• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
because it's taking back the chakra that was originally its.
there was energy/life force(chakra) on earth before the otutsukis arrive what was not on earth then was ninshu(chakra)
everything is called chakra so it can be confusing but there was indeed chakra on earth already
 
Ninshu isn't chakra. It's the method of using chakra that Hagoromo taught to people, which was later distorted and weaponized into Ninjutsu by Indra. People always had chakra, Hagoromo and Indra just taught people how to use it in different ways.
 
Ninshu isn't chakra. It's the method of using chakra that Hagoromo taught to people, which was later distorted and weaponized into Ninjutsu by Indra. People always had chakra, Hagoromo and Indra just taught people how to use it in different ways.
i am talking about this chakra, i dont know the word for it since every energy is called chakra so i just called it ninshu

ueIMvPT.jpeg



this was the one taught by hagoromo and ashura. but like i said chakra indeed existed not just the one formed by mixing physicals and spiritual energies together

and this was said by a mount myoboku toad, they were around even way before the god tree
 
I mean it was stated numerous time that Hagoromo was the first human to be born with chakra. But sometimes natural energy is used synonymously with chakra since the tree absorb the energy of the planet and its inhabitants and converts it into chakra via fruit
 
The explanation of the creation of the chakra is at the beginning of the series (Pain12 already sent the scans). The chakra only exists after the energies are mixed. Stamina is the name given to physical and mental energy, when the ninja mixes both energies, the chakra arises. I honestly think that there should be no difficulty in interpreting that those who don't mix the energies don't have chakra in their bodies...

As already stated here, chakra is a word that has been used for other energies more than once. The divine trees have the ability to absorb everything, even genetic information from everyone who lived on Earth (Isshiki mentions this). It absorbs vital energy and genetic information from all living beings and converts it into chakra.
 
Everybody on the planet having chakra is kind of a big plot point in the War Arc.

The Infinite Tsukuyomi was designed to entrap the entire population within an endless genjutsu and siphon chakra from them until they became another fruit. If only shinobi, of which are in the low hundreds of thousand, possessed chakra, why go through all the trouble to trap the entire planet?
IT siphoned life force (which can also be converted to chakra as shown wit Naruto, Gai and the cursed summon in Boruto that sucked the deer to death)

Unless regular humans can convert their physical and mental energies they don't possess chakra in the sense Shinobi do. It's like having flour without the know- how to make bread
 
Yeah and every otshuski has a byakugan iirc but not a sharingan
Kaguya had both the Rinnesharingan and the Byakugan.
She gave birth to Hagoromo who received her Rinnegan, and Hamura who received her Byakugan.
Hagoromo had two children, Ashura and Indra, with the latter receiving his power in the form of a Sharingan; hence this.
Hamura eventually started out the Hyuga Clan, who inherited his Byakugan.
I mean it was stated numerous time that Hagoromo was the first human to be born with chakra.
Hagoromo dispersed his chakra amongst the population of the world, in hopes of everyone binding their mental energies together and forming a harmonious synergy. However, the people instead chakra as a tool to link their own physical and mental energies, weaponizing it into ninjutsu. Unless there was a link that went missing during the evolution of civilization that booted chakra out of their genes, everyone in the world at this point possesses chakra; however, they do not have the power to control it and utilize it in the same way that ninja or samurai can.
right after kawaki said "he does not have chakra" or "cant manipulate chakra" iirc and in that context like i explained everyone has spiritual energy and physical energy. mixing together to form chakra is what only ninjas can do
IT siphoned life force (which can also be converted to chakra as shown wit Naruto, Gai and the cursed summon in Boruto that sucked the deer to death)
No, it siphoned chakra (find "Infinite Tsukuyomi" and "God: Nativity of a World of Trees").

If you were referring to Naruto's Baryon Mode with that first example, Naruto and Kurama's chakra are used to create an explosive new power.
In the case of the Eight Gates, nope. Those are nodes in the body that restrict the flow of chakra, which taijutsu masters can open through sheer will.
I don't know what this cursed summon is, though. I have not seen the Boruto anime.
 
