>Anyway, she has been shown to create Lumas in this scene which I posted above. Also, very few Lumas turn into Power Stars or Grand Stars, implying the ones that do turn into Grand Stars are considered greater than the ones that turn into galaxies.
I have made my rebuttal to his on Dino's wall:
"There is nothing that is implying that Rosalina is creating the Lumas in these scenes.
There are Lumas always around her, the other animations show us this, and thus it is more reasonable to think that Lumas were always with her, flying around doing whatever Lumas like to do, as shown in the other game's animations."
And with Rosalina's speech about how stars are born from other stars through the Cycle of Life, it is more reasonable to assume that Rosalina is, in fact, not creating Lumas in that scene - as nothing implies to the fact that she could do that.
>Also, the Universe was clearly a space-time reset since everything was back to normal in an instant. In the case of a regular destruction and recreation, the universe would inherently need to re-expand and repopulate over the course of eons. And Space-Time resets are normally done by a powerful entity.
Reseting time would be the exact same as a recreation of time in the fact that it would inherently mean that the universe needs to re-expand and repopulate, so using this argument as a counter is counterintuitive.
And besides, the universe has clearly not been reset, but reborn for a myriad of reasons.
Firstly, the statements made by Rosalina talking about how stars and things that are reborn in the Cycle of Life are slightly different from how they originally are, and how Mario will see what she means soon, is an implication of this, which is further proven by the differences in the universe that I mentioned in a previous comment.
Not to mention the fact, that Mario is stated to welcome the birth of a
new galaxy/universe.
>Also, the cutscene of the Lumas all getting sucked up and Rosalina rescuing Mario from the blast, and her legit being the one that returns him to the Mushroom Kingdom basically shows she was above and beyond everything that happened. Azathoth was also someone who agreed with Rosalina's Low 2-C key. And none of the other cast scales from her because game mechanics are a thing. She could stomp everyone if she really wanted to.
Rosalina using a forcefield to protect Mario and then bring him home once the battle is over is not indicative that she is beyond everything that happened, it isn't indictive of anything barring that she is a nice person who cares to save her friend and brings him home once he is done with his quest in helping her and her family.
And Azathoth agreeing to Low 2-C Rosalina in he past means nothing. People can change their minds, new arguments and new evidence has come to light of the opposite, and Azathoth isn't an all-knowing person, just because he agreed to a belief, does not make that belief a legitimate one.
You need to prove that she wouldn't scale to the others because, "game mechanics" - just saying that game mechanics is the reason she is comparable to Mario has no weight without proof. By this reasoning, I can argue that Princess Peach doesn't scale to the other Mario characters, and that it is just game mechanics that makes her seem comparable.
You like say that lore dictates her as some cosmic being above everyone else, but it really doesn't.
Her backstory paints her as a normal person who found a family with the Lumas, and thus became their caretaker, Bowser is then able to appear and steal away her precious family from her without her able to stop him - and despite the fact that apperntly she is superior to everyone in the verse, and has the power to create Grand Stars, she was still marooned in the middle of space in a spaceship she can't power without Power and Grand Stars until Mario came along, whose help she begged for.
Nothing indicates that's she this all-powerful deity that all of you have been proclaiming.
