Shapeshifting needs more context
Throughout the whole game of Super Mario RPG, whenever Mario talks to people, he sometimes transforms into people. He does this to explain scenarios, because Mario only communicates by doing this and hand gestures for the most part.
Mario got blatantly affected by that petrification.
I know he did. But if he can break out of Petrification, he should get a resistance, because if Petrification was used on say you or me, that would be the be-all end-all to us.
Characters breaking out of a petrification is a pretty common thing in fiction, especially Video Games. I don't think it can be rated as outright resistance.
Then they should also get a resistance.
Bowser never even used the ability on them. And the Mario Maker thing is obvious game mechanic.
Fair enough on the Bowser thing. And if it was just Game Mechanics alone, Mario wouldn't react to it. It erases everything else, but not Mario.
The fact that Mario sweats imply that he isn't immune to it. But clearly, the game just doesn't let you erase Mario for obvious reasons.
The fact Mario sweats just shows he doesn't understand what's going on, and this still would warrant a resistance to Existence Erasure. I don't see why it wouldn't. The eraser that erases basically everything else in the game can't erase Mario, and Mario reacts to the eraser. Sure, it's 4th Wall Awareness, but that doesn't invalidate this.
Again, Mario is blatantly affected by this.
This is Mario literally taking himself apart and putting himself back together whenever he goes down a pipe. You're right, it probably shouldn't be Resistance to Matter Manipulation, it should just be some level of Regenerationn for Paper Mario, Bowser, Peach, and Luigi.
Game Mechanic. Or just plain...nothing at all.
Well, as with the first case, not Game Mechanics, but you're right, can't really attach an ability to this.
Unless it's their Standard Equipment, no.
And I suppose. Mario does have the Star Rod, though. Which reminds me, he should get Plot Manipulation added to his page for that.
For anything related to the Manga: It's not canon.
Is there any specific reason we're treating the manga as non-canon?
Soul Manipulation - We'd need an explicit instance of them being shown/stated to be capable of attacking souls while said soul is in the opponent's body, rather than just harming ghosts
In a recent highlighted thread, it was agreed that being able to harm ghosts counts as being able to harm intangible beings and souls.
I disagree with shapeshifting as its literally just a visual aid for the player to know what the hell he's doing, and you know...its funny.
This isn't just a visual aid for the players, though. This is literally Mario explaining to other characters stuff that happened earlier in the game that the players had already seen with Shapeshifting. If it was just a visual aid, that wouldn't make sense. They could just have Mario have dialog in the game, instead. And it being funny doesn't mean that he can't do it. Like, he does it.
I'm sorry but all of these abilities are out-right speculation with no reason or context.
Not really. Not all of them. Not half of them. Maybe just a few of them. Mario Shapeshifting? That's seen. Saying it would be anything else is just speculation. Mario breaking out of Petrification? Saying that would be anything else is speculation. Peach and Bowser being stated by Word of God text that they could live for 10,000 years? Not sure how that would be anything besides Longevity. Mario getting blown up like a balloon, popping, and reforming shortly after? Like, that's not Mid-High Regenerationn?
They don't even imply the characters have such abilities at all and doesn't even remotely resemble the abilities suggested.
Mario turning into Peach and Bowser doesn't resemble Shapeshifting? Mario breaking out of Petrification doesn't resemble Resistance to Petrification? Mario changing the direction of his projectiles in mid-air doesn't look like Telekinesis? Can you elabourate on what these things resemble then? Why don't they imply that the characters have these abilities?
Please, I ask you stop with these abilities list for the Mario series. I apologize if this is rude but I think it's getting out of hand at this point.
I'm sorry to say it, but me taking time to find these abilities that Mario characters have and you coming into the threads I take my time to make to add them to get them to be added on Marioverse profiles and then you rejecting literally all of them without explaining yourself at all did kind of hurt my feelings.
If a few of these get rejected, I can understand why. Leaving me in the dark as to why they're getting rejected, though, isn't the way to go about it. I want to know why they're getting rejected.
While this thread is still going on, there are some other abilities I want to address. King Boo should get Sealing and a Resistance to it for being able to seal people into paintings and also escape them. Paper Mario, Bowser, and Luigi should get Type 4 Immortality, because after helping out Jaydes in Super Paper Mario, she said she would tilt the scales in their favour if they ever got a game over. Paper Mario should get Sound Manipulation from the Attack FX Badges, One Hit Kill from
Bump Attack,
Spin Attack, and
First Attack, Durability Negation from
D-Down Jump,
D-Down Pound, Resistance to Fire Manipulation from
Fire Shield, Ice Manipulation from
Ice Power and
Ice Manipulation, Extrasensory Perception with
Peekaboo, Electricity Manipulation from
Zap Tap, and Resistance to Status Effect Inducement with
Feeling Fine.