• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Genshin Impact Discussion Thread

This blog I made earlier explained it pretty well about those type of calc, the original calc which is the one I'm pretty sure you get the inspiration from is straight up wrong it's crazy how much of a downplay it is
to bad he doesnt scale to it anyways
 
Rhinedottir had the power of the shade before becoming a sinner. All of her creations which are prior to the cataclysm are created from the power of the Ruler of life.

Every sinner prior to their Abyssal power had the power of a shade.
 
Rhinedottir had the power of the shade before becoming a sinner. All of her creations which are prior to the cataclysm are created from the power of the Ruler of life.

Every sinner prior to their Abyssal power had the power of a shade.
Key word: Alchemy, like we see Albedo use it to make Durin a new body, does he use Naberius powers too? Is just another parallel between the Sinners and the Shades like Rerir/Ronova, thats why bro is called "Blasphemy against the Death", Rhine would probably be called "Blasphemy against the Life" and so on
 
I hope they show one of this things in the trailer
  • Durin
  • Wanderer vs Dottore teaser
  • Aether throwing hands at Rerir (Traveler upscale)
 
Key word: Alchemy, like we see Albedo use it to make Durin a new body, does he use Naberius powers too? Is just another parallel between the Sinners and the Shades like Rerir/Ronova, thats why bro is called "Blasphemy against the Death", Rhine would probably be called "Blasphemy against the Life" and so on
She had the power of it, it is in her weapon skin. The sword she wielded have the power of shade was prior to her becoming a sinner or shade for that matter. All her creations were created from her power of the Ruler of life.

Description
A glorious, illusory sword glimmering with the power of "Life" that emerged from the depths of the Ley Lines. It can change its appearance based on the Elemental Type of its wielder. Legend has it that this sword once held the name "Logseims" when it was wielded by a transcendent sinner in an ancient land.
 
She had the power of it, it is in her weapon skin. The sword she wielded have the power of shade was prior to her becoming a sinner or shade for that matter. All her creations were created from her power of the Ruler of life.

Description
A glorious, illusory sword glimmering with the power of "Life" that emerged from the depths of the Ley Lines. It can change its appearance based on the Elemental Type of its wielder. Legend has it that this sword once held the name "Logseims" when it was wielded by a transcendent sinner in an ancient land.
All of them are just paralleling the shades and phanes.
Do you believe Hroptatyr had Phanes' power?

Having the power "Life" Doesn't mean she had Naberius' power before she merged with Naberius. Dendro Element is the element of Life itself, does that mean every dendro element user had the power of Naberius? Of course not.

Raiden have the power of Time because she can stop the time, does that mean she has Istaroth's power? Not necessarily.
 
We don't even know what is that "Power of Reason" means actually, it's just paralleling them not actually have the power of them.
That could be the case however they have capitalized their concepts with quotation marks which always indicated the shades themselves. Venti referred Istaroth as "Time" itself.

And Bakunawa letter also suggest the same.

However, unlike "Gold"'s other creations, its immortality does not stem from the power of "Life," but rather a more transcendent form of Abyssal power that may be beyond even our Order's understanding.
 
However, unlike "Gold"'s other creations, its immortality does not stem from the power of "Life," but rather a more transcendent form of Abyssal power that may be beyond even our Order's understanding.
Art of Khemia literally have the power of Life, of course.
That's why i'm putting this on her profile:
 
Art of Khemia literally have the power of Life, of course.
That's why i'm putting this on her profile:
It has the power of life but not "Life" that is something uniquely to Rhinedottir as per her weapon description. Her weapon was also prior to becoming sinner.

Albedo never capitalized life when talking about Alchemy as evident in his character story but yet he did when referring to Naberius.
 
It has the power of life but not "Life" that is something uniquely to Rhinedottir as per her weapon description. Her weapon was also prior to becoming sinner.

Albedo never capitalized life when talking about Alchemy as evident in his character story but yet he did when referring to Naberius.
Duh? Because they literally want to parallel the sinners to the shades and phanes.
That doesn't mean they ACTUALLY have the power of them.

