• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Dragon Ball: Soul Manipulation Reboot.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
3,555
Reaction score
5,147
Hello all, this CRT will be going over the souls in dragon ball. This is an overhaul from the last thread, which was missing information. This is a thread aiming to fix that and cause as least confusion as possible.


Nature of Souls





Soul Manipulation



Ki Manipulation Proposals

  • Soul Manipulation
Splitting, Clones, Sealing, Teleportation, Fusionism negation, Fusionism.

  • Ectoplasm Manipulation
Ki being Spiritual Energy that also forms from your soul, which can be manipulated into attacks. Ki also being, life energy and the soul.




Agree:

Neutral:

Disagree:
 
Oh boy I can't wait for someone to stonewall this for the next 20 pages. Good work though.
 
Allat and we still don't have a Gomah profile

Looks fine, it's definitely an improvement from Sword's thread, I don't mean that in a rude way though
 
Soul Manipulation
I've at least got to return this human's body
This seems to imply that Kami Sama soul was not drawn out by Mafuba, but that Kami Sama himself got out of the Human Body as a soul so he (the Human Body) is not sealed alongside him (Kami Sama's soul). From what I see and what I remember since I read DB, it feels more like:

1. Piccolo tries to seal Kami-sama, sealing the body he is in
2. Kami-sama realizes of that. He does not want to carry a normal human being in the problem between "gods", so he leaves the body
3. The Mafuba keeps targeting just Kami-sama (who now is a Soul), sealing it.

So, it's not the actual Ki wave taking out Kami-sama's soul, but Kami-sama leaving the body and the Mafuba sealing it.

I don't have much comment on the rest, but I think it should be explained –similar to the "attack types" or "Variation types", wherever it fits better– in an specific tabber, not in general abilities. As I don't think all Ki users from DB Muten Roshi to Raditz to Frieza have actual soul manipulation for every and any ki blast. Specially those that have not trained to obtain spirit control nor similar abilities
 
I don't have much comment on the rest, but I think it should be explained –similar to the "attack types" or "Variation types", wherever it fits better– in an specific tabber, not in general abilities. As I don't think all Ki users from DB Muten Roshi to Raditz to Frieza have actual soul manipulation for every and any ki blast. Specially those that have not trained to obtain spirit control nor similar abilities
Agree, but shouldn't general Ki Users could still have Limited Soul Manipulation and/or Limited Ectoplasma Manipulation, as Ki = Spirit by nature.
 
I don't have much comment on the rest, but I think it should be explained –similar to the "attack types" or "Variation types", wherever it fits better– in an specific tabber, not in general abilities. As I don't think all Ki users from DB Muten Roshi to Raditz to Frieza have actual soul manipulation for every and any ki blast. Specially those that have not trained to obtain spirit control nor similar abilities
If Ki is equivalent to the soul then I believe all Ki users would qualify for Soul Manipulation given it is defined as '...is the ability to interact with one's soul or the souls of others.' Which suggests that the ability to manipulate your own soul's energy does constitute as Soul Manipulation.

That doesn't suddenly mean the characters can do anything under the umbrella of the ability. Freeza, for example, does not have clones, teleportation, fusion, etc. But he is still manipulating his spirit power to project it as energy blasts, reinforce his body, and so on. The extent of a character's abilities would vary.

I agree that it may be possible to add to the Ki Manipulation page a section for levels of Spirit Control which can cover the different kinds of Soul Manipulation ranging from Basic (The universal ability to control Ki) to more advanced abilities listed in the OP.
 
Those in afterlife has Ki. If they use so much Ki, aren't they suppose to disappear as Ki = Soul etc?

Isn't it more like even Souls can have Ki rather than both being the same?
 
Those in afterlife has Ki. If they use so much Ki, aren't they suppose to disappear as Ki = Soul etc?

Isn't it more like even Souls can have Ki rather than both being the same?
Ki is ur spiritual essence. Reinforcing your body with ki = spiritual barrier
 
Those in afterlife has Ki. If they use so much Ki, aren't they suppose to disappear as Ki = Soul etc?

Isn't it more like even Souls can have Ki rather than both being the same?
There isn't an example of anyone using up all of their Ki while dead. We do know, however, that if Vegeta were killed while already dead he would cease to exist.

So in theory if someone were to expend all of their Ki while dead they would cease to exist. Essentially if Vegeta used Final Explosion against Kid Buu that would likely have destroyed his soul. As he is killing himself a second time.
 
In theory if Soul = Ki.

I mean they are obviously connected but not necessarily the same.
You haven't explained why they wouldn't necessarily be the same. You raised a hypothetical (that does not exist in the franchise as far as I know) so I responded with the realistic result (if someone used up all their Ki they would cease to exist because we already know if you die a second time your soul is destroyed).

If you have an argument for why you believe they are not 'necessarily the same' then please raise it so someone can consider it properly.
 
I agree with this

Also mlp's magic and RWBY's Aura should also be self Soul Manipulation for similar reasons. Hell any power system that's life energy/spiritual powers/manifestations of the soul should be self soul Manipulation
 
Soul Manipulation

Alright, having looked over the OP, I can get behind Self Soul/Soul Manipulation aspects of Ki Manipulation in Dragon Ball and agree with it for now unless someone provides proper counter arguments.

Ectoplasm Manipulation
I guess it's fine, based on the fact that our current definition it could work

However, I'll half to note my gripe with Ectoplasm Manipulation. For those unaware, this power was and still is on the chopping block because our current Ectoplasm Manipulation page does not properly define it as it should, thus its outdated. Being spiritual energy or a soul/spirit/ghost doesn't inherently give you ectoplasm manipulation because the power is defined by how the verse treats it and thus the verse has to establish the type of energy/substance exists and what its properties do.