I should have specified full blood

Iirc it actually said kaguya was the first one of earth with chakra, and one of the scans u sent I think that's referring to current day because it said "if all chakra is reunited"
 
Kaguya had both the Rinnesharingan and the Byakugan.
She gave birth to Hagoromo who received her Rinnegan, and Hamura who received her Byakugan.
Hagoromo had two children, Ashura and Indra, with the latter receiving his power in the form of a Sharingan; hence this.
Hamura eventually started out the Hyuga Clan, who inherited his Byakugan.

Hagoromo dispersed his chakra amongst the population of the world, in hopes of everyone binding their mental energies together and forming a harmonious synergy. However, the people instead chakra as a tool to link their own physical and mental energies, weaponizing it into ninjutsu. Unless there was a link that went missing during the evolution of civilization that booted chakra out of their genes, everyone in the world at this point possesses chakra; however, they do not have the power to control it and utilize it in the same way that ninja or samurai can.



No, it siphoned chakra (find "Infinite Tsukuyomi" and "God: Nativity of a World of Trees").
every form of energy is called chakra,
If you were referring to Naruto's Baryon Mode with that first example, Naruto and Kurama's chakra are used to create an explosive new power.
In the case of the Eight Gates, nope. Those are nodes in the body that restrict the flow of chakra, which taijutsu masters can open through sheer will.
I don't know what this cursed summon is, though. I have not seen the Boruto anime.
many times, spiritual energy, life force and energies in general are called chakra.
but kaguya has been using tsukuyomi before hagoromo and asura spread chakra/ninshu

anyway look at the scans below

This is from shikamaru novel




NOW SCANS FROM THE NARUTO MANGA
i mean this was mentioned several times in the manga

1.
ueIMvPT.jpeg

this is Pa

2.

GWRkr4o.jpg


TMJyq7p.jpeg


this was the earliest explanation of how chakra is created.

I will like to look for scans of Neji looking at spider guy before and during him performing a ninjutsu, it was clearly shown that chakra moves through certain pathways from the heart to whatever part of the body.
like i said you need to learn how to knead chakra(mix physical and spiritual energy together) to create chakra something ninjas are taught. I mean even there was a time tobirama as a kid said he could not sense what hashirama was sensing cause he was not kneading chakra then e.t.c.

Anyway this are the scans i went to find, if i had more time i would have tried to find more especially the two i mentioned up there

Everyone is saying same thing but like i said everything in naruto is called chakra. Nature energy, life force and the one the ninjas wield by combining their physical and spiritual energy (This is what i am referring to), only ninjas and those taught can do this and it has been said many times throughout the series.

Now back to the original argument. Genjutsu is done by controlling the fundamental chakra/energy in everyone not the ones the ninjas create.



The said chakra(Ninshu) is not even in the said ninjas every time.
look at this as an example
UwSwAWY.jpg


There are other examples even in the series. Every energy is called chakra, but the energies are different from each other
 
Every energy is called chakra, but the energies are different from each other
Physical and mental energies were the energies that existed in everyone, even before chakra.
Chakra is a "binding force", and allowed people to weaponize their physical energies.
Nature energy is the energy that exists in the atmosphere and the terrains—similar to the human's physical and mental energies, but not the same.

These three energies are never referred to as "chakra". Only chakra is referred to as "chakra".
The said chakra(Ninshu) is not even in the said ninjas every time.
look at this as an example
UwSwAWY.jpg
"I'm not actively building up chakra in order to sense someone's presence" is not the same as "chakra does not exist in ninja at all times".
Tobirama is an adept sensor, and you have to actively knead chakra and switch your chakra to "Sensory Mode" in order to use sensory techniques.
Now back to the original argument. Genjutsu is done by controlling the fundamental chakra/energy in everyone not the ones the ninjas create.
"Genjutsu works on your opponent's five senses. You control the chakra flowing through their cranial nerves."
This concept of a "fundamental chakra/energy in everyone" is never brought up once.

