Coolboy6
He/Him- 7,434
- 6,005
Last edited:
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Surprised no one has done this after…you know (SPOILERS)
- 2,335
- 1,007
Stats are similar. Tobey-Man has way more experience due to age (character, not actor) and variety of villains fought. He also can make webs naturally whenever. They are for all intents and purposes identical in function to Andrew-Man's webs that he makes. Likely not the same in-universe atom-for-atom makeup, but, they appear to function the same for combat and moving around. Andrew-Man is taller, and appears to move a bit more flexibly, like in his fight with his Harry Osbourne.
Argument to Tobey-Man. Also Hop has recently seen his films. Not biased, but more recently informed. Hop must watch the other films.
Argument to Tobey-Man. Also Hop has recently seen his films. Not biased, but more recently informed. Hop must watch the other films.
- 6,244
- 2,366
Stomp fra
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 7,996
- 6,246
The inevitability of this match... Figures.
To his benefit, Andrew is the MUCH more agile Spider-Man between the two. And by a somewhat ridiculous degree, as Andrew's movements are much more "spider-like" and he's as slippery as a weasel more often than not. In an open area like Central Park (due to SBA iirc), there's a much better chance of Andrew dodging Peter's webbing for a prolonged period of time in a showdown between the two. He's also facing a Spider-Man that's past his prime, though it won't mean much considering Tobey still had an excellent performance in NWH. And he has a more standard, legit precognitive Spider Sense rather than Tobey's borderline-precognition.
Tobey's Spidey, however, is a much more durable Spidey. Not in the sense of his durability actually being higher, but in terms of his endurance. This guy has taken prolonged beatings that were extremely brutal and could get back up fairly decently (The Goblin fight). And that isn't to discredit Andrew, as Spider-Men are just natural glutton for punishment. He also seems to have the greater Spider Sense, at least in terms of much greater spatial awareness.
The issue is that, eventually, Andrew will run out of webbing. It could take a shit ton of time, and it could be a very tedious endeavor for Tobey to take advantage of it, but it's an advantage that could make or break it. Andrew will be forced to enter H-2-H combat with Tobey, which may not be the best for him. Not to mention that Tobey does have at least a ten year experience advantage as Spider-Man, and did win that quick web-tag to at least show Tobey's Spidey can reliably tag the more nimble Spidey (less of a speed feat and moreso speaking to his quickness on the draw).
I think OG Spider-Man takes this with more experience, less of a chance to be tagged by the other's webbing due to greater spatial awareness and at least somewhat decent agility, natural webbing, and greater resilience to damage should it come down to a fistfight.
Though really, they'd probably just enjoy some street vendor hot dogs together lol
To his benefit, Andrew is the MUCH more agile Spider-Man between the two. And by a somewhat ridiculous degree, as Andrew's movements are much more "spider-like" and he's as slippery as a weasel more often than not. In an open area like Central Park (due to SBA iirc), there's a much better chance of Andrew dodging Peter's webbing for a prolonged period of time in a showdown between the two. He's also facing a Spider-Man that's past his prime, though it won't mean much considering Tobey still had an excellent performance in NWH. And he has a more standard, legit precognitive Spider Sense rather than Tobey's borderline-precognition.
Tobey's Spidey, however, is a much more durable Spidey. Not in the sense of his durability actually being higher, but in terms of his endurance. This guy has taken prolonged beatings that were extremely brutal and could get back up fairly decently (The Goblin fight). And that isn't to discredit Andrew, as Spider-Men are just natural glutton for punishment. He also seems to have the greater Spider Sense, at least in terms of much greater spatial awareness.
The issue is that, eventually, Andrew will run out of webbing. It could take a shit ton of time, and it could be a very tedious endeavor for Tobey to take advantage of it, but it's an advantage that could make or break it. Andrew will be forced to enter H-2-H combat with Tobey, which may not be the best for him. Not to mention that Tobey does have at least a ten year experience advantage as Spider-Man, and did win that quick web-tag to at least show Tobey's Spidey can reliably tag the more nimble Spidey (less of a speed feat and moreso speaking to his quickness on the draw).
I think OG Spider-Man takes this with more experience, less of a chance to be tagged by the other's webbing due to greater spatial awareness and at least somewhat decent agility, natural webbing, and greater resilience to damage should it come down to a fistfight.
Though really, they'd probably just enjoy some street vendor hot dogs together lol
Last edited:
- 2,335
- 1,007
One thing Hop should have said but others haven't brought it up yet.
In SPOILER FOR
NEW MOVIE
They had identical reaction time due to spider sense, in the scene where Ned drags them into his house, so that's a fair point. No speed advantage.
If they went about it competitively instead of bloodlusted, Hop still sees that Tobey would want to end it faster. Personality for one, his own awareness of his weaknesses for another. He probably knows more about Andrew-Man than he himself, so to speak, he'd take mental advantage. He's also had lower lows, so he could start there, knowing what it means. Both have been jerks in their movies to others, but Tobey-Man really excelled at taking it far. Venom suit or not, he has a powerful anger he has used before. Could he do it again? He's grown, but that was one time. It could be useful to tap into it just to win, not to kill. Andrew-Man has little like it. Bloodlusted, it'd be far more "even" in terms of intent and what they'd do. Not every fight is only physical, it's mental too. They could have a conversation. Don't need mind hax to do that, especially when you're fighting what is essentially you.
In SPOILER FOR
NEW MOVIE
They had identical reaction time due to spider sense, in the scene where Ned drags them into his house, so that's a fair point. No speed advantage.
If they went about it competitively instead of bloodlusted, Hop still sees that Tobey would want to end it faster. Personality for one, his own awareness of his weaknesses for another. He probably knows more about Andrew-Man than he himself, so to speak, he'd take mental advantage. He's also had lower lows, so he could start there, knowing what it means. Both have been jerks in their movies to others, but Tobey-Man really excelled at taking it far. Venom suit or not, he has a powerful anger he has used before. Could he do it again? He's grown, but that was one time. It could be useful to tap into it just to win, not to kill. Andrew-Man has little like it. Bloodlusted, it'd be far more "even" in terms of intent and what they'd do. Not every fight is only physical, it's mental too. They could have a conversation. Don't need mind hax to do that, especially when you're fighting what is essentially you.
ShakeResounding
He/Him- 7,996
- 6,246
A match that relies on more than just strength. How Spidey-like
- 10,261
- 6,763
- 2,335
- 1,007
Count so far?
- 3,088
- 1,670
Didn't bullyman tag garfield with a web in that very scene?
- 9,226
- 3,367
tobey fra
- 5,206
- 2,724
Tobey FRA.
- 12,085
- 2,094
Your'e trash Garfield FRA
- 10,261
- 6,763
Tobey FRA
- 2,335
- 1,007
Tobey-Verse squad is off the charts tonight
Majority of votes give it to him, but its a slight edge, we can see, from the look of it.
Allow another day or so for votes to come in (time zone consideration)
- 14,934
- 21,039
Tobey FRA
Similar threads
