MCU Captain Marvel attack speed

[Qawsedf234]

The beam doesn’t bend. I

The clearly do

That’s just her moving her arms faster than the attack travels.

So are your arguing for a FTL upgrade for Captain Marvel?

 

[AnonymousBlank]

The clearly do

Literally don’t unless you completely disregard the fact that the source of the beam changes direction.

So are your arguing for a FTL upgrade for Captain Marvel?

Nope. I completely disagree since it only meets one criteria. My point with that post was that the “anti feat” you brought up isn’t actually an anti feat.

 

[Qawsedf234]

Literally don’t unless you completely disregard the fact that the source of the beam changes direction.

You mean something that an actual laser doesn't do

 

[AnonymousBlank]

That’s nice. A video that doesn’t mean anything when the emitter isn’t moving at speeds even approaching sub sonic nor is the camera even capable of recording at speeds that would allow to see a bend in the beam.

If I aim a laser pointer to my left and briefly turn it on then rotate it to the right to do the same, does the first beam that has already been emitted magically alter its position to stay in line with the current direction of the new beam? No. It doesn’t. Why? Because that would be stupid and go against how lasers actually work. And before someone tries to argue that they are two separate beams and thus would travel in different directions, even if you kept it on while rotating the laser pointer, the light that left it first would still be travelling that same direction even after you change the direction. This is the same shit with Carol except hers isn’t lightspeed.

 

[Hellbeast]

That’s nice. A video that doesn’t mean anything

**** you mean that was a sick lightshow
I definitely agree the bending evidence is flimsy but I'm pretty against the revision based on OP

 

[GroundX1]

Photon powers

could you send a link to this?

 

[AnonymousBlank]

**** you mean that was a sick lightshow

I don’t understand the appeal of light shows so I can’t say lol

I definitely agree the bending evidence is flimsy but I'm pretty against the revision based on OP

Like I said, I’m against it too. I’m just pointing out that it isn’t bending.

 

[Hellbeast]

I don’t understand the appeal of light shows so I can’t say lol

Play some sick dance music and you're down

Like I said, I’m against it too. I’m just pointing out that it isn’t bending.

Ah that makes sense.
If the other criteria are met I can live with it but I don't think that's there.

Nothing but the Photon thing is brought up; there's not really any other statements it's light based and I certainly can't remember it being high temperature in the same way as like Heat Vision

 

[Marvel_Champion_07]

I certainly can't remember it being high temperature in the same way as like Heat Vision

What about this?

 

[AnonymousBlank]

That kinda goes against it since she is pushed back meaning that the photon blasts have mass.

 

[Hellbeast]

What about this?

It certainly looks like Heating it yeah. The problem is her blasts are knocking her back which implies they have mass of some kind behind them. I still feel you'd need to fit more requirements before you convince me though

 

[Marvel_Champion_07]

Then why does every lightspeed attack that pushes things back get accepted?

 

[Bernkastelll]

Then why does every lightspeed attack that pushes things back get accepted?

They have more stuff proving lightspeed than the number of things against it, if a feat have 4 requisits that shows that it is indeed lightspeed but only 1 feat against it, the number of feats that prove it being lightspeed is way more solid

 

[Marvel_Champion_07]

So there's photons and heating for it, pushing back and possibly bending against it.

 

[Bernkastelll]

I dont think that count as bending, if I move my arm faster than light, the trajectory of the countless photons will indeed change and it will be like the feat that happend

 

[Marvel_Champion_07]

I dont think that count as bending, if I move my arm faster than light, the trajectory of the countless photons will indeed change and it will be like the feat that happend

So photons & heating VS pushing back: 2 VS 1
It also travels in straight lines every time other than that one scan, but eh

 

[Dalesean027]

Yeah as several people have said I feel like saying that's the light bending is iffy and doesn't really work here but this still doesn't meet the other requirements and needs more evidence

 

[RisingIons]

I'm even more confused by how she's so destructive with massless particles.

 

[Nullflowerblush]

the Flash doesn't actually punch with infinite mass

no wait doesn't he actually do that
All jokes aside, yes, they are hot (which is not a criteria to be met), and they are called a photon...
now here are a number of reasons it isn't lightspeed-

1. They explode.
2. Never stated to be lightspeed; only fits one criteria
3. Curves when Carol wills them to; real light does not curve naturally—the beams would have remained straight like Tony's wrist lasers
4. They are cosmic energy blasts and are a result of being blasted by the Tesseract; cosmic Infinity Stone energy ≠ light
5. They look like fire in this scene (just thought this was weird)

 

[Armorchompy]

against the SoL upgrade for sure

 

[Dalesean027]

This has been thoroughly rejected then and should be closed