Oh wait, yea it is. It's called chakra.
Again...
Hagoromo dispersed his chakra amongst the population of the world, in hopes of everyone binding their mental energies together and forming a harmonious synergy. However, the people instead chakra as a tool to link their own physical and mental energies, weaponizing it into ninjutsu.
You know information can be changed as a story moves on, right? Especially after decades of serialization. It's called retroactive continuity.

Chakra was passed onto the humans by Hagoromo with the hopes of connecting everyone's hearts and minds, as chakra is a special, binding force. Instead of bonding with each other's mental energies, they bonded their own physical and mental energies in order to power themselves up and create ninjutsu. This portrayal of the origin and nature of chakra is consistent with how Boruto portrays chakra, once again bringing up the fact that chakra is a binding force that connects everyone on Earth, as it exists within everyone on Earth.

To sum it up, in #90, chakra was the result of mixing one's physical and mental energies together.
As of #665, chakra is the force the mixes one's physical and mental energies together.
Unless there was a link that went missing during the evolution of civilization that booted chakra out of their genes, everyone in the world at this point possesses chakra; however, they do not have the power to control it and utilize it in the same way that ninja or samurai can.
 
Physical and mental energies were the energies that existed in everyone, even before chakra.
Yes and that was what kaguya was siphoning using the god tree and converting it to chakra.
Chakra is a "binding force", and allowed people to weaponize their physical energies.
I am not disputing this.
Nature energy is the energy that exists in the atmosphere and the terrains—similar to the human's physical and mental energies, but not the same.
and also the one that exists in sage creatures, snake, toads e.t.c. And totally different. And was called "Sage chakra/energy" = "Nature chakra/energy" + "Chakra from mixing your physical and mental energy"

No one is also disputing this

"I'm not actively building up chakra in order to sense someone's presence"
yes
is not the same as "chakra does not exist in ninja at all times".
the chakra from mixing your physical and mental energies does not exist within them all the time. as shown when in Sasuke retrieval arc when neji was looking at how spider guy was kneading chakra
yes
This concept of a "fundamental chakra/energy in everyone" is never brought up once.
and the concept of everyone can mix their physical and mental energies together was never brought up once. in fact it was stated only ninjas can do this and even in the novels. and the novel was after the war arc before boruto
Oh wait, yea it is. It's called chakra.
exactly what i said. i mean even madara said there was no chakra on earth before hagoromo, but somehow the energy the god tree was taking from the humans was also called chakra
Again...

You know information can be changed as a story moves on, right? Especially after decades of serialization. It's called retroactive continuity.
the information did not change, you are taking one part and neglecting the other.

Chakra was passed onto the humans by Hagoromo with the hopes of connecting everyone's hearts and minds, as chakra is a special, binding force. Instead of bonding with each other's mental energies, they bonded their own physical and mental energies in order to power themselves up and create ninjutsu. This portrayal of the origin and nature of chakra is consistent with how Boruto portrays chakra, once again bringing up the fact that chakra is a binding force that connects everyone on Earth, as it exists within everyone on Earth.
yes chakra is a binding force that binds everyone together, but the chakra used for ninjutsu is different from this, it is using the "chakra that is the binding force" to instead bind your physical and mental energy together to create a type of chakra that can be used for destructive purposes

and only ninjas can do this.
To sum it up, in #90, chakra was the result of mixing one's physical and mental energies together.
As of #665, chakra is the force the mixes one's physical and mental energies together.
and the novels that happened after this said only ninjas have the chakra from mixing of physical and spiritual energy
then in boruto

Kawaki: I ain't a ninja. I can't wield chakra or whatever you call it.
Naruto: That's not true. Chakra exists within every one of us. It's not a special thing exclusive to ninja. Sure, we ninja use chakra to power ninjutsu, but... that's not its true nature. The real essence of Chakra... is that it's a binding force.
Kawaki: A binding force...?
Naruto: Connecting you and me... and Boruto and Sarada... and also Himawari and Hinata. We're all linked in no small measure... through chakra.


