- 19,178
- 6,466
So the rating for re zero have been bugging me for a while. First of all, scaling characters like Elsa Granhiert to a feat Reinhard van Astrea performed is completely ridiculous, even if Reinhard was causal, he is so far above her she shouldn't scale at all, and the fight was plagued with PIS like fodder like Natsuki Subaru being able to keep up with Elsa, Reinhard is also far faster than her, and also the attack Reinhard used is his strongest attack, he shouldn't have been able to handled Elsa easily without it, Elsa also got stomped by Cecilius who is comparable to Reinhard.
Next this feat for Sphinx (Re:Zero) assumes the ceiling was vaporized but i read ex novel 2 and nothing was said about vaporization, this was said instead:
"The heat burned his hand, and the pain forced a scratchy sound out of his throat. Deflected by Grimm's defense, the beam destroyed the ceiling and brought down the floor of the room above the great hall."
So no mention of vaporization, this would only be like a small building level feat.
Sphinx, Wilhelm van Astrea, Libre Fermi also should have there speed downgraded, the Wilhelm who fought Libre and Sphinx wasn't Hypersonic+, only Wilhelm power of love as the author calls it, which is Wilhelm after training for years after the demi-human war in order to beat Thearesia van Astrea is Hypersonic+. Young wilhelm>old Wilhelm which we see in the main series however so Libre and Sphinx should be Supersonic+ as even old Wilhelm>Elsa.
Now the question of where to put Elsa, Crusch, Old Wilhelm etc in terms of Ap is tricky. There is the feat of Garfiel Tinsel destroying a ceiling which puts him at small building level, and the sphinx feat which is also small building level, there is a feat of Rem as an 8 year old surviving a basement being blown up, however we have feats like Rem creating a ton of ice with Al Human, Emilia (Re:Zero) creating layers of ice.
So it would seem the characters are higher with magic. Then we also have feats like Rem surviving a pretty big explosio that is larger than trees, Julius Juukulius cutting throw Betelgeuse Romanee-Conti unseen hands which are larger than buildings and can cause destruction that ejects dust which go above trees as well, i remember some statements about Garfiel Tinsel being able to kick away a building, and another one about him being able to destroy the sanctuary building.
So ultimately seeing all these feats, i suppose the characters should be Building level, while they can be higher with magic, Rem being City Block level with Magic and Emilia being Multi-City Block level with Magic after regaining her powers.
One last thing, Beast of the End Puck should be City level, the four spirits are capable of destroying cities:
"The Four Great Spirits, the spirits who have undisputed strength.
Their existence and names are widely known and the way of associating with the Four Great Spirits has been handled as a very important challenge all over the world.
In fact, a whole city has been destroyed by touching the Four Great Spirits' anger."
So Puck should be City level along with Roswaal L Mathers who is equal to him, Echidna (Re:Zero) who is comparable to Roswaal, and all the other witches like Carmilla (Re:Zero), Daphne (Re:Zero), Typhon (Re:Zero) should be City level too.
And finally we are being too generous with the large island level ratings, it's from a feat Puck performed over an unknown period of time, I think we should remove them.
Next this feat for Sphinx (Re:Zero) assumes the ceiling was vaporized but i read ex novel 2 and nothing was said about vaporization, this was said instead:
"The heat burned his hand, and the pain forced a scratchy sound out of his throat. Deflected by Grimm's defense, the beam destroyed the ceiling and brought down the floor of the room above the great hall."
So no mention of vaporization, this would only be like a small building level feat.
Sphinx, Wilhelm van Astrea, Libre Fermi also should have there speed downgraded, the Wilhelm who fought Libre and Sphinx wasn't Hypersonic+, only Wilhelm power of love as the author calls it, which is Wilhelm after training for years after the demi-human war in order to beat Thearesia van Astrea is Hypersonic+. Young wilhelm>old Wilhelm which we see in the main series however so Libre and Sphinx should be Supersonic+ as even old Wilhelm>Elsa.
Now the question of where to put Elsa, Crusch, Old Wilhelm etc in terms of Ap is tricky. There is the feat of Garfiel Tinsel destroying a ceiling which puts him at small building level, and the sphinx feat which is also small building level, there is a feat of Rem as an 8 year old surviving a basement being blown up, however we have feats like Rem creating a ton of ice with Al Human, Emilia (Re:Zero) creating layers of ice.
So it would seem the characters are higher with magic. Then we also have feats like Rem surviving a pretty big explosio that is larger than trees, Julius Juukulius cutting throw Betelgeuse Romanee-Conti unseen hands which are larger than buildings and can cause destruction that ejects dust which go above trees as well, i remember some statements about Garfiel Tinsel being able to kick away a building, and another one about him being able to destroy the sanctuary building.
So ultimately seeing all these feats, i suppose the characters should be Building level, while they can be higher with magic, Rem being City Block level with Magic and Emilia being Multi-City Block level with Magic after regaining her powers.
One last thing, Beast of the End Puck should be City level, the four spirits are capable of destroying cities:
"The Four Great Spirits, the spirits who have undisputed strength.
Their existence and names are widely known and the way of associating with the Four Great Spirits has been handled as a very important challenge all over the world.
In fact, a whole city has been destroyed by touching the Four Great Spirits' anger."
So Puck should be City level along with Roswaal L Mathers who is equal to him, Echidna (Re:Zero) who is comparable to Roswaal, and all the other witches like Carmilla (Re:Zero), Daphne (Re:Zero), Typhon (Re:Zero) should be City level too.
And finally we are being too generous with the large island level ratings, it's from a feat Puck performed over an unknown period of time, I think we should remove them.
