• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

[one more Staff needed] Black hole problem (my wife is the demon queen)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dragongod224

Dragongod224

232
93
The Black Hole Created by Xiang Ye: A Realistic Depiction?

Introduction

In the story "My Wife is a Demon Queen," Xiang Ye creates a black hole [ Accepted culc] that is later destroyed by Isabelle, the Demon Queen. This raises questions about the nature of the black hole is it's real or not. In this analysis, we'll examine the evidence for the black hole's reality and Isabelle's destruction of it.

Arguments for the Black Hole's Reality

1. Expert Testimony: Xiang Ye, a genius in physics, said that the black hole will become uncontrollable and unstoppable if created.
2. Spaghettification: The black hole displays its spaghettification talent by instantly disintegrating Raymond.
3. Photon Sphere and Accretion Disk: The black hole absorbs matter and creates a Photon Sphere and Accretion Disk around itself.
4. Absorption of a 3-Layer Dyson Sphere: The black hole absorbs a 3-layer Dyson Sphere, demonstrating its immense power.
5. Lack of Magic Involvement: Isabella Osa states that the black hole does not possess any type of magic.
6. God King's Inability to Cut the Black Hole: The God King is unable to cut the black hole with his sword, further supporting its reality.
7. Xiang Ye's Statement: Xiang Ye says that in front of black hole ever think is equal and nothing can escape.

Isabelle's Destruction of the Black Hole

1. Non-Physical Force: Isabelle does not use physical force to destroy the black hole. Because god King unavailable to cut the black hole with physical force.
2. No Physical Contact: Isabelle never touches the black hole physically.
3.Controlling black hole: lsabella sowing cantrol space surrounding black hole to control black hole.
4. Removal of Mass/Energy: Isabelle may have removed mass/energy from the black hole, Because of this it give more support to my statement.
5.According to the VS Battles Wiki's Black Hole Feats in Fiction page:Which is impossible according to common physics, while this can be ignored in cases of characters going FTL.
6.Isabella Claim: Isabella is more powerful and faster than Libelly who can avoid hit by several real laser at point blank.[Culc Blog]

"Note: Despite potential rejection of culc, it is crucial to acknowledge that numerous evidence suggests Isabella Osa successfully destroy a black hole using non-physical methods. And it's real depiction of a black hole within the story and proof that provide.


Note:- ln my last theard @Mr. Bambu a staff and culc group member has no problem seen as real black hole [theard link] . That's time only problem is black hole destruction culc and sides character culc which is already accepted.


Conclusion

Based on the evidence, it appears that the black hole created by Xiang Ye is a realistic depiction of a black hole within the story My wife is the Demon queen universe. Isabelle's destruction of the black hole is likely a non-physical process. That's say I think this should be ignored is case of Isabella

Discussion

Staff and members, please share your thoughts and opinions on this analysis. Do you agree or disagree with the arguments presented?


Agree: @GarrixianXD [staff] , @Voidnether , @Duedate8898 [staff] , @Qawsedf234 [staff]
Neutral:
Disagree:
 
Last edited:
Only thing if is this is an outlier to the story or not, despite that, it seems good but you should ask a admin/mod /calc member to evalue this, you need 3 votes from those rank members
 
If the numbers you got from the calc are good then sure, they can be used but you will likely need a blog so that isabella's speed section have it linked to the blog, if there's any calc member here willing to check the calc then you can ask them to evaluate the same calc in the blog.
 
I think all of this is enough to prove the created black hole in question is a realistic black hole. Should be good.
 
The arguments for blackhole should be fine, though I'm unsure about Libelly actually dodging light as it is not evaluated currently (as far as I know).
 
It looks like the calc was accepted on the grounds the destruction of the blackhole itself was elaborated on proper. Which your OP doesn't really do, so I'll have to ask, what is the context behind the creation of this black hole and its destuction. You're only posting single panels without much text or really even strong visuals to give me an understanding of what has occured or why the explanation you've given for those scans is correct.

So, if you can provide the chapters covering this or more, I'll better be able to see if this black hole is fine from an in-story perspective.
 
Duedate8898 said:
It looks like the calc was accepted on the grounds the destruction of the blackhole itself was elaborated on proper. Which your OP doesn't really do, so I'll have to ask, what is the context behind the creation of this black hole and its destuction. You're only posting single panels without much text or really even strong visuals to give me an understanding of what has occured or why the explanation you've given for those scans is correct.

