Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

[Phoenks]

Hello, im new here,
Asking for an evaluation of this

Samsara Chōetsu (Verse)

fcoc-vs-battles.fandom.com

Mainly the Cosmology Ratings on the Cosmlogy Page i Made, The values in the big {} are what i want them to be at(ofcourse waiting for an evaluation, and will be changed afterwards from waiting to Accepted as (Blank Value).

Hello.

It doesn't seem like the cosmology blog here is even finished yet. The formatting is quite bad and the cosmology is quite barren in detail.

The descriptions also fail to give an idea of how they qualify for the tiers you're thinking they do. In fact, I struggle to even see the verse as being Tier 1 in the first place going off of your explanations.

I'm going to reject this for now. You should spend more time on this before submitting again.

Also, if you're new, please join the discord. In the future, if your cosmology does pass the first (visual) test, then you will be invited into a conversation on there for further discussion.

 

[Phoenks]

Blog: https://fcoc-vs-battles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:RatherClueless/Cosmology_Blog

"The Name of This Story? Does it Even Matter?" (Rather's) cosmology has been accepted by staff after a review that has lasted longer than all the other ones combined.

The tier of it at peak is currently set at "Unknown" past some of the smaller structures, due to his cosmology simply not really fitting well within some of the outlines of the current Tiering System. However, we currently are still waiting for Ultima to give his personal thoughts and verdict on it. After which, the tiering might be changed. Given Ultima's reputation of taking a pretty long time for certain activities (Understandably so), we decided to let him through before that, since it could end up taking a while. The narrative reasoning was already determined to be absolutely fine regardless of what tier it might end up as, anyway.

Also, Rather has expressed that he doesn't even care much for tiering his characters and doesn't even plan on having statistics like that on some of his character pages... so I didn't want to hold him back for an extended time over that.

Congrats to him! I look forward to seeing some of his pages. I find a lot of the meta-fictional concepts pretty interesting.

 

[VeneficaAuthor]

Upon reflection and a new review, the staff team has decided to rescind The Shadow of Revenge’s cosmology acceptance, effective immediately.

 

[Re5yh]

Bump

 

[Rayfire]

Bump

 

[VeneficaAuthor]

Bump

What are you bumping exactly?

There aren’t any current submissions or discussions here.

 

[DMUA]

Isn't this thread pinned, too?

People can just access it when they need it, it's not for broad discussion

 

[JohnConquest1]

Bump

I would assume you want to submit this for review due to the time frame between posts.
But this is the Fanfiction Character/Original Character section of the wiki, We're not involved in VSBs Tiering process.