We are saying the same thing and different things at the same time, so let me drop a summary of my thought and explain it to the best of my ability


please permit me to use the word "Ninshu" so i can better explain this
Chakra = the binding force existing in everyone that connects everyone after hagoromo shared it
Ninshu = the said binding Chakra above used to mix Physical and mental energy together to produce a chakra that can be used for other purposes

So here Kawaki said he can't wield Ninshu and Naruto replied that is not true cause i think kawaki thinks he cant wield ninshu at all (and many other people also think only ninjas can wield it) but Naruto explained chakra exists in everyone and it is supposed to be a binding force but "We ninjas use it to power ninjutsu" Yes Ninjas use the chakra that exist in everyone to create ninshu (mental + physical energies bound together with chakra).
 
please permit me to use the word "Ninshu" so i can better explain this
Chakra = the binding force existing in everyone that connects everyone after hagoromo shared it
Ninshu = the said binding Chakra above used to mix Physical and mental energy together to produce a chakra that can be used for other purposes

So here Kawaki said he can't wield Ninshu and Naruto replied that is not true cause i think kawaki thinks he cant wield ninshu at all (and many other people also think only ninjas can wield it) but Naruto explained chakra exists in everyone and it is supposed to be a binding force but "We ninjas use it to power ninjutsu" Yes Ninjas use the chakra that exist in everyone to create ninshu (mental + physical energies bound together with chakra).
Lemme just fix a few things for you.

Chakra: The binding force that exists in everyone. Originally, Kaguya consumed the Chakra Fruit, and she passed chakra onto her sons Hagoromo and Hamura when she gave birth to them. After they sealed away Kaguya, Hagoromo went on to share this gift with the world.

Ninshu: The principle of connecting your mental energies with that of those around you, allowing for harmony, introduced by Hagoromo.
Ninjutsu: The principle of connecting your own physical and mental energies, allowing one to weaponize their chakra.

Everything is the same chakra, just different applications.

Kawaki said he could not perform ninjutsu, stating that he lacked chakra. However, Naruto refuted this and stated that chakra existed in everybody.
Only ninja can use chakra to perform ninjutsu, as they were trained to do so, but chakra exists in everybody.
C'mon man, this stuff is pretty clear.
 
Ofc it siphoned chakra. My point is Life force is also chakra which IT extracts with the usual chakra (for a shinobi)
If you were referring to Naruto's Baryon Mode with that first example, Naruto and Kurama's chakra are used to create an explosive new power.
This doesn't change the fact that Kurama basically converted his life force into chakra for Naruto.
In the case of the Eight Gates, nope. Those are nodes in the body that restrict the flow of chakra, which taijutsu masters can open through sheer will.
I think the 8G one was pretty clear because Madara saw Gai's life force (which already was chakra) prior to Gai using Night Guy.
I don't know what this cursed summon is, though. I have not seen the Boruto anime.
It's in the Kara actuation arc. A deer cannot possibly know how to convert mental and physical energies to create chakra yet chakra got siphoned from it leading to it's death.
 
Lemme just fix a few things for you.
i know the word hence why i said allow me to use ninshu for something it is not, i just want to differentiate between them

Ninjutsu: The principle of connecting your own physical and mental energies, allowing one to weaponize their chakra.
Everything is the same chakra, just different applications.
Everything is not the same. the ninshu when used to bind mental and physical energy creates the chakra used for ninjutsu
Kawaki said he could not perform ninjutsu,
no he stated he cant utilize the chakra the ninjas do.
then we also have other statements from the series about the said chakra(weaponized one) and how civilians cant bind their own physical and mental energies together to create that chakra(weaponized one).
and unless everyone in the series has learnt to knead their physical and mental energy together with chakra (the one shared by hagoromo)
stating that he lacked chakra. However, Naruto refuted this and stated that chakra existed in everybody.
Only ninja can use chakra to perform ninjutsu, as they were trained to do so, but chakra exists in everybody.
C'mon man, this stuff is pretty clear.
YEs and YES. it is very simple
Does chakra exist in everyone? YES
Is it everyone that can use the chakra to knead their physical and mental energies together to create the chakra needed for ninjutsu? NO

they need to be taught how to knead that chakra.


