- 1,071
- 40
A duel inside an abandoned city.
Who would win and why?
Who would win and why?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Esdeath vs Tier Harribel
- Thread starter Notadeadguy
- Start date
-
- Tags
- esdeath tier harribel
- Status
- 2,870
- 73
Esdeath wins due to hax like time stop + she can just freeze all of halibels water attacks rendering them useless.And has some good range attacks herself.
- 2,870
- 73
I said freeze her water attacks read....
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #6
Actually I think she only remelts the ice into waterbut that's about it. Overall Harribel can be incapacitated by being frozen so she can't necessarily freeze everything
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #8
Except when she was frozen by Hitsugaya and one of her allies literally had to break the ice to get her out.
- 2,870
- 73
Sighs no she didnt Rukia is easily above Hitsugaya in terms of Ice manipulation she has absolute zero.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #11
CHILLVIBEZZ said:
I'm talking about their fight in the anime.... Remember?
Anyway if she can be frozen by Hitsugaya, then it's obvious Harribel can't handle absolute zero
- 2,870
- 73
Esdeath is much faster than Halibel try again she can easily dodge her attacks and use time stop thus rendering Halibel immobile and finishing her off then.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #15
We're all just going under the assumption she can and that she can hit him.Dbzgoku20 said:
Otherwise this fight would be impossible
And Chill does raise some good points
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #17
But what about the time stop?Dbzgoku20 said:
You seem to be ignoring that factor
- 137
- 5
does not matter. soul crush will kill her right away.
soul crush is always on so even if it just take 1 second for esdeath to stop time its to late. soul crush is on and her soul crush is city level. and esdeath is just Building level.
and esdeath will not use time stop right away. she does not fight like that.
soul crush is always on so even if it just take 1 second for esdeath to stop time its to late. soul crush is on and her soul crush is city level. and esdeath is just Building level.
and esdeath will not use time stop right away. she does not fight like that.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #20
Kamiyasha is right and how would you know if Harribel would use Soul Crush first?
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #22
Um about that...Dbzgoku20 said:
I don't see any Soul Crush in her profile
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #24
Well then there's a hole in your argumentDbzgoku20 said:
- 2,870
- 73
If that were actually true im pretty sure soul crush shouldve worked on Ichigos classmates but either way its no valid argument to begin with
- 1,565
- 197
1: Soul Crush isn't a legit argument, If we start to use that then Aizen Solos every verse of "living beings".
2: Arguments like soul crush (Bleach) or genjutsu working on someone without chakra network (Naruto) or logia intangibility (One piece) aren't valid arguments.
3: Esdeath has Massively Hypersonic reactions (Mach 200 i believe). She would be capable of react easily to her attacks.
4: It's a Draw due to the fact that esdeath isn't fast enough to fight Halibel, and Halibel isn't incapable of landing a blow on Esdeath due to her speed reaction.
Or it's a win to Esdeath due to the Time Stop.
2: Arguments like soul crush (Bleach) or genjutsu working on someone without chakra network (Naruto) or logia intangibility (One piece) aren't valid arguments.
3: Esdeath has Massively Hypersonic reactions (Mach 200 i believe). She would be capable of react easily to her attacks.
4: It's a Draw due to the fact that esdeath isn't fast enough to fight Halibel, and Halibel isn't incapable of landing a blow on Esdeath due to her speed reaction.
Or it's a win to Esdeath due to the Time Stop.
- 2,870
- 73
False one of them even mentioned the fact that they were sensing immense power from aizen and nothing from ichigo.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #30
And that's the hole in your argument.Dbzgoku20 said:
Harribel wouldn't necessarily use her soul crush to immediately crush Esdeath, I believe she would need to do her Ressurection to do that, and I should ask you this.
What's the exact range of Soul Crush? Is it only up close, several meters? I doubt that it would put Esdeath down so easily. Plus in that split second Esdeath would pull off the Time stop, then the Soul Crush wouldn't exactly go off.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #32
And?Dbzgoku20 said:
- 2,870
- 73
Its not something automatic at all to begin with you just disproved yourself though i dont even know why im bothering with this nonsense since its generally disregarded given that its just some cop out argument since ever.
- 1,071
- 40
- Thread starter
- #36
So everyone but you agrees that Soul Crush would win.
Well since its nigh unanimous then we won't factor soul crush.
Because
1. It's not automatic
2. It's really not an attack
3. Those Hollows you mentioned were just fodder so it's obvious they'd die
Well since its nigh unanimous then we won't factor soul crush.
Because
1. It's not automatic
2. It's really not an attack
3. Those Hollows you mentioned were just fodder so it's obvious they'd die
- 11,444
- 1,997
The only real argument I can make for Harribel here is that her flight ability far exceeds Esdeath's. What's stopping her from simply raining Cero's from above? All of Esdeath's projectile attacks are virtually worthless against Harribel thanks to Hirviendo, and one good Cero hit will easily knock the general out. Considering the fact that Ichigo had trouble dodging Ulquiorra's Stage One Cero Oscuras, what stops Harribel from doing the same to Esdeath?
- 2,773
- 126
Soul Crush is same as Conqueror's Haki. Only works on fodders, we shouldn't use it for battle
- Status