And theres no reason for Naberius and other shades and phanes to shared their power to these sinners before they become a sinners anyway
 
The Rächer of Solnari pursues you relentlessly and mocks you for seeking nothing more than a joke. However, his attacks are halted by a sudden blast — the Harbinger, Marionette, and her robot Pulonia arrive. Confronted by his old enemy, the Rächer is shocked by the transformation of her creation, now standing as his equal. Even so, he manages to find an opening and binds Pulonia before turning toward you for the killing blow.

Pulonia = 10% rerir

10% rerir is fodder to much of verse, only death authority is saving his ass
 
The Timeline in Genshin Impact:
  1. Old World (More than 6,000+++ years ago. The Original world where Dragon King Nibelung and Seven Sovereigns ruling)
  2. Sky-War (More than 6,000++ Years ago, Heavenly Principles–4 Shades vs Seven Sovereigns)
  3. First Era (still more than 6,000+ Years ago, unified civilizations era like Sal Vindagnyr, Hyperborea, Remuria etc)
  4. The Great War of Vengeance (6,000 years ago, the war triggered by Dragon King Nibelung when he descended in the "Funerary Year")
  5. Archon War (Started more than 3,000+ years ago and ended 2,000 years ago)
  6. Cataclysm (500 years ago)
 
Gets equal opponent to him

Ain't that level


It is literally game saying rerir 10% = pulonia

And sandrone is ranked 7th if you don't know
reading comprehension no actually thinking comprehension is very strong within yu
maybe sandrone is no 7 bcs she herself isnt strong while she can amp pulonia to hell and back
(ty for arlecchino upscale btw)
 
That one NPC is right after all, Dottore is number 2 for absolutely no reason and no feats at all, lmao.
The only one who truly representing their harbinger rank is just Capitano atp.

Sandrone number 7 because of her intelligence and her robot things.
Columbina logically would've been number one if their harbinger rank can be raised or lowered, sadly they can't.

Their rank is simply how important their contribution is within the Fatui.
 
Last edited:
Their rank is simply how important their contribution is within the Fatui.
By this logic Pantalone and Pulcinella would be nº1 and 2
tell me how a corpse is more important than the Major of Snezhnaya and the Richest man alive
That one NPC is right after all, Dottore is number 2 for absolutely no reason and no feats at all, lmao.
The only one who truly representing their harbinger rank is just Capitano atp.
Even if i hate Dottore, he has this:
Columbina logically would've been number one if their harbinger rank can be raised or lowered, sadly they can't.
So we are forgetting the plot of Columbina being weakend (Not only because she spend her power helping the Tsarita, but also because she is unable to reach a deep connection with her moon, which is what gives powers to a moon goddess) thats why i doesnt scale rn to Moon Goddess lvl? most likely the Prime of Columbina would come with the conclusion of Nod Krai's arc (6.3 Boss fight)
 
I wonder if being far away from moon also weakened columbina's 2 brain cells, and after getting her moon she will become like arle 🙃
 
By this logic Pantalone and Pulcinella would be nº1 and 2
tell me how a corpse is more important than the Major of Snezhnaya and the Richest man alive
Look at him, bro's Khaenri'ahn.
And look at Pierro, bros the director even though he's not from Snezhnaya.
Being hailed from Snezhnaya doesn't make you above someones from other regions.

Khaenri'ahns is just that special on Tsaritsa's eyes.
Even if i hate Dottore, he has this:
That's just recent events, but how about the moment he got recruited in the past like 500 or 400 years ago? What makes bro number 2 at that moment

Talking about combat capabilities, even Arlecchino stated herself can deal with Dottore. Like i can guarantee you, that if Dottore doesn't exist, Arlecchino would be the number 2.

Tsaritsa is just loved Khaenri'ahns way too much.
So we are forgetting the plot of Columbina being weakend (Not only because she spend her power helping the Tsarita, but also because she is unable to reach a deep connection with her moon, which is what gives powers to a moon goddess) thats why i doesnt scale rn to Moon Goddess lvl? most likely the Prime of Columbina would come with the conclusion of Nod Krai's arc (6.3 Boss fight)
Capitano also getting weakened overtime, and Columbina will get stronger (And i even doubt she will be the number one if she's still in the fatui when she got all of her powers back because that one npc already said the number one cannot be replaced)
 
That's just recent events, but how about the moment he got recruited in the past like 500 or 400 years ago? What makes bro number 2 at that moment.
According to scaramouche story.

