ShinMaximillion
Username Only- 605
- 1,743
Still curious about what warning was being talked about on Mbpoops. What warning bro?
x2
x2
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Honkai: Star Rail Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Giannysmag
- Start date
- 1,083
- 366
if there was one, im surprised it was about that and not the emanator post that was a worse offender
Zanesucksatlife
Any/All- 1,171
- 1,201
What you're arguing for is that they can be Imaginary spaces those small little areas?
Ok.. how does that work?
HSR is showing how much it's contradicting HI3 right now
Not too mention, the idea of imaginary space hasn't even been brought up in HSR yet
So why we assuming or even headcanoning that it exists when we don't know yet?
Just because HI3 has it? That is a bad argument to be made.
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Never said this actually. I just said persona has a more digestible story and themes than amphoreus i dont need to know all DDS/SMT/SH/PERSONA/Catherine fullbody terminology to enjoy one part of the franchise
This honestly makes Honkai’s storytelling and writing worst. We know persona takes place chronologically the games are just self contained which is better because it doesnt **** up the cosmology. Honkai is constantly contradicting its own cosmology and we can see that by the fact you mfs keep trying to argue the hi3 tree is the 4D universe AFTER WE MADE A CRT CLARIFYING THE 2. Megaten does a better job at presenting its cosmology because the games dont blatantly contradict eachother like hoyo does its that simple its like ZZZ and genshin, sure they’re apart of the cosmology but they dont contradict already established parts of the cosmology unlike hsr so yea i would say megaten is better than honkai i didnt say that before but now that im being forced to argue which is better yes megaten does a far better job at not contradicting its cosmology than hoyo
Gave a half baked response earlier cus job can you tell me what my warning was now?
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
And just so you dont take this out of context ill give you an example
mementos doesnt contradict the Tv world or tartarus’ existence it’s its own thing and none of them contradict eachother the only simularities they have are the collective unconcious
The imaginary tree theory contradicts the already established Hi3 imaginary tree by positing the imaginary tree is the physical universe (reality) while the hi3 tree is EXPLICITLY higher dimensional it is up to US to differentiate the 2 which shouldnt be how it works the verse should explain itself the different between reality and imaginary which they did very well in Hi3 but then Hsr (the sequel) contradicted it THATS A BIG ISSUE IN WRITING. Zzz and genshin dont have these problems because they are more self contained than hsr and hi3 which is why you see no one complaining abt genshin or zzz contradicting the tree and sea unlike hsr.
- 843
- 1,451
It actually has various inconsistencies with it being Imaginary Space.
1. They're distinguished as Unknown Void Domains, or Imaginary Barriers. Specifically areas where there's a lot of raw imaginary energy. They're never called Imaginary Space.
2. We never see the aeons in these gaps despite them existing in Imaginary Space.
3. Visually not consistent with what's presented in Chapter 25-Ex of Honkai Impact.
4. A character with higher dimensional existence like Durandal would be able to access the Tree through these gaps if they were Imaginary Space, as they'd be able to move on coordinates 4D to 10D. (11D is a time dimension). This is also never shown.
5. Distance is never said or shown to be constantly shifting in these domains of Imaginary Energy, like it should be in all spaces greater than 4th Dimensionality.
The thing that matches up, destroying everything that enters, is a feature of large amounts of raw Imaginary Energy, as seen in Imaginary Space... or as a side effect of Imaginary Energy leaving from Imaginary Bleed, this is confirmed by Chapter 17 of Hi3. I genuinely just think that these areas are where reality is at its weakest and Imaginary Bleed is causing vast amounts of Imaginary Energy to leak in.
- 2,915
- 2,311
Where do I even start…
Hiiighly Recommend SMT V Vengeance. Its Goated
Though reminder, SMT is actually difficult and doesn't hold your hand.
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Yea my friend told me to get it ill prolly get it soon and SMT 3 nocturne cause it goes on sale a lot
- 1,931
- 1,893
Decoration room 2.7 event
- 1,931
- 1,893
The way Aha escaping the jobless allegations
- 8,675
- 3,155
Bet my salary is higher than himThe way Aha escaping the jobless allegations
- 1,931
- 1,893
Nah lil bro, no hoyoscaller can beat this allegations✌
- 5,386
- 2,832
This gotta be the most nothingburger reply cause the only instance HSR retconned HI3 is when it said the Tree is unrivaled and that's literally it, they are the same Imaginary Tree and they don't contradict each other just because 1 said attribute isn't shown on the latter
- 5,386
- 2,832
Monthly wages for my country is 1.1k dollars and I still think I'm cooked one way or anotherNah lil bro, no hoyoscaller can beat this allegations✌
- 5,592
- 6,891
This response is basically “nuuh”.
