- 18,714
- 12,972
Don't we have Honkai Impact and Star Rail share a spot?Find me a character that isn't Warp-related that appears in both verses. I'll wait.
Nagash? Supreme God of the Dead? Nope.
Sigmar? Nah.
Emprah? Nope.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Don't we have Honkai Impact and Star Rail share a spot?Find me a character that isn't Warp-related that appears in both verses. I'll wait.
Nagash? Supreme God of the Dead? Nope.
Sigmar? Nah.
Emprah? Nope.
We do, and we also group Persona and Shin Megami Tensei together along with every series under the "Nasuverse"Don't we have Honkai Impact and Star Rail share a spot?
No? Persona and SMT take alot of elements between each other, far more thant Fantasy and 40K doWe do, and we also group Persona and Shin Megami Tensei together along with every series under the "Nasuverse"
Idk, I don't know all spots in the thread, if Sonic characters are occupying consecutive spots in the same tier they should be fused into a single one.Is not that the same case that sonic tho?
Why does any of that matter? If they're the same verse they're the same verse, sharing characters or not means absolutely nothing.Find me a character that isn't Warp-related that appears in both verses. I'll wait.
Nagash? Supreme God of the Dead? Nope.
Sigmar? Nah.
Emprah? Nope.
How about a magic system? Is that shared?Why does any of that matter? If they're the same verse they're the same verse, sharing characters or not means absolutely nothing.
Honkai Impact and Honkai Star Rail don't share a verse page but share a canon and thus share a spot in 3-C (the #3 spot I believe)Also, "Characters from Warhammer" wouldn't work, they don't share a verse page either!
However that tells you literally nothing about who's even in the spot lolHonkai Impact and Honkai Star Rail don't share a verse page but share a canon and thus share a spot in 3-C (the #3 spot I believe)
That is stupid, Sage monarch and Dragon talisman have two different spots in 2-A, even if the share...Existence?Honkai Impact and Honkai Star Rail don't share a verse page but share a canon and thus share a spot in 3-C (the #3 spot I believe)
Sage Monarch is just a novel inside Dragon Talisman, it just Yang Qi was ascended from his novel.That is stupid, Sage monarch and Dragon talisman have two different spots, even if the share...Existence?
Sage Monarch is just a novel inside Dragon Talisman, it just Yang Qi was ascended from his novel.
Yang Qi ascended because of the narrative help.Wouldn't that make DT not 1-A, because that is a blatant anti-feat?
That doesn't change much really, both share existence, and isn't Yang Qi the final antagonist of the story?
Do they have the same god tiers? Take place in the same multiverse?Point is, treating Fantasy and 40K as the same verse is very blatantly stupid, there's 0 cross-scaling for a reason.
Then they should share a single spot, yeah.Wouldn't that make DT not 1-A, because that is a blatant anti-feat?
That doesn't change much really, both share existence, and isn't Yang Qi the final antagonist of the story?
Technically, they don't share a multiverse, because that's part of the Materium. Maybe attempt to understand the verse your arguing before trying it, yeah?Do they have the same god tiers? Take place in the same multiverse?
If yes to any, specially the 2nd, they should share a spot.
The Warp is the same, no? Why are you focusing on the physical world as if "multiverse" was limited to this? Like, some tiers past L2C have the word "multiverse" and all have "verse" in them for a reason, everything can be accounted for in the word "multiverse", you're just talking about semantics here.Technically, they don't share a multiverse, because that's part of the Materium. Maybe attempt to understand the verse your arguing before trying it, yeah?
What even is this argument? I can't find them if they're merged or not, I don't know the verse and honestly it absolutely doesn't matters if they're in the same page or not for this list.And like I said, can you find who's in the High 8-C spot from Fantasy's Verse Page at a glance? And you're not allowed to look at the current list. If the answer is no, then don't try to merge them
EhemTier Low 2-C:
undefined
This is pure pedantry in all honesty. They share an overall setting, they're the same verse. It doesn't really matter how it organises internally or how many technicalities there are.Technically, they don't share a multiverse, because that's part of the Materium. Maybe attempt to understand the verse your arguing before trying it, yeah?
And like I said, can you find who's in the High 8-C spot from Fantasy's Verse Page at a glance? And you're not allowed to look at the current list. If the answer is no, then don't try to merge them
Aren't those like, proper different settings? If not then yeah, they should be merged.Eh just dump them into 1st with Fantasy then. Though someone merge the sonics in Low 2-C then cause they're taking up two spots for no reason
Pretty sure Archie and Game are very different canons.Eh just dump them into 1st with Fantasy then. Though someone merge the sonics in Low 2-C then cause they're taking up two spots for no reason
Then remove dragon talisman from 2-A, because Sage monarch not only exists in the same cosmology (as a piece of fiction, but still), but one of the characters literally comes from that novel with the desire of killing the prota.This is pure pedantry in all honesty. They share an overall setting, they're the same verse. It doesn't really matter how it organises internally or how many technicalities there are.
