PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,074
- 6,002
Like who exactly did he erase the people remembered?No, but people still remembered them, so…
If they do then the history is not totally erased
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Like who exactly did he erase the people remembered?No, but people still remembered them, so…
Valeria Trifa, no?Like who exactly did he erase the people remembered?
If they do then the history is not totally erased
Then the history is not truly erased. Also people with aca 1 and I think 4 would still remember anyone who's history has been erased as their own history won't be affected by itValeria Trifa, no?
Logically they shouldn't be remembered since with temporal erasure they never existed in the first placeLet me say something, if someone is erased from.history would the person still be remembered? Cause if the person is remembered then his history not truly erased. But if someone whose history was truly erased regenerated then I guess high godly is fine
But his history was completely erased lmaoThen the history is not truly erased. Also people with aca 1 and I think 4 would still remember anyone who's history has been erased as their own history won't be affected by it
Not sure about 4 but I guess people with Acausality 1 should be able to rememberThen the history is not truly erased. Also people with aca 1 and I think 4 would still remember anyone who's history has been erased as their own history won't be affected by it
Because it was just like type 10 immortality and the old type 1 concept hax, arbitrarily 1-A with little to no explanation on how it’s better than the lower level stuff beyond “a specific tier”Why was true godly even removed in the first place
Yes certain acausals would still rememberBut his history was completely erased lmao
Like rea? LmaoYes certain acausals would still remember
If people who are not acausals still remember then it is not history erasureLike rea? Lmao
It is, tho. We have numerous statements of it lmao.If people who are not acausals still remember then it is not history erasure
You and pain are derailing...It is, tho. We have numerous statements of it lmao.
True, let’s stopYou and pain are derailing...
Does he? I’ll check againMachina doesn't erase history though, his ability is to make things reach their end instead of erasing history.
I suppose that this seems sensible to me. Well-informed suggestions from our staff and retired staff would be appreciated.Regenerating from being erased to the point of never having existed in the first place ("proper history erasure") definitly qualifies for High-Godly. The problem lies within our explanation and definition of History Erasur. We dont have a proper one. Like "Dimensions", every fictional work defines "History Erasure" differently, heck, depending on the cosmology, even proper history erasure might not be High Godly. For example in a verse with a proper platonic concept system, where someone just hopps back from History Erasure because his platonic concept was untouched.
We only need to properly define what we understand under "History Erasure that qualifies for High-Godly" like we did with "Dimensions that qualify for tiering purposes"
I don't think we need to clarify anything, we might just have to look at what pages shouldn't have it.@ByAsura @Executor_N0
Do you have any suggestions for how we can better clarify our standards so not every character who is a living universe, gets destroyed, and comes back afterwards, gets High-Godly?
Yes.Does he? I’ll check again
SM verse mechanics/laws of physics operates on a combination of type 3 & 4 causality system, chaos maybe governed by type 2, all being pseudo-abstracts as they embody a specific idea/concept through the star seeds (at least its what Iamunanimousinthat told me)Sailor Moon might be a sketchy case. I believe changing the past in that verse doesn't affect the future completely, but I'll have to check.
Well that would fall under case by case, that would depend if they are remembered after being erased, if they are, then it's not high tier history erasure, and thus It doesn't qualify for a proper High Godly rating, but, if they aren't, then it is High Godly.What about dudes who are living timelines? Will they get high godly regen if they got destroyed, or will it just be mid godly?
Cosmology needs to be taken into account as well, since some cosmologies, especially verses that work up with multiverses, don't take into account time paradoxes or completely ignore them even with such an erasure, and thus they should still qualify for High Godly. At least, that's what I think. Verses that have indications of having 2nd temporal dimensions or hypertimelines should also fall under this, with the right circumstances,since the erased information can also be stored in the other temporal dimension, or either both within the lower spacetimes and the higher flow of time in the hypertimeline's case.in these cases, you could have an History EE and avoid paradoxes, in a sense.Well that would fall under case by case, that would depend if they are remembered after being erased, if they are, then it's not high tier history erasure, and thus It doesn't qualify for a proper High Godly rating, but, if they aren't, then it is High Godly.
Yeah, but the fact that someone who was erased in history level still remembered, means that the interactions, actions, etc the character has done still happened, even the things destroyed by that characters still remain as it was. And thus, that character goes completely against the means of the ability, which means history erasure, and thus, is contradicted, no matter the cosmolgy and the verse settings that verse has. One thing is time paradox inmunity, and the other is history erasure, for example, we only got one on DBH with Zamasu, but countless examples of time paradox inmunity where a new timeline is created, and thus, we can't assume that Zamasu deserves a proper High Godly rating.Cosmology needs to be taken into account as well, since some cosmologies don't take into account time paradoxes or completely ignore them.
Read what I said above.So characters like DBH Zamasu are good example of Who doesn't meet ALL the criteria for High Godly regen through history erasure.
Yes, and I already answered, the history erasure statements in DBH are pretty much contradicted, or simply the verse settings portray the ability in some way that It doesn't meet the criteria for the ability at all. So if verse cosmolgy doesn't qualify, It doesn't qualify. History erasure means that all the traces you hace done, even your entire existance is erased and is like you were never born to begin with, so yeah you know...Read what I said above.
Not that. Discrete 2nd temporal dimensions are a thing. And Heroes stated twice that the timeline is gone, btw.Yes, and I already answered, the history erasure statements in DBH are pretty much contradicted, or simply the verse settings portray the ability in some way that It doesn't meet the criteria for the ability at all.
Nope, history erasure makes it that you were never even born to begin with, DBH case is just It doesn't qualify, and, you should've been erased from people's mind.Not that. 2nd temporal dimensions are a thing. And Heroes stated twice that the timeline is gone, btw.
Also this is derailing
This completely contradicts the feat of Zen-Oh destroying the timeline, since it implies that time wasn't erased and thus Zen-Oh shouldn't be tier 2. But to argue that, you need to argue for 3-A universesNope, history erasure makes it that you were never even born to begin with, DBH case is just It doesn't qualify, and, you should've been erased from people's mind.
My bad.Don't debate DBS here. And keep non-staff comments to a minimum. Cluttering this thread won't do anybody any good.
But is important, becouse we are literally debating how the ability should work, and which characters should get and which not, we are debating the criteria.Don't debate DBS here. And keep non-staff comments to a minimum. Cluttering this thread won't do anybody any good.
Sorry but DBS or not no matter the verseThis completely contradicts the feat of Zen-Oh destroying the timeline, since it implies that time wasn't erased and thus Zen-Oh shouldn't be tier 2. But to argue that, you need to argue for 3-A universes
Which brings us back to the other thread:
For this argument to work, all of DBS needs to go down to 3-A. And you would still have problems with Heroes's own stuff, even then.
Also, don't we treat Goku going back to the timeline as PIS, since he's able to breath in the void?
I already explained that this paradox can be avoided, above.Sorry but DBS or not no matter the verse
If someone who is stated to be erased from.history (past, present and possibly future) is still remembered or the actions be performed in the past still happened then that does not qualify for high godly that is what the note should be about in the high godly page
Your explanation is not viable and goes against the basis of being truly erased from.history, unless the said erased is acausal type 1 or 4 or 5, then yes when he is erased he should not be remembered or his past actions. Whether be it time paradox or anythingI already explained that this paradox can be avoided.
It doesn't go against anything, it's just how 2nd temporal dimensions work.Your explanation is not viable and goes against the basis of being truly erased from.history, unless the said erased is acausal type 1 or 4 or 5, then yes when he is erased he should not be remembered or his past actions. Whether be it time paradox or anything