As you provided, Dragon Ball treats it's spirits as having Ki/Chi, and doesn't actually define them as beings of ectoplasm. A common example of this type of energy/substance manipulation would be Ghost Busters, in which the ghosts are stated to be ectoplasm/ghosts, they leave behind residual energy and when one phased through a character, he completely covered him in slime (Ectoplasm). Another example is Danny Phantom, the ghosts bodies are made up of a substance known as ectoplasm which is a sticky slime substance that can be manipulated in several ways, constructed from their consciousness and ghost energy (both incorporeal).

Several profiles have Ectoplasm Manipulation but don't have a description because those verses don't actually describe their spirits/ghosts as having it. People just think since it's a spirit/ghost and having energy, it can have ectoplasm but that's not the case. Now yes, by it's current description, Dragon Ball could potentially apply (because spirit energy) but as I've stated, our Ectoplasm Manipulation page is outdated and verses that simply have the power without actually defining it or having it established need it removed. I don't know if I missed it but I saw no mention of the substance/energy of ectoplasm in the OP. Ki may have the spirit aspect but it's not ectoplasm going off the OP, it's just the energy of the verse with spiritual attributes.

Edit: I checked the previous thread that used Gotanks Ghost Kamakazi attack as evidence but it described it as "ectoplasm like" not actually ectoplasm fundamentally. It doesn't explain it, it just based it of ki having some spiritual attributes. I'll bold this portion so people can understand. I only agree (right now at least) with the addition because it fits in the current description in some capacity. However this ability is outdated and needs an overhaul as it's current doesn't properly define it because not every verse describes it and some don't even have it.
 
The spirit they refer to is Ki. The way spirit is written is スピリット here. It's not necessarily spiritual. It can refer to any type of "spirit". Will, Soul, Life energy etc.

Though Vegeta calls スピリット as soul and life energy, so it's fine regardless ig.
Now yes, by it's current description, Dragon Ball could potentially apply (because spirit energy)
It doesn't say "spirit energy" but just spirit there.
 
ghost in DB are deaper than soul
Peak, make a CRT about it.

Actually in Toei ki can affect ghost
Tbh, I have a hard time remembering the ghosts from Dragon ball, All I remember is the time when Goku was in hell, and a row of ghosts were waiting in line to go to heaven, and the filler episode when the random OP girl with plot manipulation, and a ghost appeared, where they created a "ball of all the delicious things imaginable through fourth wall breaking only to have Beerus Hakai the ghost.
 
Soul Manipulation

Alright, having looked over the OP, I can get behind Self Soul/Soul Manipulation aspects of Ki Manipulation in Dragon Ball and agree with it for now unless someone provides proper counter arguments.

Ectoplasm Manipulation
I guess it's fine, based on the fact that our current definition it could work

However, I'll half to note my gripe with Ectoplasm Manipulation. For those unaware, this power was and still is on the chopping block because our current Ectoplasm Manipulation page does not properly define it as it should, thus its outdated. Being spiritual energy or a soul/spirit/ghost doesn't inherently give you ectoplasm manipulation because the power is defined by how the verse treats it and thus the verse has to establish the type of energy/substance exists and what its properties do.

As you provided, Dragon Ball treats it's spirits as having Ki/Chi, and doesn't actually define them as beings of ectoplasm. A common example of this type of energy/substance manipulation would be Ghost Busters, in which the ghosts are stated to be ectoplasm/ghosts, they leave behind residual energy and when one phased through a character, he completely covered him in slime (Ectoplasm). Another example is Danny Phantom, the ghosts bodies are made up of a substance known as ectoplasm which is a sticky slime substance that can be manipulated in several ways, constructed from their consciousness and ghost energy (both incorporeal).

Several profiles have Ectoplasm Manipulation but don't have a description because those verses don't actually describe their spirits/ghosts as having it. People just think since it's a spirit/ghost and having energy, it can have ectoplasm but that's not the case. Now yes, by it's current description, Dragon Ball could potentially apply (because spirit energy) but as I've stated, our Ectoplasm Manipulation page is outdated and verses that simply have the power without actually defining it or having it established need it removed. I don't know if I missed it but I saw no mention of the substance/energy of ectoplasm in the OP. Ki may have the spirit aspect but it's not ectoplasm going off the OP, it's just the energy of the verse with spiritual attributes.

Edit: I checked the previous thread that used Gotanks Ghost Kamakazi attack as evidence but it described it as "ectoplasm like" not actually ectoplasm fundamentally. It doesn't explain it, it just based it of ki having some spiritual attributes. I'll bold this portion so people can understand. I only agree (right now at least) with the addition because it fits in the current description in some capacity. However this ability is outdated and needs an overhaul as it's current doesn't properly define it because not every verse describes it and some don't even have it.
Thanks for the insight, well if this does get accepted and the standards change later for ectoplasm, DB can get an overhaul for that specific ability if it does not meet the correct standards.
 
I agree with much of the things LordGriffin said, and agree with Stefanno that limited things related to Soul and Ectoplasm seem on board.
Yeah, Ki users in general would get self soul manipulation like I described, and soul manipulation will be added to the Ki page for more advanced users too, and just a general mechanic of ki itself. Obviously the specific abilities won't apply to every user because it depends, but it is also just more proof for ki itself that it can interact with the soul in one way or another. Something more like, "advanced ki users have the potential to use x abilities".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top