So, if you can provide the chapters covering this or more, I'll better be able to see if this black hole is fine from an in-story perspective.
Click to expand...
Ok

Chapter 297 for first black hole
Chapter 450 for second black hole

Basically the main character has a field which allow him to create anything he imagines and its non magical in stories point of view.
 
Last edited:
Dragongod224 said:
According to the VS Battles Wiki's Black Hole Feats in Fiction page:Which is impossible according to common physics, while this can be ignored in cases of characters going FTL.
Click to expand...
This is about escaping the event horizon of the black hole, which the black portion of it. Escaping the gravity in general doesn't require that speed until you cross the event horizon.
Dragongod224 said:
4. Removal of Mass/Energy: Isabelle may have removed mass/energy from the black hole, Because of this it give more support to my statement.
Click to expand...
I read Chapter 299 where she destroys the Black Hole and she just compresses it down until it implodes, but takes all of her Demon power.

For the thread it looks(?) legitimate, but scaling wise it has issues:
  • Only the Demon Queen's full power scales to it
  • You'd have to prove a UES for the main character to scale to it
  • Chapter 450 shows (from my view) the final boss being unable to stop the black hole and he just dies to it
So its not something people actually scale to consistently in my mind.
 
Apologies for the wait on my end, forgot to send my confirmation.

Essentially, arguments for the blackhole 1-4 appear to be fine and based in the series itself, so off that alone I think the blackhole could qualify.

However, Point 5-7 in support are weak as saying that it has "no magical response" doesn't really mean that the blackhole itself isn't magic. This is actually what really delayed my response as I was looking for an explanation within series on what exactly Forging is, and from my understanding it is a form of magic. 6-7 just are neutral statements overall in whether or not this is a real blackhole.

Your points on how Isabelle destroyed the Black Hole are not the strongest, as only really Point 2 has legs to stand on while all the others just don't have enough context to be solid support.

Overall, I think this should be fine to be accepted as a Black Hole
 
Qawsedf234 said:
This is about escaping the event horizon of the black hole, which the black portion of it. Escaping the gravity in general doesn't require that speed until you cross the event horizon.
Click to expand...
Ok
Qawsedf234 said:
I read Chapter 299 where she destroys the Black Hole and she just compresses it down until it implodes, but takes all of her Demon power.
Click to expand...
Yes
Qawsedf234 said:
For the thread it looks(?) legitimate,
Click to expand...
Do you agree or not I don't understand
Qawsedf234 said:
but scaling wise it has issues:
Click to expand...
Ok
Qawsedf234 said:
  • Only the Demon Queen's full power scales to it
Click to expand...
Yes
Qawsedf234 said:
  • You'd have to prove a UES for the main character to scale to it
Click to expand...
I think I don't need to do because it's already confirmed in manhua (scan)
Qawsedf234 said:
  • Chapter 450 shows (from my view) the final boss being unable to stop the black hole and he just dies to it
So its not something people actually scale to consistently in my mind.
Click to expand...
No, he don't die but survived (scan)
 
Duedate8898 said:
Apologies for the wait on my end, forgot to send my confirmation.

Essentially, arguments for the blackhole 1-4 appear to be fine and based in the series itself, so off that alone I think the blackhole could qualify.

However, Point 5-7 in support are weak as saying that it has "no magical response" doesn't really mean that the blackhole itself isn't magic. This is actually what really delayed my response as I was looking for an explanation within series on what exactly Forging is, and from my understanding it is a form of magic. 6-7 just are neutral statements overall in whether or not this is a real blackhole.

Your points on how Isabelle destroyed the Black Hole are not the strongest, as only really Point 2 has legs to stand on while all the others just don't have enough context to be solid support.

Overall, I think this should be fine to be accepted as a Black Hole
Click to expand...
Ok
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Dragongod224
  • Locked
(staff needed) My wife is a demon queen: Xiang Ye Abilities Revisions
Replies
29
Views
2K
Dragongod224
Dragongod224
LordJoshMeh
Genshin Impact Black Hole Problem
2
Replies
73
Views
5K
GarrixianXD
GarrixianXD
Dragongod224
  • Locked
[staff needed] Xiang Ye power and ability revision part 2 [My wife is the demon queen]
Replies
14
Views
851
Dragongod224
Dragongod224
Dragongod224
  • Locked
(My wife is a demon queen) Xiang ye ap Revision
Replies
11
Views
2K
Dragongod224
Dragongod224
Half_Shiny
(1 staff needed) The Red Eclipse (Black Hat (Villainous) Rework 1 of +3?)
2
Replies
45
Views
3K
Half_Shiny
Half_Shiny
Back
Top