Like you said "only ninjas can perform ninjutsu" cause they know how to use the binding chakra to knead their physical and mental energies together to create the destructive form of chakra.
its like this everyone has Flour(binding chakra), Mental energy (Water) and Egg (Physical energy).
But is it everyone that can use this three to form Dough? NO
 
Now back to what i said, The chakra needed for genjutsu is the (binding chakra/energy) existing in everyone not the one made from kneading physical and mental energy together, cause not everyone can do that.
 
Kawaki said he could not perform ninjutsu, stating that he lacked chakra. However, Naruto refuted this and stated that chakra existed in everybody.
Does Chakra exist in humans? Yes

Can regular humans or animal (bar sage creatures) create chakra? No

So what else would be the "chakra" that exists? It's their life force. Life force is chakra and that's proven by both series.
Only ninja can use chakra to perform ninjutsu, as they were trained to do so, but chakra exists in everybody.
They were trained on how to create chakra and in turn use it for Ninjustu whereas regular humans never had such training.
 
Anyways let's not derail the thread

i agree with the OP as someone already linked a scan of not one jounin being affected by the genjustu casted during the Chuunin exams. That's enough justification for at least Jonin tier shinobi to have a degree of resistance to low to mid tier genjustu
 
"Heh... leave it to the Konoha elites..."
Why are we to assume somebody like Kisame, who has never done a single genjutsu-related thing in his life, nor has the same kind of training that the Konohagakure shinobi do is resistant to genjutsu?

Everybody at the Chunin Exams that saw the feathers and were unaffected by the genjutsu would get Resistance to Illusion Creation. However, we cannot just assume that everyone who is on the level of a Jonin has the same resistance, especially when half of the people on this list are not even Konohagakure shinobi. In fact, Shee, one of Kumogakure's Jonin and an adept genjutsu user, was caught by Sasuke's genjutsu with an ordinary Sharingan.
 
"Heh... leave it to the Konoha elites..."
Why are we to assume somebody like Kisame, who has never done a single genjutsu-related thing in his life, nor has the same kind of training that the Konohagakure shinobi do is resistant to genjutsu?

Everybody at the Chunin Exams that saw the feathers and were unaffected by the genjutsu would get Resistance to Illusion Creation. However, we cannot just assume that everyone who is on the level of a Jonin has the same resistance, especially when half of the people on this list are not even Konohagakure shinobi. In fact, Shee, one of Kumogakure's Jonin and an adept genjutsu user, was caught by Sasuke's genjutsu with an ordinary Sharingan.
So all konoha jounin and those shown to be awake during the knoha crush gets resistance to illusion creation and mind manipulation.

I also disagree for kisame but Mui should also get it, he fought hozuki and could see through all his genjutsu
 
"Heh... leave it to the Konoha elites..."
Why are we to assume somebody like Kisame, who has never done a single genjutsu-related thing in his life, nor has the same kind of training that the Konohagakure shinobi do is resistant to genjutsu?

Everybody at the Chunin Exams that saw the feathers and were unaffected by the genjutsu would get Resistance to Illusion Creation. However, we cannot just assume that everyone who is on the level of a Jonin has the same resistance, especially when half of the people on this list are not even Konohagakure shinobi. In fact, Shee, one of Kumogakure's Jonin and an adept genjutsu user, was caught by Sasuke's genjutsu with an ordinary Sharingan.
I mean, he's fought alongisde Itachi for years and you'd think he'd have learned how to in a sparring session or something (I don't know if it's canon but there's a cutscene in storm where they're sparring just before Itachi fights Sasuke)

At the very least, that means all Konoha ninja jonin tier or above should get resistance.
So all konoha jounin and those shown to be awake during the knoha crush gets resistance to illusion creation and mind manipulation.

