One Piece Marineford Size Updated, Updated

[MonkeyOfLife]

Continuation from here

Made another updated calculation on the size of Marineford

Marineford's Size (UpdatedOfUpdated)

vsbattles.fandom.com

Marineford Size Calc

vsbattles.fandom.com

Again the current one uses character height which is less consistent than object sizes

And scales the character from a weird angle looking up and has to assume the bottom of the ship

Updated one scales ships to ship and then ship to battleship to then battleship to Marineford, nearly shows the whole thing and is far more detailed than any other Marineford panel

The Polar Tang ship is comparable to Thousand Sunny in size making the battleship size consistently to be that big, therefore making Little Oars Jr the one who's inconsistent that also gets supported by the fact that Little Oars Jr was 38 meters in height but later on changed to a bigger number because of his height being inconsistent in the manga

VIVRECARD(ビブルカード)ONE PIECE(ワンピース)図鑑～ OFFICIAL SITE

one-piece.com

This thread is only to change the accepted size of marineford in the One Piece calculation's section

Credits to @Eminiteable aswell for helping me with the scans

Also using this scan of the 2-3 story buildings to disprove the size of the battleship and to say that all the other buildings are the same size simply isn't true as the buildings at the front of marineford are 4-5 storys high, proving they aren't the same

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

... Forgot to evaluate the Calc itself wait

 

[Kachon123]

I don't really care about your method of finding the Battleship height, as there are several ways to find it with each getting vastly different sizes.

My issue now is the panel you used to find the size of Marineford.

This isn't a good scan to find the size of Marineford because using the 42 meter battleship height you found in your blog, the height of the buildings in Marineford Town would be like 50 meters which we know isn't true:

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

My guy couldn't just wait

I don't really care about your method of finding the Battleship height, as there are several ways to find it with each getting vastly different sizes.

My issue now is the panel you used to find the size of Marineford.

This isn't a good scan to find the size of Marineford because using the 42 meter battleship height you found in your blog, the height of the buildings in Marineford Town would be like 50 meters which we know isn't true:

1. We don't know where that part of town is 2. We can do exact same thing with kt's calc on the width of Moby dick being 100m which would make the other buildings width be around 50-100m in width as well which you just showed aren't any where near that big in your panel you used

 

[Kachon123]

We don't know where that part of town is

In that scan we see the majority of the buildings, with none of which being shown to be vastly smaller than the other ones.

We can do exact same thing with kt's calc with the width of Moby dick being 100m which would make the other buildings width be around 60-100m in width as well which you just showed aren't any where near that big in your panel you used

KT using a bad method doesn't mean that you should too.

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

KT using a bad method doesn't mean that you should too.

I'm trying to find something that's better and more accurate

It's still a better method than KT's calc which is why I suggested this

In that scan we see the majority of the buildings, with none of which being shown to be vastly smaller than the other ones.

We see taller buildings at the back of that panel...

 

[Kachon123]

It's still a better method than KT's calc which is why I suggested this

Which I still disagree with.

We see taller buildings at the back..

They're the same exact size.

 

[Stryker861]

are there not any other shots of marineford to use?

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

Which I still disagree with.

Then explain why..

They're the same exact size.

They are literally not as you can see the height of the buildings at the back

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

are there not any other shots of marineford to use?

No, if I remember correctly the one I'm currently using is the only marineford panel that's the biggest and most detailed from a top down point of view

 

[Kachon123]

They are literally not as you can see the height of the buildings at the back

They're elevated.

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

They're elevated.

A complete assumption...

 

[Stryker861]

couldent we find the height of the buildings by scaling off the aveage black cats length

 

[Damage3245]

@MonkeyOfLife Why are you trying this again so soon after the last thread?

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

@MonkeyOfLife Why are you trying this again so soon after the last thread?

As it's a continuation of the last thread that doesn't have the inaccuracy people brought up

Do you need to wait to post another thread? I did try to research if there were any cooldowns or something but couldn't find anything on that in the rules

Where the last thread concluded it has been around 24h