Jester found scaramouche around 400 years ago and pursued to join fatui, and then asked dottore to do research on it, and it was mentioned scara as a creation of electro Archon was all the more special

And then dottore created his own segments using scara as blueprint for his segment's base

That might be the reason he was ranked 2 at the time


Also imo pirro is ranked 10th, there are total 11 harbingers including pierro, and 11 ranks
 
Also imo pirro is ranked 10th, there are total 11 harbingers including pierro, and 11 ranks
I don't think so, bros never in the harbinger rank to begin with and even if he is that would be too low for someone like Pierro who's Khaenri'ahn, and we know all Khaenri'ahn is gigachad. Even Guthred is comparable to Capitano 500 years ago.
 
People still can't accept that Simulanka is the best summer event of all time while that place literally teasing Natlan and Nod-Krai.

  1. The 3 Goddesses of Simulanka = A , B, and M = The Three Moon Sister
  2. Albizzi, Boborano, Cappet = Aberewaa, Bosmtwe, Cuxtal. (Mentioned by Capitano)
  3. Princess Cimest = Mavuika
  4. Faurobert = Capitano
  5. The Jumping Contest = The Pilgrimage
  6. Black Dragon = Durin = Nibelung = Gosoythoth
  7. Esnoire the Light House Keeper = Lightkeepers + Kuuvaki
  8. "Towards the Lighthouse, or Far Away" = New Moon = Columbina
 
Last edited:
Also imo pirro is ranked 10th, there are total 11 harbingers including pierro, and 11 ranks
He isn't bro..... no one is currently at rank 10, Genshin official merch also shows this. You could argue either Diluc dad or Crucabena was the 10th harbinger. Crucabena may have been 4th.
 
Look at him, bro's Khaenri'ahn.
And look at Pierro, bros the director even though he's not from Snezhnaya.
Being hailed from Snezhnaya doesn't make you above someones from other regions.

Khaenri'ahns is just that special on Tsaritsa's eyes.
So its just about contribution when you said so because how is an angry woman (Signora) more important than the richest man alive? A mistreating woman (Cruca) more important than the major of the city your building the Fatuis with and a god's creation?
That's just recent events, but how about the moment he got recruited in the past like 500 or 400 years ago? What makes bro number 2 at that moment
In recent time it would be harder to maintain an ranking since there would be more competition and in any case he would had been weaker since, unless proven otherwise a character would always grew in strength has time pass, like its common sense a baby is weaker than a young adult (Yeah, im making that comparasion, because it is stated Omega, the only alive fragment of Dottore, it at the prime of his life)
Talking about combat capabilities, even Arlecchino stated herself can deal with Dottore
She would get low diffed by Shouki no Kami ngl "Hoyo lend me the moon powers, this is weakend Hydro Traveler", lets not even talk about the fact that she isnt top 3 because she aint even God lvl, and when i say god im talking about important strong god, not god damn Havria, by this reasoning Arle should be Archon lvl because of this voice line
ll I can say is this... If we are forced to be at odds one day, I will raise my weapon against her without hesitation (Arle about the Tsarita)
Like i can guarantee you, that if Dottore doesn't exist, Arlecchino would be the number 2.
So your saying either the Moon Goddess or an Archon's equals are weaker than Arle? weak used to be belieable
Capitano also getting weakened overtime
He still had the rank 1 status because he is the only Harbinger equal to an archon, even when weakend, so yeah, this just means weakend capi > Prime Dottore
Columbina will get stronger
I dout Columbina would come back to the fatui anyways, making the rankign system in her invalid (Like Wanderer case) and rank 1 is untouched because of respect
Also imo pirro is ranked 10th, there are total 11 harbingers including pierro, and 11 ranks
There a theory saying there was no 10th harbinger in the rankings to begin, like in early stages of the game the CN version said "The 11th Harbingers" like the numbers of fatuis in that group, but probably got recotnned or idk, probably was Creepus
 
There a theory saying there was no 10th harbinger in the rankings to begin, like in early stages of the game the CN version said "The 11th Harbingers" like the numbers of fatuis in that group, but probably got recotnned or idk, probably was Creepus
there is an actual 10th harbringer (or was), It most likely died or left prior to game events.
 
Back
Top