I also disagree for kisame but Mui should also get it, he fought hozuki and could see through all his genjutsu
See above for Kisame, and for Muu while I agree for some resistance, I don't know if he actually saw through ALL of Gengetsu's illusions. After all, how would they be rivals if Gengetsu's main trick was completely ineffective?
 
I should have specified full blood

Iirc it actually said kaguya was the first one of earth with chakra, and one of the scans u sent I think that's referring to current day because it said "if all chakra is reunited"
Retcon
The said chakra(Ninshu) is not even in the said ninjas every time.
look at this as an example
UwSwAWY.jpg


There are other examples even in the series. Every energy is called chakra, but the energies are different from each other
Kneading chakra ≠ having chakra in the body
 
I'm not even gonna lie, the "resistances" in Naruto aren't even resistances. They just have methods to break out.
It's like giving someone resistance to fire manipulation because they have a water bottle.
If Genjutsu was paralysis, resistance is not being paralyzed at all or being able to move to an extent, while what they do in Naruto is finding methods of breaking out.
Or a better one, drowning. Resistance is water breathing while what they do in Naruto is swim to the top and breathe.
Not even, dying. Resistance is being immortal while what they do in Naruto is resurrect.
These aren't resistances at all.

Kurenai put Itachi in a genjutsu. If he was resistance with his Dojutsu, he'd never be put in a genjutsu. Random ninja put Kakashi, Guy, Sakura, Shikamaru, and others in a genjutsu. If they were resistance, they'd never be put in a genjutsu.

That isn't even resistance.
We're gonna ignore this
 
I'm not even gonna lie, the "resistances" in Naruto aren't even resistances. They just have methods to break out.
It's like giving someone resistance to fire manipulation because they have a water bottle.
If Genjutsu was paralysis, resistance is not being paralyzed at all or being able to move to an extent, while what they do in Naruto is finding methods of breaking out.
Or a better one, drowning. Resistance is water breathing while what they do in Naruto is swim to the top and breathe.
Not even, dying. Resistance is being immortal while what they do in Naruto is resurrect.
These aren't resistances at all.

Kurenai put Itachi in a genjutsu. If he was resistance with his Dojutsu, he'd never be put in a genjutsu. Random ninja put Kakashi, Guy, Sakura, Shikamaru, and others in a genjutsu. If they were resistance, they'd never be put in a genjutsu.

That isn't even resistance.

Every Ninja with over borderline common sense in Naruto knows how to do this as well. This isn't resistance to mind manipulation, this is just a method to get out of it.

This seems to make the most sense to me.
 
This seems to make the most sense to me.

Immediately upon seeing the feathers, Naruto started to fall asleep
Naruto Chapter 114 Page 15

Naruto Chapter 114 Page 16

Even after most of the people had fallen asleep and before they used Kai, Kakashi Guy and Sakura weren't sleepy. This shows they could resist it to an extent before even releasing it.
 
I mean...other Byakugan users have resistance so...
Then they should get axed
I already said why

If Kabuto had no resistance a regular genjutsu would've sufficed, as Sasuke used a normal genjutsu to have a cloud ninja tell him where Bee was
No, because we don't know Itachi's arsenal when it comes to genjutsu. And it's in character for Itachi to use potent genjutsu against people, like when he used Tsukuyomi on Kakashi and Kid Sasuke.
Naruto and Tsunade aren't known as geniuses across the board.