The point was it looks like shit, is terrible for organization, and searching two entire verse pages to pick a character out just to be wrong is an issue. There are over 100 combined profiles between Fantasy and 40K, do you expect people to pick the right one? If I asked "Who are the place-holders for Honkaiverse?" Could you answer it?This is pure pedantry in all honesty. They share an overall setting, they're the same verse. It doesn't really matter how it organises internally or how many technicalities there are.
I don't care for Honkaiverse so of course I couldn't answer it, what even is that point? The verse is big but so what? You'd be expected to support or reject the reasoning for a character like anyone else.The point was it looks like shit, is terrible for organization, and searching two entire verse pages to pick a character out just to be wrong is an issue. There are over 100 combined profiles between Fantasy and 40K, do you expect people to pick the right one? If I asked "Who are the place-holders for Honkaiverse?" Could you answer it?
Exactly! You can't answer who's the honkai placeholders because they ain't listed!I don't care for Honkaiverse so of course I couldn't answer it, what even is that point? The verse is big but so what? You'd be expected to support or reject the reasoning for a character like anyone else.
And the rest of this is just... irrelevant to what I'm saying. Idk why you made it 2 verse pages and I'm not asking for specifics or saying it is or isn't justified. Perhaps it's better for verse organisation, perhaps its a bit inconvenient for the thread. But it's still one setting in its totality so long as the Warp and overarching cosmology is shared. And it is shared.
....? What are you even talking about? I can't list them cause I can barely list a single character of the top of my head.Exactly! You can't answer who's the honkai placeholders because they ain't listed!
So why should we apply the same issue to Warhammer in High 8-C?
I'm whatever to what's decided to be labelled there, so long as its a single slot.So why should we apply the same issue to Warhammer in High 8-C? We can pick one, and both me an Abaddon agree Arkhan>Ahriman/Draigo/Voldus, so just list him lol
....? What are you even talking about? I can't list them cause I can barely list a single character of the top of my head.
If you read the conversation on this, what I'm avoiding is Honkai's issue at #3 3-C. If someone who doesn't give a rat's ass about the verse can't tell who the placeholder is, then it's just a list decided by who goes to the greatest lengths to find who in the hell is even in the spot and what they got.Tier 3-C:
1. Chen Jin
2. Characters from Marvel Comics (Doctor Doom and Daimon )
3. Characters from Honkai (Star Rail and Impact)
4. Avenger (Space Ishtar)
5. Gatchan
6. Cui Heng
7. Dark Schneider
8. Yhwach
9.Characters from Spongebob Squarepants
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
This might be even less of an issue than I thought cause I'm not quite seeing what's the problem with the way it's labelled.If you read the conversation on this, what I'm avoiding is Honkai's issue at #3 3-C. If someone who doesn't give a rat's ass about the verse can't tell who the placeholder is, then it's just a list decided by who goes to the greatest lengths to find who in the hell is even in the spot and what they got.
Then if loops back around, Planck. Tell me who the placeholders are for Honkai. If you, who doesn't know the verse can't answer that, there's my problem. We don't know.This might be even less of an issue than I thought cause I'm not quite seeing what's the problem with the way it's labelled.
Just list them alongside the verse name?? Is something stopping that from working?Then if loops back around, Planck. Tell me who the placeholders are for Honkai. If you, who doesn't know the verse can't answer that, there's my problem. We don't know.
The main characters that would be listed there are Welt Yang from Honkai Impact (who is also in HSR, but is in his peak and have access to his strongest abilities in HI) and Acheron from Honkai Star Rail. If it bothers you that much they can both be added next to their positions in the 3-C tier. There are several positions that are just listed with the name of the verse without characters next to them, the fact that in that specific position there are two verses (which are actually one) doesn't make it that different from the rest from my point of view.Then if loops back around, Planck. Tell me who the placeholders are for Honkai. If you, who doesn't know the verse can't answer that, there's my problem. We don't know.
I mean I've always grumbled about that too, it's why I basically refuse to let any verse I use here be left as just "Characters from X"The main characters that would be listed there are Welt Yang from Honkai Impact (who is also in HSR, but is in his peak and have access to his strongest abilities in HI) and Acheron from Honkai Star Rail. If it bothers you that much they can both be added next to their positions in the 3-C tier. There are several positions that are just listed with the name of the verse without characters next to them, the fact that in that specific position there are two verses (which are actually one) doesn't make it that different from the rest from my point of view.
Eh yes he does (courtesy of magic).Speaking of 3-C it is funny how The top 3 have Low 1-A hax...with the exception of Thor, and maybe another character
I was referring that Thor has High 1-A haxEh yes he does (courtesy of magic).
Plus he has the God Blast, which has High 1-B to Low 1-A AP.