- 7,332
- 6,798
Istaroth plot hax when silver wolf just edits the plot in her favor
- 1,281
- 1,139
Istaroth plot hax when silver wolf just edits the plot in her favor
- 1,281
- 1,139
Don't know where I should ask this, so I'll ask here
Should Durandal's page be renamed to Durandal (Honkai Impact 3rd)?
Should Durandal's page be renamed to Durandal (Honkai Impact 3rd)?
- 7,332
- 6,798
Yea but you can also name it by her actual name Bianka Ataegina or Kiana Kaslana cuz shes original kiana in hi3 (dont)
- 5,886
- 3,560
Rename her to Bianka Ataegina but have Durandal (Honkai Impact 3rd) that redirects to her page
- 5,592
- 6,891
Also, by the way. I don’t even fully believe IX is properly non-existent (i.e that it even has NEP1). To me it genuinely seems that it is being posited as a “Void” in a very similar fashion to how SoQ and IS are posited as “Voids”, which is to say IX realistically is js a chaotic space with negative entropy/a lowest-energy space that cannot possess definable materiality. Which, uh, isn’t actually NEP at all, as previously established.
Not that I’m actually planning on making a CRT on this without extensive elaboration in later patches, it’s still possible my theory can be wrong.
Not that I’m actually planning on making a CRT on this without extensive elaboration in later patches, it’s still possible my theory can be wrong.
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Please go read nova’s staff crt and come back i dont even need to respond to this it speaks for itself.
Are Aeons getting kicked out of Tier 1? (Staff Version)
(Permission granted by Rainaaaaaa) So. Following that horrid thread (7 pages in 12 hours), I think it's pretty much a given that this should be redone in a more civil fashion. As a preface, I'll genuinely be using similar arguments as the last thread, but I'll also be adding another section...
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Because surely the same imaginary tree that exists outside of reality, is higher dimensional, infinitely transfinite and CONTAINS infinite universes.. is the universe… so again like i and many others have said its either the universe is 11D or the cosmology is 4D and ive talked to knowledgeable people abt this and it can only be the latter which im totally fine with btw if you mfs wanna keep saying they’re the same
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Istaroth plot hax when silver wolf just edits the plot in her favor
Can we actually get plot manip from this or just some enhanced fate manip
- 1,931
- 1,893
Ix should stay, it's pretty blatant stated to be nothingness and represent as other side of coin of existence.
If you ask about imaginary space then yeah it's vague tbh to me, like dudu statement about Imaginary space being absolute nothingness, but what she refer literally only spesific region of IS that she recently passed, not it's the entirety which is weird. To me it just dimensionless place which lack of any structure.
Meanwhile SoQ is the true one representing chaotic
- 5,592
- 6,891
Prolly js resistance to Precognition/Clairvoyance
- 5,592
- 6,891
The other side of existence here is explicitly negative entropy. I.e very low energy. It's the same shit told to us in regards to Imaginary Space; using buzzwords like "nothingness" won't cut it here. But whatever, I already said I wasn't planning on making a thread.
Also "Existence" here isn't properly "Being" rather than js Physicality/Reality
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Are you sure the tree that doesnt exist in reality, doesnt have the same properties as reality, already has infinite branches (timelines that are stretched to infinity) and rivals the 11D soq is just the physical (4D) universe (aka REALITY)… are you sure this doesnt get contradicted by herta’s anaology?
- 1,931
- 1,893
I mean, it's pretty blatant IM2 feats, and "script" Here refer to elio script
Therefore it just mention her emanator power could pontentially intervene with finality script, which also perhaps one of reason elio suggest her not to really use that power aside from the effect on herself.
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
NEP welt einstein and tesla because they are anti entropy
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Im completely fine with nuking the verse to 2-C btw since you mfs wanna keep arguing ts thats already been/being addressed like we’ve made 2 whole crts clarifying the differences between the 2 and you’re still saying they’re the same
- 5,592
- 6,891
Save us Genshin
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Genshin is unsurprisingly more consistant than hsr which in the crt i linked literally goes over how hsr not only contradicts the already established cosmology but contradicts itself
but my reading comprehension ig
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
What was my warning btw
Mbpoops
He/Him- 8,608
- 7,893
Are Aeons getting kicked out of Tier 1? (Staff Version)
(Permission granted by Rainaaaaaa) So. Following that horrid thread (7 pages in 12 hours), I think it's pretty much a given that this should be redone in a more civil fashion. As a preface, I'll genuinely be using similar arguments as the last thread, but I'll also be adding another section...
- 5,886
- 3,560
Su did say that there are an infinite amount of timelines / possibilities that the second key can observe
- 299
- 112
Doesn't that imply an infinite number of leaves? And as far as I know, the size of a leaf isn't as vast as the universe. I'm not talking about leaves; I'm talking about branches.
Similar threads
