Saber vs Saber Alter

[Schnee_One]

Now this is more of a curiosity match, who wins between UBW Saber and her Evil HF counterpart?

Saber Alter:

Saber (Fate/stay night):

Now I know I'm not allowed to vote on my own thread but this isn't going to be added anyway, IMO Alter takes it, while UBW Saber will hold the advantage in a full on sword fight due to far better instincts and agility, eventually one of them will use Excaliblast with the other following suit, which is when Alter Saber's power advantage takes effect and overwhelms UBWs Excaliblast killing her.

But hey, extra thoughts are always appreciated

 

[ZGhostWolf]

Either saber takes it or they kill each other.. She has better stats, better skills and the only thing she lacks is mana.. Alter could spam excalibur but if you think about it it's not as useful as you think.. If 1 excalibur isn't enough are you sure 2-3 will be? Ofc not having to worry about mana is always good. But saber should have the advantage in sword fight and if either of them decides to go for excalibur the other will answer with excalibur too killing both of them in the blast..

 

[Schnee_One]

What makes you think one Excalibur won't be enough?

Avalon would make Alter outlast Saber as Saber doesn't have as much mana or prana as her. Without it Alter and Saber would clash with Excalibur which Alter will win via more mana and power.

 

[Ramesses_the_Sun_King]

Excalibur Morgan(which I will now call morcalibur) can be spammed so Alter has a advantage in terms of trump cards. But since we don't know how many oaths she has cleared when using Morcalibur we can't assume it can overpower a regular Excalibur. Also Alter didn't start the fight against Medusa by spamming Morcalibur and as a result Medusa was running circles around her.

In CQC Saber has a huge advantage and can probably deal a lethal attack with better instincts and agility. But at the same time Alter could just straight up overpower her with better mana to her prana burst.

I'm going inconclusive since we don't know enough about Excaliburs oaths which means we don't know which Excalibur attack is stronger. And since they both have respective advatages it is too close to call.

 

[Schnee_One]

I can't make an argument for that at all, very good points.

Saber

+Instincts which help in a sword fight

+Much better agility

Saber Alter

+Much more mana

+Excalibur is more spammable

Points can be made for both.

 

[ZGhostWolf]

What makes you think one Excalibur won't be enough?

Avalon would make Alter outlast Saber as Saber doesn't have as much mana or prana as her. Without it Alter and Saber would clash with Excalibur which Alter will win via more mana and power.

I didn't say it wasn't enough.. I said if 1 excalibur didn't kill the target spamming more isn't always going to help, hence alter ability to spam it 24/7 isn't as useful as the majority thinks.. Ofc there are situations we're it's very good..

If one of them decides to fire of excalibur the other will do the same possibly killing off each other

 

[Schnee_One]

Why would two Excaliburs kill each other? Excalibur and Enuma Elish ended in Gil's favor. Bellerophon and Excalibur ended in Bellerophon's favor with the help of Shirou.

You can't kill eachother by clashing, either one wins or they both stop clashing and continue.

I'm pretty sure spamming Excalibur is a pretty good idea.