• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece General Discussion: Elbaph

I read that there may be inconsistencies in our One Piece scaling. Is this accurate?

 
Okay. So these inconsistencies in our scaling do not exist?
 
Okay. So these inconsistencies in our scaling do not exist?
The inconsistencies do not exist.

The guy on Reddit is saying that because our profiles rate some Yonko Commanders like Katakuri and Cracker at High 6-C while others like Jack at 5-C, they're wrong and inconsistent, when there's nothing that states or implies that all commanders are equal or relative.
 
Well, from a narrative viewpoint it seems strange that they would be so uneven, but without direct evidence it is hard for us to do anything, yes.
 
Well, from a narrative viewpoint it seems strange that they would be so uneven, but without direct evidence it is hard for us to do anything, yes.
Whether Big Mom's commanders were that powerful in the past or will be in the future doesn't really matter. Them being around the 6-C level is what the plot demanded the scaling to end up turning out like so that's how we will index their stats.
 
Key.PNG
lmao what is going on. This is really entertaining I might get active again.
 
Wait is the debating happening or nah?
Might as well live stream it 🤭
 
I ******* love how the top reply on that reddit thread talked about Queen breaking Big Mom's skull being used for the scaling even though we said multiple times it didn't happen and we even had a discussion rule for the Queen vs Big Mom stuff
But yes.. We're the ones who are illiterate and don't read up on stuff properly. 🗿
 
Well, from a narrative viewpoint it seems strange that they would be so uneven, but without direct evidence it is hard for us to do anything, yes.
2 of Blackbeard's commanders went on Whole Cake Island and took down everybody there in the blink of an eye including Cracker, then left with their most important asset in the span of a few hours
 
Nah for real
I was convinced it was just Oda making those dumb questions before, man will answer shit like "Would it be weird for Vegapunk to be attracted to his own satellites?" but not legitimately good questions like whether eating Brook's fruit after eating a different one will negate the whole "You die if you eat multiple fruits" thing or not.
Oda definitely chooses the dumb questions on purpose, but sometimes it irritates me when people ask obvious questions and he answers them anyways.
"Did Ben Beckman take Kidd's arm?"
like cmon bro, how much did you need it spelled out
 
How many chapters do you guys think we have before the Straw Hats have completely left Egghead?
 
Where? There's one part that might say something like "[Zoro] fights on equal terms with Lucci", but Idk if that could be used cause, well, the ending of the fight showed very well that Zoro is far superior to him lol
 
Nah bro he couldn't even knock Lucci out

I'm gonna keep pushing this because it's hilarious to watch Zoro fans and Lucci haters alike lose their shit
 
Where? There's one part that might say something like "[Zoro] fights on equal terms with Lucci", but Idk if that could be used cause, well, the ending of the fight showed very well that Zoro is far superior to him lol
Literally the same situation as Hawkins and Killer.

Anyways, Lucci did fight evenly with Zoro. He fought evenly with a that lowered his level to draw out the fight for whatever reason.
 
for whatever reason.
For plot. Without Oda wanting to draw the fight out it'd just be Zoro hitting him with Leopard Hunt from the jump and ending it in less than a minute.
Which sounds weird, but that's literally how Zoro is, as soon as he had a direct clash with Pica he clapped his cheeks with one move.
 
Back
Top