MaxLevel_King
He/Him- 356
- 64
Explanation Page (Most of the scans I use in this CRT will come from here): https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Maou_Gakuin_no_Futekigousha_Explanation_Page
The source of this verse's information comes from the Explanation Page on the wiki. A lot of the information from that page that has been accepted as fact isn't true, so I'm here to refute it. I will highlight every claim in the page that I've found to be false, provide the scan for it, and then explain using the scan why they're false.
Note: The specific points I'm arguing against are highlighted in Bold. Another thing, if the entirety of the scan includes information that isn't relevant to the claim being made and my refutation, I'll cut it out so that we can get straight to the point. You can always go to the Explanation Page to confirm the entire scan for yourself if need be.
Claim: Inhabitants from a world located in layer 1 would refer to a world located in layer 2 as a deeper world (or deep world when compared to the depth of their world), and inhabitants from a world located in layer 22 would refer to a world located in layer 21 as a shallower world (or shallow world when compared to the depth of their world).
Refutation: This isn't stated anywhere in the scan, nor is it stated anywhere in the story. While it's true that a Shallow World would refer to another Shallow World that's deeper than it as a deeper World, it will never refer to that Shallow World as a Deep World. The only Worlds referred to as Deep Worlds are Worlds located in Layers 21-99+. It is because of this claim that Balzarondo's statement is taken to apply to any deeper World. I'll get to that later.
Claim: Using the example from the statement, a deeper world would gain 1 magic power and 1 weight of order from any shallower world above it. If we consider that there are countless worlds on each layer, then a deeper world would gain an innumerable amount of magic power and weight of order from the countless shallower worlds above it, causing the overall power as well as the strength of laws and concepts in the deeper world to be at least innumerably greater than that of the shallower worlds above it. ("Innumerably" is used as a synonym for "countlessly".)
Refutation: It is because of this claim that the reasoning that Layers transcend each other (and it wouldn't even be the Layers, but the Worlds that sunk into those Layers) is treated as fact. It's true that there are countless Worlds in each layer, and that Fire Dew from countless Worlds flows down into deeper Worlds. Using Layers 1 and 2 as an example, Fire Dew from countless Worlds in Layer 1 flows down into countless Worlds in Layer 2. However, that doesn't mean that a single Layer 2 World steals Fire Dew from countless Layer 1 Worlds. The reason is that the countless amount of Fire Dew that flows down from Layer 1 is distributed between countless Layer 2 Worlds. Countless and infinite are not the same. Countless refers to a finite quantity that is too great to be counted. Meaning that a finite uncountable quantity of Fire Dew that is distributed between countless Worlds wouldn't be a countless quantity for a single of those countless Worlds.
Claim: In a deeper world the power of everything, i.e. "Strength, speed, toughness, magic power, everything.", is in another dimension when compared to a shallower world. (The difference between layers is compared to the difference between dimensions, but it is not stated that deeper layers are higher dimensions.) World-destroying magic from shallower worlds, meaning magic capable of destroying an entire space-time continuum, cannot destroy an ordinary object (in this case a ship) from a deeper world. The matter in a deeper world is also stronger than any of the matter in a shallower world.
Refutation: Balzarondo's statement that a shallow world-destroying magic wouldn't be able to destroy "a single ship here" in "this small world, which exists deeper than your small world" doesn't mean that it applies to any deeper World even 1 layer apart as people like to claim. He didn't state that "because this World is deeper you can't destroy this ship", he just stated "In this small world, which exists deeper than your small world. . .". Context is needed for this statement. Balzarondo is from the Holy Sword World Hyfolia which is a Deep World (Layers 21-99+), and he specifically referred to shallow world-destroying magic, or magic that can destroy Shallow Worlds (Layers 1-10). You also have to keep in mind that the Militia World is from Layer 1. You can't use the fact that shallow world-destroying magic that can't destroy a ship from a World at least 11-20+ layers deeper than it means that world-destroying magic from Layer 1 can't destroy a ship from a Layer 2 World.
Proof;
Note: Before anyone starts making any assumptions, neither the Venuzdonoa Downgrade CRT nor this CRT have been made because "I just want to downgrade the verse" or "I don't like this series" or "I want my favorite character from another verse to beat Anos" or anything stupid like that. I don't have anything against this verse as MGnF is legitimately one of my favorite series, and I couldn't care less about who can or can't beat Anos or vice-versa. The reason that I've made both of these CRT's is because I feel that a lot of the information about this verse that's treated as fact either has no solid evidence behind it or is outright wrong. The difference between me and most of the other fans of this series on this website is that while other fans do all they can to try and give this verse the highest tiers possible, I simply try to give this verse the tiers that I feel is accurate and actually supported by the series itself. That is all.
Agree:
Neutral:
Disagree: @YoPercy @EldemadeDityjon @Godsatoshi23 @Fixxed @Robo @Artorimachi_Meteoraft @Tatsumi504 @Rendynoc0unter @DarkDragonMedeus @Just_a_Random_Butler @Dereck03
The source of this verse's information comes from the Explanation Page on the wiki. A lot of the information from that page that has been accepted as fact isn't true, so I'm here to refute it. I will highlight every claim in the page that I've found to be false, provide the scan for it, and then explain using the scan why they're false.
