- 18,946
- 27,763
- Thread starter
- #41
Not relevant at all to the accuracy of the rating.It is as it causes no issues when it doesnt scale to anyone but itself.
If that's the case Yhwach and those who scale to him should be 3-A to Low 2-C since Yhwach is stated capable of creating the Bleach universe. SD and DK should be somewhere in tier 4 (depending how many stars are in their skies) for being able to create their realms.Gross false equivalence. The bleach realms have absolutely never been assumed as being some transparent space-times like you are suggesting Kaguyas here, for whatever reason, are. Not to derail this into something else, but this is an entirely different situation and context.
The bleach realms and the contents within said realms are accepted as universes. The stars in Kaguyas realms making them cosmic size should be looked at the same way.
Literally, all Kaguya has is a creation statement + a visual of a star in her realm. Same exact case for SD and DK, they have visuals of stars in their realms and a creation statement. Same case for Yhwach, their are visuals of stars in the realms (plus confirmation that the stars exist) and a creation statement.
So Kaguya with a little bit of Shinobi alliance chakra can make an attack that scales trillions of times above anything else she has, but it's not an outlier because it's a special attack? Uh no.See above. And also, im fairly certain that the former case with SD and DK are outliers, while in this case, Kaguya is doing it with something that scales to absolutely nothing but itself.
If so, that is another false example.
I'm beginning to wonder if you know what an outlier is. Really big number for attack potency =/= outlier.Once again, see above. The tier is only with the move. Said move scales to nothing but itself. Scaling from characters where they are either outliers, inconsistencies, or different cases all together are not the same as this particular case.
As defined by the site, An Outlier is an event or incident that is considered to be completely and irreconcilably inconsistent with a character, entity, group, or series' normal displayed level of power. Additionally, However, efforts should be made to try to reconcile outliers with other canon information, and only very extreme examples should be classed as completely unusable.
Just because a rating or feat is the highest the verse as seen up until that point does not make it an outlier. More than one character scaling to a high tiered feat doesn't make it an outlier. Scaling more than one special attack does not make it an outlier. Y'all use this outlier argument when you see something too high and don't like it.
Yes, I agree, a creation feat is a creation feat. I am not making this thread to say otherwise, I am making this thread to consistency check the site.One staff member's takeaway on how we judge cosmic creation isn't exactly enticing. And I disagree with that anyway.
A creation feat is blatantly that, a creation feat. Now whether or not the feat is an outlier or causes major inconsistencies in tiering and scaling is a completely different situation, but that doesnt change the fact that the feat, for in and of what itself is, would be a creation feat. Theres 0 reason to believe that the contents within said realm are magically outside of it and the space-time is some transparent dimensional space where things outside of the realm are seen.
That rises to a level of mental gymnastics and logic not implied anywhere within the given series, and its the exact same case here with Naruto.
I'll say it again for any confused, just because a creation feat scales to your regular statistics, does not make it an outlier or an inconsistency. However, you cannot tell me that Kaguya absorbing Shinobi Alliance chakra amping her AP trillions of times via ETSO is 100% consistent and not an outlier, and not apply the same generosity to other verses. It's plain hypocrisy.
Kaguya's chakra >>>>>> weaker form juubi chakra = small planetary worth of chakra >>>>> Shinobi Alliance chakra btw. But currently we accept Kaguya absorbing a peon amount of chakra can amp her trillions of times and not be an outlier. Which I'm not inherently against, as long as we are consistent with that mindset.