No, and thats not what we do with Rimuru, we separate the LN and WN, not LN and Anime
Cuz nobody tried to do it lol
Ooohhhh, ok so it WASN'T disqualified, just nobody got to it, thanks for clearing that up for me
As far I know, yeah, also, anime stuff usually is accepted in calcs because they give us more info, a great example is a profile I made, it's a LN but the speed calc comes from the anime.
vsbattles.fandom.com
Could I just add "low 7-B with Fallen Down" to his page then? Or do I have to get someone else's permission or just someone else entirely?As far I know, yeah, also, anime stuff usually is accepted in calcs because they give us more info, a great example is a profile I made, it's a LN but the speed calc comes from the anime.
Kuro (Isekai Shokudou)
Kuro is a member of the Ancient Six, 34,684 years ago Kuro fought alongside the other dragons to defeat the Million Colors of Chaos. And after the battle concluded, when they were deciding upon their own personal territories, she chose the end of the sky filled with naught but magical energies...
you should make a CRT
Aww man, really? Dang
Overlord has gone through nothing short of tiering hell, frankly. It's a difficult verse to scale cause a lot of feats just don't exist and you need the right translations. The officials are... well they get things very wrong at times.
I keep getting inconsistent heights for Ainz, I remember seeing a 5 ft nothing, a 5 ft 9, and a 7 ft. But even then, just looking at the scene itself, isn't that at least a city block worth of area vaporized AT MINIMUM? Shouldn't that be able to serve as a very under leveled low end or am I crazy?
iirc the LN arguably doesn't support that, since Fallen Down's aftermath is moreso treated like a flashburn/heatblast of an area, and has no real mention of a crater last i checked, only the ground and trees being charred, vitrified, and some dirt/sand turning to glass or whatnot. Whether you'd wanna argue the crater interpretation is more valid because both the anime and manga have a crater is another story, but idk how well that goes since LN is primary canon. Anime is also very unfun for scaling using heights yes. They scaled up a lot of things heights just because. The mud fairies the lizardmen used and the Skeletal Dragons are both cases of things having their heights jacked WAY the hell up. Ainz also gets taller, though even some LN art has him as taller than his apparent intended/WoG height, so who effing knows with Ainz
The data book depicts the larger version, would that count?
Actually, I think a CRT should be made to discuss whether Overlord anime and manga stuff are OK to use in calcs or not
Still an inconsistent feat
Try to get a high-quality version of Nuclear blast, and I'll discuss with the other main Overlord Supporter about possibly getting the verse upgraded
From a post on Reddit
Apologies, I'm quite ignorant of how things work around here.
Calculation Group Members, they are the members who analyse the feats and calc it
Yes? Why wouldn't they? We already treat anime and mangas for LNs to be secondary for such things (or if it's originally a manga than the anime is secondary). Aka if it's not really contradictory and is just adding context to a feat, such as timeframes, or in the case of LNs especially, actual visuals lmao.
I have a question: Why do you care how strong a given verse is?
Because I just want to make sure that if something is wrong it gets corrected. If I'm outvoted, then so be it, I tried.
Also, only people who care come to this site in the first place, cuz people who don't care just ignore it for the most part.
Yes. The first 3 feats you're thinking of are probably invalid cause the LN takes priority.
Shalltear never blocks it. Ever. She never even faces someone who uses it on her.
Nothing is technically wrong with the profiles right now, there's just some possibilities of higher stats, some of which are invalid, others are meh.
Ok so Shalltear holds up her nail to block Brain's Nail Cutter, which uses 4 Fold, but afaik any mention of SoL is only for 6 fold. Also idr the scene that well, but iirc wasn't Brain like, prepping the move. More than enough time for Shalltear to hold up a finger in preparation to easily block this trash human's attack, even if 4 Fold had a hidden SoL statement i don't remember
Brain didn't know 4 Fold ATT. What he dropped against Cocytus is literally his ultimate attack combining pretty much every offensive technique he has.
Yeah I'd have to check the LN for specifics, but the Anime definitely depicts Cocytus as just face-tanking it with 0 damage
Against Shalltear he knows 4 Fold, and by Vol 14 he knows 6 Fold
Ah, one of those times the Anime is crappy with the timelien then
I think you actually see 4 slashes in the anime? I just can't say whether or not it had him mention 4 Fold by name, since him combining that with Field was Nail Cutter basically, so why mention the component parts for pacing reasons
tbf even if she did (she honestly might have i'd have to read the scene again) there's also no SoL statement for 4 Fold i know of. The statement was only 1 time for 6 Fold and then it's never brought up again. So it just doesn't matter either way
Actually, there's evidence to the opposite
Hey look, someone who doesn't know how four-fold Slash of Light works!
Rude, however, going by the actual Light Novel which I quoted
Ah, so four simultaneous strikes, AKA, she can very easily just hold it in one spot after seeing where the Katana was going. Not to mention, as has been repeatedly said and ignored by you before, there was a single statement for Six Fold being SoL, not Four Fold.
Like I said, Four Fold being light or not is a different argument. Her herself reacting to it however is factually true. Are you not reading my comments fully because I didn't ignore it before
Which is weird considering even if we discount the Four Fold, he still has Sixfold in his peak key. You seem to be confusing "arguing for a verse being lightspeed" for "arguing what written text says". I don't care how yall handle Overlord, I love the series but powerscaling it ain't my cup of tea. However just denying the written text leaves a sour taste in my mouth, you can call it outliers or whatever idc but rudely denying things does nothing.
