Does Godzilla in hell Godzilla scale to outerversal?

[cringebaby2]

So I’ve heard some say that Godzilla in hell (GIH) is outer and killed god and Yog-Sothoth. And that GIH threatened all of IDW. As confirmed by tweets made by the writers.
But then I’ve heard Godzilla still isn’t Outer.
So I thought I’d ask.

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

He killed A Yog-Sothoth.

Most of the issues when it comes to people scaling is that they think they can just composite everything. Oh, Random-God Insert from this series is Tier 0? Then that must mean in this comic Random-God Insert is also Tier 0.

It's ridiculous.

 

[CosmicWreck]

Marvel's omniverse contains all of fiction.

DC's omniverse contains all of fiction.

SCP Foundation baseline universe views both universes as fictional.

SCP solos all of fiction.

These kind of statements happen all the time and they are all equally meaningless as the writers cannot possibly have the rights of fictional mediums outside their control which is what such definitions imply and even in this case, with characters that are part of the public domain like Lovecraft's works, when used by other authors it's quite clear that the characters are quite limited in power compared to the originals as their portrayals are naturally limited by the writer's own understanding of the works.

An example of this occurring is in Alan Moore's Providence, where the outer gods were depicted as being much weaker than they were in Lovecraft's original stories.

You can read this page which is where we dip a bit into why cross-scaling by statements like these don't make sense though surprisingly we never addressed it anywhere else.

 

[Confluctor]

So I’ve heard some say that Godzilla in hell (GIH) is outer and killed god and Yog-Sothoth. And that GIH threatened all of IDW. As confirmed by tweets made by the writers.
But then I’ve heard Godzilla still isn’t Outer.
So I thought I’d ask.

Nah, low 2c at best

 

[XXKINGXX69]

DC's omniverse contains all of fiction.

Facts

 

[CosmicWreck]

Facts

Yes, yes, I may be misremembering a quote of DC explaining how the multiverse works.

Even without that, the point is scaling between communities on vague statements is ill advised.

 

[cringebaby2]

He killed A Yog-Sothoth.

Most of the issues when it comes to people scaling is that they think they can just composite everything. Oh, Random-God Insert from this series is Tier 0? Then that must mean in this comic Random-God Insert is also Tier 0.

It's ridiculous.

So basically Gfans over stating

 

[TheGreatJedi13]

He killed A Yog-Sothoth.

Most of the issues when it comes to people scaling is that they think they can just composite everything. Oh, Random-God Insert from this series is Tier 0? Then that must mean in this comic Random-God Insert is also Tier 0.

It's ridiculous.

drats foiled again into trying to push my verse to tier 0

but yeah those are common its basically like saying goku is tier 1 because of Ergenverse Chi/Qi

 

[Planck69]

drats foiled again into trying to push my verse to tier 0

but yeah those are common its basically like saying goku is tier 1 because of Ergenverse Chi/Qi

Just a correction, Qi in Ergenverse ain't actually Tier 1, Essences/Daos are.

That said, it'd be similar to saying Chinese medicine is 1-A+ cause that one dude in the Cthulhu Mythos got so stoned, he ended up ascending through infinite layers of 1-A realms.

 

[Jibz]

i love how he wasn't given a name at all in the entire story.