• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece: AP Revision of High Tiers

Status
Not open for further replies.
Enryu_The_Red_Tower

Enryu_The_Red_Tower

4,803
2,530
Well, I guess giving the list of how the affected characters' profiles have been, since they are being cast for Luffy Gear 4th and packing other things:

Doflamingo: 6-C with Black Knight, At least 6-C himself. High 6-C with Awakening and Durability in general as High 6-C

Katakuri: High 6-C

Cracker: Original Cracker - AP High 6-C with At least 6-C, likely higher in Durability. Biscuit Soldier - AP and Durability as At least 6-C

Ace: High 6-C

Marco: High 6-C

Vista: High 6-C

Jack: At least 6-C, likely higher

Luffy: 6-C in Base and Gear 2nd, At least 6-C with Gear 3rd, High 6-C with Gear 4th variants. higher with his Strongest Attacks

Fujitora: At least 6-C, likely higher, with High 6-C Environmental Destructive Capacity

Jozu: High 6-C

Zephyr: Prime - High 6-C. Film Z - At least 6-C

Shiki: Prime - High 6-C and Old Shiki as Unknow

Gild: At least 6-C

Smoothie: High 6-C

Blackbeard: Pre Gura Gura no Mi - High 6-C and Post Gura Gura no Mi - Likely at least High 6-C

Sabo: At least 6-C, likely higher

Zunisha: Likely High 6-C

Inuarashi: At least 6-C, likely higher

Nekomamushi: At least 6-C, likely higher
 
And also now I will talk about adding Immortality Type 2 to Whitebeard. It's quite simple, he had two holes in his chest, pierced by hundreds of swords, shots, and a few dozen cannonballs, and he was still able to fight for a reasonable amount of time after losing half of his head. I think those motives are enough for Immortality Type 2 to Whitebeard to be accepted.

He dies mean he is not immortal
 
Fujitora should be put at At least High 6-C as he should be as strong or at least be comparable to other Admirals, the same should be apply with Prime Zephyr (as he was become the youngest Admiral of the time) and Prime Shiki.

For Luffy i agree with the High 6-C for Gear 4th Variants, but i'm not sure with the Higher with his Strongest Attacks, nothing suggest that he would be able to oneshot Top Yonkou Commanders with his strongest attacks, let alone equally match the power of Admirals ad Yonkou.

And i don't think WB should have Type 2 Immortality, he was able to remain alive after having two holes in his chest (or one hole in the chest and half of his face melted), but he was still fatally injured and he would have eventually die in anycase, even if he was able to escape the war on Marineford along with his crew, so no WB is not immortal he had only insane Endurance.
 
^

I agree with Stefano about everything except "at least high 6-C". I think he should be High 6-C solidly, but without an "at least"
 
I have some objections, but sadly I don't have time to respond tonight. I will write a response to this tomorrow.

I'll just say right now that I also disagree with Type 2 immortality for Whitebeard; he's just got a lot of endurance, not immortality.
 
So in that case I will remove the proposed Immortality Type 2 to Whitbeard and comment about the difference between the Fujitora AP and his EDC.
 
Before this goes through, can I check that it will wait until tomorrow at least because I have a few points about the scaling that may impact these ratings.
 
Stefano4444 said:
Fujitora should be put at At least High 6-C as he should be as strong or at least be comparable to other Admirals, the same should be apply with Prime Zephyr (as he was become the youngest Admiral of the time) and Prime Shiki.
For Luffy i agree with the High 6-C for Gear 4th Variants, but i'm not sure with the Higher with his Strongest Attacks, nothing suggest that he would be able to oneshot Top Yonkou Commanders with his strongest attacks, let alone equally match the power of Admirals ad Yonkou.
Click to expand...
Well Fujitora did not show us or was quoted with him being comparable to other admirals, the most we see is he briefly confronting Luffy Gear 3rd, beat Law without much fuss, stop the bird-cage for a brief period, blocked a Doflamingo attack and have defeated Jack, he literally did not fight with a Top Tiers or easily defeated a High Tier to put in High 6-C, in addition Fuji already has High 6-C with his Environmental Destructive Capacity, and also Prime Zephyr did not show us anything relevant to put on High 6-C, and also just why he trained Akainu, Aokiji and Kizaru does not mean that he is comparable to them adults (since Zephyr trained them in adolescence).

