- 2,537
- 1,271
The category? Just added it.Uh... please don't mix a verse-specific P&A page with an explanation page, separate the two into their own pages.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The category? Just added it.Uh... please don't mix a verse-specific P&A page with an explanation page, separate the two into their own pages.
I prefer the name. If a mod changes it, then that's that.I wouldn't be a fan of that, it's misleading for a verse-specific P&A page, other cases have already been renamed for similar reasons (for this case it's the inverse, a title that implies it's an explanation page when it'd be a verse-specific P&A page).
Like I said, it is supplementary. For example the Heavenly Dao and Primal Chaos being supplementary evidence for conceptual manipulation, chaos manipulation, causality manipulation, Empyrean Dao key, etc.That kind of stuff, yeah, that would be fine to be in the verse page as it's just introductory lore to such parts, you can just add in a new subsection for those or so to easily just link there as needed.
@LordTracer @Colonel_Krukov @Js250476Uh... can somebody please ping @LordTracer , @Colonel_Krukov and @Js250476 ? If the page is to stay it requires considerable additions to say the least, and I'd rather that to be the case as it's a pretty used verse-specific P&A page.
A new version of that page is being drafted (albeit for the Legends continuity).I just noticed this only has 8 powers and the descriptions are mostly unecessary lore that isn't too useful for our purposes, let alone no scans and some "powers" not even being proper P&As on the site to count (thus not doing any favors and reducing the effective P&As to 5).
I have no idea if there’s something being planned for the Canon continuity, I don’t interact with that side of the verse.I suppose there's also plans for the other continuities in that regard?
Wait, I got a question since I am not aware (I am creating right now two cosmology pages and two physiology pages), how many powers are needed “at least”?Uh... please don't mix a verse-specific P&A page with an explanation page, separate the two into their own pages.
On another note...
I just noticed this only has 8 powers and the descriptions are mostly unecessary lore that isn't too useful for our purposes, let alone no scans and some "powers" not even being proper P&As on the site to count (thus not doing any favors and reducing the effective P&As to 5).
Uh... can somebody please ping @LordTracer , @Colonel_Krukov and @Js250476 ? If the page is to stay it requires considerable additions to say the least, and I'd rather that to be the case as it's a pretty used verse-specific P&A page.
Mind quoting any policy regarding this? Or even a page that talks about it? I want to make sure my 4 pages/projects not going wasted due to this.At the very least you need 10, but it can be as low as 5 if there's particularly lengthy descriptions/citations that are really needed and aren't just bloating with unecessary information.
Thank you
First things first, as IDK about the verse, would "Cultivation Realms" be an appropiate way to call the power as a whole? I can't just ask to remove the "Explanation Page" part of the name as it's clear the name of the power isn't just the name of the verse here.I prefer the name. If a mod changes it, then that's that.
Like I said, it is supplementary. For example the Heavenly Dao and Primal Chaos being supplementary evidence for conceptual manipulation, chaos manipulation, causality manipulation, Empyrean Dao key, etc.
It doesn't belong on a verse page because it is relevant to parts within that page.
How can we handle The Force in Star Wars then? Discussion is welcomeI just noticed this only has 8 powers and the descriptions are mostly unecessary lore that isn't too useful for our purposes, let alone no scans and some "powers" not even being proper P&As on the site to count (thus not doing any favors and reducing the effective P&As to 5).
I don't think there were any objection, so i renamed it.Going by the discussion so far, can a mod please rename this to "Cultivation Realms"? Unless there's any objection, of course
I may not be a huge star wars fanatic but from what I've been told(and from what I've seen) about the series I'll give my 2 cents on it. By any chance if I'm wrong on certain information, or the way I propose conflicts with how the verse works don't hesitate to correct me. Here's what I think.Going by the discussion so far, can a mod please rename this to "Cultivation Realms"? Unless there's any objection, of course
Also...
How can we handle The Force in Star Wars then? Discussion is welcome
Also I wanna ask something. I couldn't help but noticed that this page for Naruto. Does anyone even use this page? I mean it's detailed on the stuff but I don't really see Naruto profiles using it.
Is there another verse powers and abilities page you wanna review?Bump.
Yeah that's probably a fair point tbh....How would that make it be in a watch list for the purposes of this thread? This is more of just a semantic that should probably have its own thread.
I just noticed this only has 8 powers and the descriptions are mostly unecessary lore that isn't too useful for our purposes, let alone no scans and some "powers" not even being proper P&As on the site to count (thus not doing any favors and reducing the effective P&As to 5).
@Gewsbumpz_dude- Monster Physiology (Goosebumps Film Series): Not only is this page also used for other media contrary to what the title says, the amount of powers is below the minimal of 10 and IMO lacks the detail (some powers don't even have scans) to pass the bare minimal criteria of 5, I'd suggest deleting it if @Gewsbumpz_dude can't defend it.
@YungManzi- Magic (Frieren: Beyond Journey's End): Justifications are lacking, there's no summary, and it barely meets the 5 page criteria, and while there's a linked blog post for further explanations, it just goes over the in-verse semantics of using the power as a whole, seems quite borderline and I'd appreciate if @YungManzi could bring it up to standard. In other words the issue here is more on quality than standards per-say.
@Comiphorous- Nevadean Physiology (Madness Combat): Only two pages use this, should be deleted if @Comiphorous has no plans to add more character pages with it.
@Chaos Jester25- Noise (Mega Man Starforce): Only three pages use it, which is lacking by current standards, should be removed if @Chaos Jester25 has no further plans on characters to add.
@Bernkastelll- Occultism (Ordem Paranormal): Okay from a glance, but the page just explains verse semantics over giving proper justifications to the claimed powers, turning it of quite low quality, the user that made the page doesn't seem to be on this forum, so... can @Bernkastelll help here?
@ActuallySpaceMan42 @Wokistan- Planeswalker Physiology (Magic: The Gathering): Very good page, but... only three pages use it, does @ActuallySpaceMan42 and I presume @Wokistan have plans to add more pages with it?
@LordGinSama- Plant Physiology (Trigun): Besides the tier 1 stuff as a whole being very questionable on the verse, only three pages use this page, does @LordGinSama has plans to add more pages with it?
@Chariot190- Stand: IDK if a Trivia section is within the purposes of the site at all, I'd like general thoughts on the matter by staff, I'm also noticing that the amount of pages using this one is also lacking, with only 4 characters, it does seem there's work to add more characters with it, however. @Chariot190 is worth pinging here.
Honestly, at this point, I don't care if it gets deleted. I don't blame y'all for saying it is pretty minimal (And for further clarity, at the time I didn't know the standards of verse-specific powers. I just asked about it in Vs Central and was told that it was okay if it has a few powers and it applies to multiple characters).@Gewsbumpz_dude
I want to know the context behind this. What are you referring to?Monster Physiology (Goosebumps Film Series): Not only is this page also used for other media contrary to what the title says