Note: The specific points I'm arguing against are highlighted in Bold. Another thing, if the entirety of the scan includes information that isn't relevant to the claim being made and my refutation, I'll cut it out so that we can get straight to the point. You can always go to the Explanation Page to confirm the entire scan for yourself if need be.
Claim: Inhabitants from a world located in layer 1 would refer to a world located in layer 2 as a deeper world (or deep world when compared to the depth of their world), and inhabitants from a world located in layer 22 would refer to a world located in layer 21 as a shallower world (or shallow world when compared to the depth of their world).
|
Claim: Using the example from the statement, a deeper world would gain 1 magic power and 1 weight of order from any shallower world above it. If we consider that there are countless worlds on each layer, then a deeper world would gain an innumerable amount of magic power and weight of order from the countless shallower worlds above it, causing the overall power as well as the strength of laws and concepts in the deeper world to be at least innumerably greater than that of the shallower worlds above it. ("Innumerably" is used as a synonym for "countlessly".)
The spherical blackboard must have been a magical tool as it was transparent and what appeared inside were silver bubbles. It seemingly imitated five Shallow Layer Worlds and one Deep Layer World. "Let's say, for example, that the Shallow Layer Worlds have a magic power of 10 and the weight of their Order is 10. The same goes for the Deep Layer World." 'Shallow Layer World: Magic Power: 10. Weight: 10' 'Deep Layer World: Magic Power: 10. Weight: 10' was added. "According to the Order of the Silver Sea, magic power flows to the deep layer and the Order exerts its power to the depths. The magic power of the Shallow Layer World shifts by one, same for its Order." One magic power and weight are subtracted. It was rewritten as 'Shallow Layer World: Magic Power 9. Weight 9'. "The magic power and Order are given to the Deep Layer World, turning it into power." From each of the five Shallow Layer Worlds, one magic power and weight are transferred for a total of five magic power and weight, which are added to the ones the Deep Layer World originally had. There, the Deep Layer World becomes 'Magic Power 15, Weight 15'. "It's actually not that simple, but this is the basic principle of the Silver Sea's Order. A small world that possesses numerous magic power and a strong functioning Order is heavy and sinks into the depths. Thus, it is considered deep." |
Claim: In a deeper world the power of everything, i.e. "Strength, speed, toughness, magic power, everything.", is in another dimension when compared to a shallower world. (The difference between layers is compared to the difference between dimensions, but it is not stated that deeper layers are higher dimensions.) World-destroying magic from shallower worlds, meaning magic capable of destroying an entire space-time continuum, cannot destroy an ordinary object (in this case a ship) from a deeper world. The matter in a deeper world is also stronger than any of the matter in a shallower world.
"In this small world, which exists deeper than your small world, the power of everything is in another dimension. Strength, speed, toughness, magic power, everything. Even the resistance of a grain of air would be a weight to you. If you unleash your shallow, world-destroying magic, you will not be able to destroy a single ship here." |
Proof;
Source: https://ncode.syosetu.com/n1578dx/504/ "Pablohetala's academy alliance is one world, the phantom beast agency of the disaster world Evezeino. The highest-ranking phantom beast they have is called the Lion of Arzenon's destruction. Evezeino has long been in a hostile relationship with the holy sword world Hyforia. However, I recently joined Pablohetara.” "Recently?" "About a week ago. Evezeino was originally a deep world, and he won the silver water battle in an instant, and was named at the bottom of the Holy Six Academy." . . . "What is Holy Jouroku Roku Gakuin?" "It refers to Pablo Hetara's rank up to sixth place. Currently, the number one rank is the magic bullet world Elenesia. Therefore, this Pablo Hetara Palace is located here in the Seventh Elenesia. The second place is the holy sword world Hyphoria. These two worlds. In addition, for a long time, small worlds below the third place could not follow, but Evezeino is still low in the ranking, but it has the potential to match it." |
Note: Before anyone starts making any assumptions, neither the Venuzdonoa Downgrade CRT nor this CRT have been made because "I just want to downgrade the verse" or "I don't like this series" or "I want my favorite character from another verse to beat Anos" or anything stupid like that. I don't have anything against this verse as MGnF is legitimately one of my favorite series, and I couldn't care less about who can or can't beat Anos or vice-versa. The reason that I've made both of these CRT's is because I feel that a lot of the information about this verse that's treated as fact either has no solid evidence behind it or is outright wrong. The difference between me and most of the other fans of this series on this website is that while other fans do all they can to try and give this verse the highest tiers possible, I simply try to give this verse the tiers that I feel is accurate and actually supported by the series itself. That is all.
Agree:
Neutral:
Disagree: @YoPercy @EldemadeDityjon @Godsatoshi23 @Fixxed @Robo @Artorimachi_Meteoraft @Tatsumi504 @Rendynoc0unter @DarkDragonMedeus @Just_a_Random_Butler @Dereck03
Last edited: