Luke Skywalker vs Anakin Skywalker

[Auggie123456]

This Is ROTS Anakin and ROTJ Luke

Luke Skywalker

Luke Skywalker is the main protagonist of the Star Wars original trilogy. The son of famous Jedi Knight Anakin Skywalker, he was left on Tatooine with his aunt and uncle after the fall of the Jedi Order. 19 years later, he encountered former Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi (Under the alias "Ben...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Anakin Skywalker

Anakin Skywalker is a Human Jedi Knight and the Chosen One destined to balance the Force. Born created by the Force itself, Anakin had a gift of unprecedented potential in the Force. Discovered by Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn and his Padawan, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin expressed his desire to become a...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Luke:

Anakin: 3 (Yamato666) (Stillwinston) (TOAAPRESENCE1)

Incon:

 

[Yamato666]

anakin on mustafar was 80% percent of darth sidious's power, and as we saw luke was not able to beat sidious without darth vaders help. So if you dont wanna go in specifics i think anakin wins.

 

[Auggie123456]

Alright so that’s a vote for Anakin right?

 

[Yamato666]

Alright so that’s a vote for Anakin right?

yes

 

[Auggie123456]

Gotcha

 

[Auggie123456]

Bump

 

[Hasch]

Yeah but Sidious kinda used a surprise attack on Luke and couldn't stop Vader from launching him into an explosion.

 

[Stillwinston]

Tbf context can matter a lot in these kinda things, Luke had also just come off a hard fought duel with Vader (Both were kinda sandbagging in a sense but still)

 

[Auggie123456]

Standard Battle Assumptions is being used

 

[Stillwinston]

Yeah that aside I'm thinking Anakin probably takes this with mid to high difficulty I guess. In terms of their physical attributes they're about on par, neither is gonna tire out quickly. Anakin's more aggressive and willing to bust out dark side powers if need be if we're going with EP3, doubly so if this is him at Mustafar.

It won't be easy and it won't be quick, but Anakin prolly takes it with several busted ribs and other injuries I guess

 

[Hasch]

It depends on whats canon right now.

It used to be that Anakin > DV because of the burns but then it was apparently retconed to be DV > Anakin or something.

 

[Stillwinston]

Well my assumption was that DV was better than Anakin in a duel generally speaking (Like a 6.5/10 majority if they fought) cause of things like learning from his mistakes among other stuff lol.

I'm still kinda leaning on Anakin here, namely for being willing to bust out dark side powers and being far more aggressive and breaking down Luke's defence I guess

 

[Auggie123456]

Well my assumption was that DV was better than Anakin in a duel generally speaking (Like a 6.5/10 majority if they fought) cause of things like learning from his mistakes among other stuff lol.

I'm still kinda leaning on Anakin here, namely for being willing to bust out dark side powers and being far more aggressive and breaking down Luke's defence I guess

That a vote for Anakin?

 

[Stillwinston]

I guess so till I'm convinced otherwise

 

[Auggie123456]

k

 

[Auggie123456]

Bump

 

[Auggie123456]

Bump

 

[Auggie123456]

Bump

 

[Hunterzillas]

Wasn't Darth Vader in Episode 6 canonically stated to have surpassed his previous peak of power?

And Luke still beat him.

 

[Auggie123456]

is that a vote for luke

 

[LordTracer]

Is this Disney or EU?

 

[Auggie123456]

disney

 

[LordTracer]

Oh, I can’t really give input then.

 

[Auggie123456]

Thats fine

 

[TOAAPRESENCE1]

Is this legend luke or Disney luke?

Edit: saw the response of someone that commented the same and the answer

Since this is disney luke I give it to anakin as this luke is not something to really think about compared to legends

 

[Auggie123456]

Disney as I said

 

[Auggie123456]

alright vote counted

 

[Auggie123456]

Bump