Literally Luffy Gear 4th one-shot Doflamingo, Katakuri (although he got up after the direct hit but then fainted) and Cracker along with his biscuit soldiers with his Strongest Attacks, so we'll just put the "higher" because Luffy Gear 4th with his strongest attacks, managed to destroy Dofla's threads in a direct blow by destroying the God and continuing that they were reinforced with Busōshoku Haki, while with his blows like Gomu Gomu in Double Culverin were not able to destroy them while these threads were without Haki, Tank-Man: Full Version was able to one-shot Cracker and severeal biscuit soldiers that only one of these soldiers was able to effortlessly resist Elephant's 3rd Gear Gear Luffy and King Cobra caused devastating damage to Katakuri to the point of fainting shortly thereafter and Katakuri was able to withstand the normal blows of Bound-Man and Snake-Man with little damage, then it would be appropriate to give Gear 4th Luffy with his Strongest Attacks the "higher"
 
I agree with Luffys strongest Gear 4th attacks (ex: King Kong Gun, Cannonball, and King Kobra) being High 6-C, but I'm not too sure about the form itself yet. Potentially baseline High 6-C like you stated before Enryu.
 
My issues with the OP scaling currently:

Luffy gets his 6-C rating from destroying the Black Knight that Doffy creates as seen here and here.

However, the only reason the Black Knight is 6-C is by scaling it to the durability for the Birdcage which is questionable.

The Black Knight has two glaring antifeats that suggest it isn't as durable as the Birdcage at all;

So this should be taken into consideration that the Black Knight's durability does not scale to the Birdcage. It can't be used as the basis of Luffy being 6-C. On top of that, Doflamingo was sent into a panic by Fujitora's first meteor which was only calced to be just over a dozen meters across. If his Birdcage could effortlessly withstand a meteor a couple of kilometers across, why would Doflamingo be so flustered by Fujitora's first meteorite?
 
The times when Luffy hit Black Knight before destroying it were:



Seeing as the first instance is a completely basic punch (not even using Haki), and the second instance was more of a block then an attack, all I'm seeing is that Black Knight's durability has no impressive feats.

And this is further contradictory if we remember that Zoro and Fujitora were pressing their swords into the Birdcage and didn't once cut it...

I think a reasonable conclusion is simply that the Birdcage is a lot more durable because it is designed to be that way; it is a prison to trap enemies and it meant to be inescapable.
 
Well, we'd need to find a new justification for Luffy's base form and his Gear 4 form.

He wouldn't scale to the 85 gigatons feat of the Birdcage, so his Gear 4 form wouldn't be High 6-C based on that either.

If we cannot find a feat or calc from Dressrosa or Whole Cake Island, then we'd have to use his tier for the Punk Hazard arc which is "At least High 7-A, likely 6-C" and go from there.
 
Luffy's strongest attacks have never been used against the Birdcage. On what basis do they scale?
 
Damage3245 usually makes sense regarding the One Piece scaling. Perhaps it would be better to close this thread so he can create a new one instead?
 
Agree, I would like to see what Damage has to say. He generally provides a lot of scans for context to make it easier to understand (it's hard to remember something as long as One Piece). I agree with you, Ant.
 
I don't think a new thread is necessary yet; I'll try and summarize my thoughts:

Luffy's keys for Punk Hazard, Dressrosa and Whole Cake Island can probably be condensed down to this:

Tier: At least High 7-A in base, likely 6-C with G2 & G3, at least 6-C with G4

Attack Potency: At least Large Mountain level in base (Stronger than Zoro and Sanji), likely Island level with Gear 2 and Gear 3 (Able to contend with Fujitora), at least Island level with Gear 4 (Many times stronger than before)

(Same for Striking Strength and durability)

Fujitora should be At least Island level physically for being roughly comparable to the other Admirals and considered a monster by Doflamingo.
 