Ok, but it seems kinda disingenous to assume someone with the highest exams scores in history doesn't know basic genjutsu stuff like breaking out. Plus he has yin element and
main-qimg-0c69eb2c5b28847cfbf3255d6a413006
Your assuming something never shown.
Naruto has Yin element as well, has all elements, and he has no skill in genjutsu.
Tsunade has Yin element and she has no shown skill in genjutsu
Karin was able to detect if her chakra was being affected by genjutsu against Danzo. You can sense if your chakra is being disturbed
Naruto Chapter 477 Page 4
This has nothing to do with anything, this is proof of her sensing capabilities.
Kid Obito could tell if someone was put in a genjutsu.
And then there's that basic thing that even Naruto could somewhat do, which someone with excellent chakra control could do on another level (as seen with Sakura being the onle one to break out of the clam genjutsu in the last). Also an MS genjutsu is far more powerful than a regular one, so it makes sense that it worked then.
The fact that they need to break out shows that it's not resistance.
But if Hiruzen studied all of Konoha's genjutsu he should know of counters. That seems like a pretty hard thing to miss.
This should've been the case against Hashirama and Tobirama. When they put Hiruzen under genjutsu he should've broken out.
After the revisions he'll be High 7-A, and already has 6-C for Sage Mode.
That 6-C is getting axed via my SM CRT
I mean, that sorta does sound like a resistance. Negation works too though I guess. Although there is such a thing as genjutsu resistance of some sort, given the fact that Sasuke wasn't affected by IT, Deidara could train his eye to be immune to non powerful genjutsu, etc.
You're missing a lot about resistances.
IT works by producing light and whoever gets hit with the light is put under genjutsu.
Sasuke blocked the light. He didn't stop the genjutsu from affecting him, he stopped it from reaching him.

Deidara trained his eye to counter it. He didn't train his eye to not get affected, he trained it to see through it. He wouldn't have to see through it if it didn't affect him
There's such a thing as limited resistance.
This isn't limited resistance.
Again, would you give someone "limited resistance to drowning" because they can swim to the top of a sea to breathe?
I don't think it's that they can't break out, it's just harder to break out of sharingan genjutsu than regular genjutsu.
Cee is a Yin release user who's also a sensory type and he got bodied by a regular sharingan genjutsu

There's no proof of sharingan genjutsu being more potent, all it's shown to be mainly is being produced via their eyes
 
Kurenai put Itachi in a genjutsu. If he was resistance with his Dojutsu, he'd never be put in a genjutsu. Random ninja put Kakashi, Guy, Sakura, Shikamaru, and others in a genjutsu. If they were resistance, they'd never be put in a genjutsu.
No kurenai thoght she put itachi in a genjutsu, he was unaffected by it. i mean he literally said "Genjutsu of that level has no effect on me" iirc.
that is to say yes they do resist illusions and mind manipulation, so its not a matter of negating illusions and mind manipulation alone, they can also resist it.
the keyword is potency, in the novel a guy resisted normal sharigan genjutsu and was unaffected but fell to MS genjutsu immediately.
 
Immediately upon seeing the feathers, Naruto started to fall asleep
Naruto Chapter 114 Page 15

Naruto Chapter 114 Page 16

Even after most of the people had fallen asleep and before they used Kai, Kakashi Guy and Sakura weren't sleepy. This shows they could resist it to an extent before even releasing it.
they resisted since they did not fall under it.
negation will be them disrupting their chakra after they are under the mind manipulation already, something
 
No kurenai thoght she put itachi in a genjutsu, he was unaffected by it. i mean he literally said "Genjutsu of that level has no effect on me" iirc.
that is to say yes they do resist illusions and mind manipulation, so its not a matter of negating illusions and mind manipulation alone, they can also resist it.
the keyword is potency, in the novel a guy resisted normal sharigan genjutsu and was unaffected but fell to MS genjutsu immediately.
This is false.
Itachi fell under the genjutsu, he just found a method to reverse it, which is the Demonic Illusion: Mirror Heaven and Earth Change jutsu.

If he didn't fall under it, he wouldn't have been in that tree illusion at all.
 
Back
Top