The poison manipulation for Servants

[J.P.Polnareff]

Servants should not have poison manipulation (immunity),except a few:

1)Hassan Of Serenity,her body is made of poison

2)Galahad/Mashu,it has been stated in FGO that their shield have a passive that make themself and their master having Poison Immunity.

3)(Only in Camelot Singularity) Tristan,his gift,Reversal,give him Poison Immunity,and is the only reason why the Hassan's plan to kill him with Serenity's poison didnt work.

For all other servant,the poison manipulation intended as immunity to it should be removed since they can be harmed by it (Serenity's poison does not let her having phisical contact with anyone,Servants included,also Agravain run away when Serenity was spreading her poison in the castle,cause it would be deadly for him,and he is a servant too)

This is my first thread and im not native english so sorry for eventual mistakes or grammar errors

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Mordred stated in Apocryha that poisons like Jack's mist dont affect servants, yet it killed any human it came in contact with nigh-instantly

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

In extra Robin Hood stated to have killed hundred of servants with his poison

 

[WeeklyBattles]

That would be a feat for the potency of Robin's poison then, not something that disproves poison resistance, but would you happen to have a scan of that?

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

If servant are really immune to poison what would be the point to give Tristan a Gift that specifically gives him Immunity to poisons,included Serenity's and made it a plot point for that section of the story?

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Nero is unaffected by Robin's poison, which would have killed her master if he didnt make himself immune to poison and turned a snake to dust in seconds

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

In that clip nero was falling because of Robin's arrows poison,but Hakuno's command seal let her continue to fight

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Yeah, so that would be a feat for his poison arrows, that poison would be more potent than the poison mist he uses as Nero was visibly unaffected by it

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

Just checked the Type Moon wikia,Poison Resistence is actually a skill,and only Serenity and Medea Lily have it,even tho there are a more few exception like Arash with his Toughness EX and Mash/Galahad with their shield

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

Also in type moon wikia,in Serenity's profile there's a statament from Grand Order Materials that says that she can kill Heracles once with her poison

 

[Yobo_Blue]

There's clear differences between the stuff used by Servants and the stuff used by humans and mages though.

 

[Yobo_Blue]

Iirc, Jack's poison is a recreation of natural human stuff, while Serenity's is explicitly a super strong poison able to effect Servants because of its potency.

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

So what are you saying is that the poison immunity should be changed to "Poison immunity only against human-made poison"? If thats the case ,it should be added a total immunity to the few servants i mentioned before.

 

[WeeklyBattles]

It shouldnt be an immunity, it should just be a resistance

 

[Yobo_Blue]

It's less human stuff and more about potency.

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

Ok,so you'll change it like we just said?

 

[Yobo_Blue]

Serenity's is human made, but it's also super strong. It's a resistance. No resistance is impenetrable, which is why some work and some don't.

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

And what about Tristan's gift then?

It stated to give total Immunity to poisons

 

[Yobo_Blue]

In-verse maybe, but this is a wiki that looks at stuff from across fiction.

 

[Promestein]

The poisons used by Servants like Semiramis and Serenity are more effective than conventional poisons, which most Servants are unaffected by. Servants like Tristan and Arash, who have explicit resistance to poisons, just have a resistance of a higher caliber, likely protecting them against such things.

 

[Overlord4896]

agreed with promestein.

 

[John985]

the translation of volume 5 of strange fake is ongoing but it hasn't reach that part yet so I wont be able to give you scans, but it was said there that Hydra poison can also destroy the soul.

Edit: and on Serenity profile it only said this. She's saying in unlikely event not that it will work.

Heracles
"Assuming in the unlikely event that he died on one occasion even to my poison, if it is with the effect of that hero's Noble Phantasm, he should be "unable to die a second time to the same poison"————In other words, he truly…?"

 

[J.P.Polnareff]

I agree too,but for Tristan should be like that only with the Reversal Gift