- 11,531
- 8,017
Hello. Now I have been reading the profiles for the Supernatural god tiers. And I see a problem with how they seem to be rated.
God and those who scale to him are rated as "At least 4-B, likely 3-A." The reasoning for the 3-A is that, God and The Darkness have Universe level feats. Fair enough. Then the reasoning for the 4-B is that 10,000 supernovas were needed to kill The Darkness. However it is stated that "and that was only because she was weak to light."
If both these ratings and their reasonings are correct, this honestly seems like some downplay. God and The Darkness have legitamate Universe level feats. And the only reason the supernovas could kill TD was cause she's specifically weak to light. Not because they're powerful enough to kill her.
When have we ever put feats aside and rate people based on weaknesses unrelated to stats? This is like like not making Superman straight up 4-B, despite his numerous Solar System feats, cause "he's weak to a red sun." We all know it's not that Superman isn't as powerful as a sun, rather he is weak to red sun radiation. And with these guys it seems to be the exact same case.
Basically, unless the current profiles are inaccurate (in which case we'd have to rewrite them), there is no reason at all not to rate these people as straight up 3-A.
God and those who scale to him are rated as "At least 4-B, likely 3-A." The reasoning for the 3-A is that, God and The Darkness have Universe level feats. Fair enough. Then the reasoning for the 4-B is that 10,000 supernovas were needed to kill The Darkness. However it is stated that "and that was only because she was weak to light."
If both these ratings and their reasonings are correct, this honestly seems like some downplay. God and The Darkness have legitamate Universe level feats. And the only reason the supernovas could kill TD was cause she's specifically weak to light. Not because they're powerful enough to kill her.
When have we ever put feats aside and rate people based on weaknesses unrelated to stats? This is like like not making Superman straight up 4-B, despite his numerous Solar System feats, cause "he's weak to a red sun." We all know it's not that Superman isn't as powerful as a sun, rather he is weak to red sun radiation. And with these guys it seems to be the exact same case.
Basically, unless the current profiles are inaccurate (in which case we'd have to rewrite them), there is no reason at all not to rate these people as straight up 3-A.
