Isekai at Peace Discussion Thread

[SweetDao]

Never fully into the High 1-A, I know it was too good to be true

oh well, at least the low tiers got upgraded

You would still need someone to do a thread tho

 

[Noneless21]

Well probably not me because me too monke brain to even understand why she was disqualified

The last time I tried to downgrade it's because the author deleted some stuff that was kinda important for her rating which is based, he should do that more often

 

[SweetDao]

The last time I tried to downgrade it's because the author deleted some stuff that was kinda important for her rating which is based, he should do that more often

You want SV below Yogurt?!

 

[Orioreeem]

I mean shoudn't she still qualify? Nebula is 1-A via her own thing while Shiro is High 1-A via R-F a whole new system superior to the other

 

[Fantric]

You want SV below Yogurt?!

Isn't Yogurt 3-A now? At least you tried lol

 

[Noneless21]

to be honest things might change? At least they're trying to make High 1-A even harder to get (which is very fair, because it's starting to feel like second version of 1-A at this point)

 

[SweetDao]

Isn't Yogurt 3-A now? At least you tried lol

I didn't just "try", I succeeded. I just need to make up a new justification for the few characters that will be impacted by this (Yogurt, UEG, ...).

 

[Fantric]

I mean shoudn't she still qualify? Nebula is 1-A via her own thing while Shiro is High 1-A via R-F a whole new system superior to the other

If I understand it correctly, you need an infinite hierarchy of 1-A beings and R>F over that as a whole so not really.

 

[SweetDao]

I mean shoudn't she still qualify? Nebula is 1-A via her own thing while Shiro is High 1-A via R-F a whole new system superior to the other

Tbf, the main issue is that Nebula shouldn't qualify for 1-A in the first place and should be Low 1-A instead.

 

[SweetDao]

If I understand it correctly, you need an infinite hierarchy of 1-A beings and R>F over that as a whole so not really.

No, you don't need any hierarchy, you just need some very good statement that puts you above the quality of "1-A" (not just a realm or a hierarchy).

 

[Fantric]

So we just only need a proper Nebula being 1-A scale and Shiro is H1-A again?

 

[SweetDao]

So we just only need a proper Nebula being 1-A scale and Shiro is H1-A again?

I guess you could see it that way, but eh. From what I've seen, I doubt Nebula has anything (for now) that can put her at that level.

 

[Noneless21]

that's kinda weird, if Nebula even encompasses the dimensionless stratum that houses Makina's true form, that's kinda textbook 1-A, from my understanding

well in any case I'll just let Pegasus to see the thread, she getting booted from High 1-A or not, it's up in the air

 

[SweetDao]

that's kinda weird, if Nebula even encompasses the dimensionless stratum that houses Makina's true form, that's kinda textbook 1-A, from my understanding

Why not one layer into Low 1-A?

 

[Fantric]

that's kinda weird, if Nebula even encompasses the dimensionless stratum that houses Makina's true form, that's kinda textbook 1-A, from my understanding

well in any case I'll just let Pegasus to see the thread, she getting booted from High 1-A or not, it's up in the air

It should be but....I can honestly see an argument that puts her just higher into L1-A....

 

[Noneless21]

i think it's because we use the > symbol to hitting the home with Nebula's tiering which is a mistake but that's just me

 

[SweetDao]

I kinda forgot about it tbf, but that's irrelevant. The way Nebula is portrayed doesn't correlate with a higher quality nor BDE type 2. If you assume the Makina stuff is truly Low 1-A, it would be a realm with BDE 1, so encompassing said realm and "being absolutely superior" to it would just be a layer into it.

 

[Orioreeem]

Why not one layer into Low 1-A?