I corrected the tier statistic from 7-A to High 7-A in the above post, to match the attack potency.

Anyway, how would this affect the other One Piece characters?
 
Ah, thank you.

Anyway, as far as other profiles go,

Doflaming would be 6-C; Island level, with Island level+ Birdcage.

Law should probably be At least High 7-A, 6-C with Gamma Knife.

Cracker, Katakuri and Smoothie should all be At least 6-C.

Comparable characters to those Yonko Commanders will probably be At least 6-C as well.

The original Admirals and Yonko should still be At Least High 6-C, so they're unchanged.

Can anyone think of any more changes? I want to have this thread stay active a while longer before changes made.
 
Okay. I suppose that seems fine, but I would prefer more staff input.
 
Damage3245 said:
Law should probably be At least High 7-A, 6-C with Gamma Knife.
Click to expand...
Shouldn't Law be 6-C without Gamme Knife due of him be stronger than Pica and that he had defeated Vergo?
 
I don't think it was ever explicitly stated that Law was stronger than Pica.

And I'm somewhat against Vergo's rating. I think he might need to be downgraded slightly.

Pica - by virtue of his Devil Fruit - should be stronger than any of Doflamingo's other officers.
 
Except we have nothing to base Vergo > Pica on.

Law is undoubtedly superior to Vergo (though not drastically above him since Vergo could still beat him up heavily).
 
Damage3245 said:
I don't think it was ever explicitly stated that Law was stronger than Pica.
And I'm somewhat against Vergo's rating. I think he might need to be downgraded slightly.

Pica - by virtue of his Devil Fruit - should be stronger than any of Doflamingo's other officers.
Click to expand...
Disagree, for how much strong it was Pica, we see that he has never stand a change again Zoro.

And Sanji, who could fight on par with Vergo, should be on the same level of Zoro.
 
Sanji has been demonstrably weaker than Zoro since the timeskip.

Zoro was stronger than Pica, yes, but perhaps that simply means Pica is overrated? He has impressive environmental destruction because he is able to rearrange the island via his Devil Fruit but in terms of durability he is rubbish.

EDIT: Vergo's current profile is very misleading, and deliberately written to try and make Vergo seem more impressive than he is.
 
Or probably because it's easier to cut someone than beating them to death. Sanji maybe weaker than Zoro, but not by much.
 
Sanji against Vergo who isn't using Armament Haki; Sanji almost breaks his leg.

Zoro against Pica who is using Armamment Haki; Zoro one-shots him.

There isn't anything in the manga suggesting Vergo is more powerful than Pica; it's just pretty clear that Sanji is too weak.

Zoro can cut through Pica's stone golem body and through immense blocks of stone using air slashes, but Sanji couldn't kick through a heavy metal door in the Punk Hazard Arc.

Pica should be At least High 7-A, and so should Vergo and Sanji. Zoro should be At least High 7-A, likely 6-C.
 
Well tbf, like I said earlier, it's easier to cut someone than beat them to death. For example, It'll take a long time to punch someone until they die, but I can just insta-kill them by sticking a knife to their head.

But yeah, I agree with the revisions you proposed.
 
I also think that Damage3245 seems to make sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Brogeefrong
Luffy vs Megaman | 0-3-0
Replies
30
Views
3K
MintyBoi1
MintyBoi1
Apollonir.Scale
  • Locked
One Piece: Magma Fruit and Earthquake Fruit Scaling
Replies
17
Views
2K
Damage3245
Damage3245
CloverDragon03
  • Locked
Guilty Gear Scaling Revision (Part 7): A New Set of God Tiers
2
Replies
41
Views
2K
Planck69
Planck69
Farfetchedx
Psykos Revision and OPM mid tiers possibly High 6-C upgrade
2
Replies
55
Views
5K
Raiden38
Raiden38
StoneKillerz12
The Owl House: Massive Verse Revision (High 6-A for Titan Luz, Titan Belos, 3-C rating for The Collector, Speed of Light for light spell, etc.)
Replies
26
Views
2K
The_2nd_Existential_Seed
The_2nd_Existential_Seed
Back
Top