasonings are all quite fallacious.
 
Antvasima said:
@Moritzva
Thank you for helping out. So do we need to perform any changes based on this discussion, or can we close this thread?
Please don't close it; I'm writing my response.
 
Moritzva said:
Wall of text
"If a character… not that easy."

- I'll believe many fictional characters have their supernatural power types at the same levels, but I'll also assume they're literal gods.

- It makes sense that characters' magic types are unequal levels, as magic is learned, just like music is learned and one may be better at violin than at flute.


"Well, yes, they're… pass Tabuu's defenses."

My point is that the universe creator MH is defeated with a thi energy wall from Tabuu and the weaker-in-magic Ganondorf is defeated with a large energy ball also from Tabuu.

"Video game logic… of this thread."

I'd argue for SSB playable characters to be much lower than universe level in offensive magic, strength, and durability.


"Humans in different… Pit means anything."

This part of the dialogue can be interpreted as Kid Icarus humans being human level.

"Then such should… alongside a 'Higher'."

No problem, as long as it's clarified that she couldn't use that attack in a normal battle.

"Ok, you point is…?"

That instance doesn't prove Pit is stronger than Magnus.


"Have you heard… apart very fast."

That doesn't apply to Kirby like it applies to Dragon Ball, as proven below.


1) "The first part… pretty self-explanatory."

Let's begin.

2) "What, you expect… versus battles debaters."

I expect him to create boulder-sized boulders to satisfy the general public.

3.1) "I'll say this… a great story."

The Starship being formed for him would be pointless if he didn't need it for his next mission, so the least problematic interpretation of the instance is that it's formed for him because he needs it.

3.2) "Okay."

Thanks.

3.3) "I don't see your point here."

It's argued that Kirby sends Marx flying with his last attack.

3.4) "Entities that are… of a human…?"

- I don't understand the first part.

- I simply said the sun is the size of the moon, and I wanted to say he can't stop the moon-level sun and moon from fighting.

4) "Cool, Dyna Blade has strong armor."

- It's either that or he's too weak to destroy the armor.

- By Occam's razor, it's the latter, especially given the fact that the armor isn't stated to be made of a special material.

5) "Okay, see above."

Ok.

6) "Stamina has little to do with AP."

It's still related to physical strength, which the thread is actually about.

7) "It's clearly magical. Why would he be able to?"

Its lock being magical doesn't stop physical strength from being able to open it.

8) "This has absolutely nothing to do with AP."

Jumping strength is another type of physical strength (see point 6 again).

9) "Sectonia is stronger than him."

Again, she's not even squeezing him when he tries to break free from the vine.

10) "I'm fairly sure… do with AP."

- The cutscene shows a shallow-rooted 1.4-meters-tall tree, not an enemy.

- Inhaling strength is another type of… Ok, you mayn't have seen I corrected the title of the thread (see point 6 again).

11) "Why do all… or something similar?

Because it's the least problematic interpretation for each of such instances.

12) "See above."

Ok.


"12 faulty or… 13 true facts."

- They're not faulty, as proven above.

- In fact, much of your argumentation commits petitio principii.

- They're not off-topic (see point 6 again).


"Gotcha. You should… is entirely wrong."

Ok, my conclusion is: Power and Stats' structure should be more of less like this…

Tier / Name / Origin / Gender / Age / Classification / Powers and Abilities / Magic/Reality Warping Power (specific types) / Physical strength (specific types) / Speed / Durability / Stamina / Range / Standard equipment / Intelligence / Weaknesses / Notable Attacks/Techniques
 
I can't go over the entirety of the wall of text as of yet, since I am at work and I will be for a while - but I fail to see any reason for the proposal, as any time there is a tier distinction between different types of attacks, it is already noted.

I see no reason to change tens of thousands of profiles for a formatting we already support.
 
Moritzva makes sense to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top