Isn't Low 1-A sum of all possible dimensions. So if something is dimensionless and bigger then it, it should be 1-A. I don't know how you can be a layer in Low 1-A if low 1-A is supremum and sum of everything. Heck it being dimensionless and bigger then everything below it strait up can't be Low 1-A anymore because Low 1-A is still all about dimensions

 

[SweetDao]

Isn't Low 1-A sum of all possible dimensions. So if something is dimensionless and bigger then it, it should be 1-A. I don't know how you can be a layer in Low 1-A if low 1-A is supremum and sum of everything. Heck it being dimensionless and bigger then everything below it strait up can't be Low 1-A anymore because Low 1-A is still all about dimensions

Yeah, but that doesn't mean you can't have layers into Low 1-A. Heck, you can have more "layers" into Low 1-A than the "quantity" that represent Low 1-A in the first place. Yeah, that's wild. Also, no, you can have some void that are "dimensionless" and "bigger" than the rest of reality and still be Low 1-A depending on the description themselves (more often than not, the lack of description).

 

[Enter_Bluey]

I mean tbh

"That is to say: If there is a hierarchy of 1-A layers, each of which operates within the same framework, with the same "algorithm" dictating the difference between them, a High 1-A character would transcend the framework entirely, and instead operate on a different, higher hierarchy, governed by another, likewise higher algorithm"

I think having an actual hint of a 1A heirarchy or framework would make SVs argument better. The epilogue has no restriction to target size, dimension, etc, beyond comparison. But will it be enough for a different quality now? The argument did go off her viewing Nebula like Nebula encompassed everyone else and became 1A. I really can't tell, since what gets accepted on here and what not surprises me like all the time so...she may remain the same tho. She's dodged system revisions like 2-3 times now

 

[SweetDao]

I think as long as someone can genuinely prove something is 1-A beside SV, you could make a case, ig.

 

[Enter_Bluey]

She would be beyond comparison of that baseline 1A individual, the high 1A could've maybe been a "possibly", or maybe it'll become a possibly now. The more I look into it tho, it helps to have the making of a heirarchy for sure

Also I noticed Nebula profile was made

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Nebula has had a profile since the High 1-A thread passed, you're super late lol.

About High 1-A, never really cared too much for it, I turn my brain off after 1-A, but if it comes to it I would personally downgrade the cast, though honestly it's not a priority for me, would rather get everything else through first, also working on a CRT for another verse. But yea knock yourselves out if you want to.

Think I might soon pester some staff to look at my Polaris calc, so I can post the speed thread.

 

[Dereck03]

PEAK

Also, why is kuro on her base form instead of her true form? kek

 

[Noneless21]

PEAK

Also, why is kuro on her base form instead of her true form? kek

yeah the artist had a different idea since in WN, Kuro is in her black Shiro form

still peak tho

 

[Dereck03]

Lmao, author's notes are truly smth else.

 

[Noneless21]

it'll get a lot more out of pocket later down the line with actual original characters living there 24/7

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

So, Magnawell weighs 200 billion tons, not that far off from what I calculated.

If Stellar lighting strength doesn't work out, seems the current ratings would still stick.

 

[Noneless21]

the author may or may not have been lurking here or in the server and I have no way to proof it but I'm just so sure he is

 

[Enter_Bluey]

I still remember isis just casually punching him in the air

Also yeah I was very late on the Nebula profile..

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

CRT on Trinia, just want to update the Trinia blog.

But yea I don't believe Trinia is actually star sized.

 

[Re5yh]

I think I will downgrade Shallow Vernal to tier 4-A at peak

 

[Legacy30]

Hey, it's the troll who copypastes arguments from other people and got banned from fandom because of it. Why'd you delete the shitpost you made in this thread?

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Not sure if serious or not but

She started at 5-B, everything above has just been a bonus, this is a slice of life series, nobody expected it to go this far, and pretty sure a lot of the supporters here are amused by the characters opness more than anything. I am just here for the sugar.

If serious though you should start the downgrade a little higher seeing as Shiro can create parallel timelines and all...

 

[Noneless21]

also, why are you here? Like, did you read this and like it? Or you're here because I was partially responsible in your temporary ban?

 

[Legacy30]

You know vandalism can get you banned too, considering you did it before?

 

[Re5yh]

Check my contributions on my fandom account

 

[Re5yh]

I didnt vandalism, i inspected it

 

[Re5yh]

Well, im actually sorry that i plagiarized a lot of stuff from your site and I wont do it ever again. And i would stop lying ever again.
Also, please be correct that its plagiarizm, not vandalism.

 

[Orioreeem]

Wtf am i reading above?